(Possible spoilers) New Mane 6 for Season 5?

[Grumpy Enchantress 586]

Doesn't it seem like the show is building to a new mane 6? In all of the key episodes they've taught other ponies about their elements. Do you think it's possible that they're all going to be replaced in Season 5? (Possibly because all the other Mane 6 are princesses and too busy for the elements and regular episodes of the show as implied with the background ponies in all the key episodes.) 

 

So far the replacements would be Cocoa Pommel, Spitfire, and Cheese Sandwich. If you do buy the theory, any thoughts on who the other 3 might be? 

 

[An Old Head 4,815]

I... find this extremely unlikely. It'd work well as a fan theory, but if our beloved current Mane 6 were ever replaced, I'd stop watching the show. I mean, Cheese Sandwich is awesome and all, as are the other two, but Hasbro would be out of their minds to chuck the show away like that.

 

For now, let's assume that the other 3 ?'s belong to whoever Tenderhoof is (from Simple Ways), a pony that Fluttershy meets from the Breezies episode, and... let's throw some embodiment of Starswirl in there for Twilight

[Moved to Elsewhere 11,330]

I find this unlikely considering that one of them is voiced by a celebrity who wouldn't do the show regularly.

[Mywas 687]

Doubt it. even the older Generations stayed true to its main characters.

[duidamasterXD 9,626]

Naw, I think the current storyline involves the Mane Six inspiring others to live out their respective elements and that's why we have such clear parallels. There's no real indication that they're intending to change casts, and I'm frankly happy for that.

[ghostfacekiller39 23,860]

I think Hasbro knows what kind of shitstorm they'd be facing if they did that.

 

They only care about the money. That's clear. If they did a whole new line up, then so many people would stop buying stuff from them on top of having to spend extra money producing new toys.

 

They'd lose money, and they know that.

 

So nahh. I think the mane 6 right now is pretty cemented in place

[Grumpy Enchantress 586]

I find this unlikely considering that one of them is voiced by a celebrity who wouldn't do the show regularly.

How do you know he wouldn't? He's friends with Daniel Ingram and was going to do a recurring voice on that awful Star Wars Detours show. (Yes, Star Wars is a bigger franchise but this was just going to be a lame Seth Green show.)

[Jangocoolguy 433]

I think you're overthinking things there, Grumpy

 

The Mane 6 are simply teaching ponies a lesson much as they've always done. The difference is that this time said ponies are very close to their elements or are being rivals to them.

 

Replace the star characters? Are you mad? Just replacing one of them with a different character is tempting the Shark enough as it is, but replacing all of them? Surely you realize how silly that sounds...

[Neon Fire 473]

I think that's a great theory, but I don't think they would do that.  It would be interesting though to have an episode or two with "the new Mane 6"

[Forlong 1,725]

 

And discontinue Princess Twilight and Pinkie Pie toys?  As if!  The mane six were the reasons that the show became popular in the first place, replacing any of them would be a mistake.

[GenderIsAnIllusion 2,177]

I have the feeling Spifire would kill Cheese sandwich while the other one watched....

[Sugar Cube 4,843]

No. The Mane Six would never get replaced, especially by a cast that includes male ponies like Cheese Sandwich. We're four seasons into the show and the Mane Six have always been the focal characters that the audience has come to know and love. Why would there be a need to replace them? Simply put, there is no replacing them.

 

The Mane Six have simply inspired others through their own or elements of harmony. Coco Pommel, Spitfire, and Cheese Sandwich all learned about generosity, loyalty, and laughter in their respective episodes and then proceeded to give our heroes their "keys." This is buildup for the Mane Six, not a step towards replacing them. :/

[Grumpy Enchantress 586]

 

And discontinue Princess Twilight and Pinkie Pie toys?  As if!  The mane six were the reasons that the show became popular in the first place, replacing any of them would be a mistake.

They can still sell the toys and kids will know of them through reruns. Hasbro has actually tried this type of thing in the past when they killed Optimus Prime in the original Transformers animated movie from 1986 and they were actually planning on killing all of the main characters and replacing them with new ones in the next season. That was also Hasbro so I wouldn't be surprised if they got rid of all of the Mane 6 and replaced them. They probably couldn't kill them so maybe they'd all become princesses and be too busy to do normal stuff. They can still sell the original toys, though but now they have 6 more they can sell a lot of in addition.

[Radiance64 7,052]

No, I don't think that's happening for this show... no way there'll be a new Mane 6 or whatever number until G5 at least.

[WarriorShy 48]

Or maybe there will be a very hard villain to defeat that they may need 2 elements of harmony... but mane 6 never be replace

[True Rarity 1,239]

Not at all. You can't just go and replace the Mane Six. They're not expendable.

 

Besides, Cheese Sandwich was voiced by a guest star who won't likely appear on the show again.

[Scootalove 10,685]

Very unlikely because, that would be Hasbro jumping the shark in this case which is not a good idea at all and plus getting rid of the six assets that can bring you money and happiness to the fandom is something that is a pointless and ridiculous matter to come to.

[Tigerpop198 696]

This will never happen. Most people would find it very strange for the mane 6 to be changed so suddenly. Who would want the mane 6 to be changed anyway?