Is G1 Ember possibly G4 Tempest / Fizzlepop?

[ManaMinori 4,145]

It has been established that  the ponies of Equestria can create portals to other worlds and interact with them. Starswirl did it (Reflections/ Shadow Play/ EQG), Twilight did it,(Equestria Girls/ Rainbow Rocks),  Sunset Shimmer did it (The Fall of Sunset Shimmer/ EQG), Celestia did it (Reflections), and Clover the Clever did it (EQG:FF).....

So what is the likelihood of a portal being opened and allowing ponies from other worlds to come into and interact with Equestrians? Because I'm finding that if past generations of MLP were separate worlds rather than past timelines (which some might argue it is), then could a certain "special pony' (Ember from gen 1) in fact, be Fizzlepop Berrytwist? Ember, in g1, was a pony who was being raised by g1 Twilight, and told that she'd become a 'very special pony'. Interestingly enough, in g4, Fizzlepop ends up befriendsing g4 Twilight, and learning that she is, in fact, a very special pony at the end of the MLP movie......Also, we've seen form changes as life forms from one world step into another, so the alteration of an earth pony into a unicorn isn't out of the realm of possibility, and Fizzlepop is quite the special pony as an adult......

 

 

 

[Misty Shadow 7,940]

Using that same logic you could argue that Twilight from G1 is the same pony as Twilight Sparkle. They both look similar (or at least as similar as Tempest does to Ember), therefore they're the same pony. 

Oh, but wait. Twilight from G1 looks even more similar to Twilight Sparkle's mother.

Therefore, Twilight Sparkle is her own mother.

[Castle Bleck 19,376]

Given the title, I was expecting this to involve a certain, adorasexy Dragon Lord.

[Misty Shadow 7,940]

1 hour ago, A.V. said:

Given the title, I was expecting this to involve a certain, adorasexy Dragon Lord.

I'm surprised no one is jokingly theorizing that Ember from G1 is actually the adorasexy Dragon Lord just because they happen to share the same name. 

[ManaMinori 4,145]

2 hours ago, CloudMistDragon said:

Using that same logic you could argue that Twilight from G1 is the same pony as Twilight Sparkle. They both look similar (or at least as similar as Tempest does to Ember), therefore they're the same pony. 

Oh, but wait. Twilight from G1 looks even more similar to Twilight Sparkle's mother.

Therefore, Twilight Sparkle is her own mother.

g4 Twi S. looks nothing like g1 Twi, though. Faust said herself that Twi S's. design was based more off of g3 Twilight Twinkle, rather than g1 Twilight

[TBD 17,256]

I always think Fizzy Pop from G3 is Tempest shadow...but maybe since they do have the same coat and mane colors. 

[Altastrofae 933]

Eh... You're kinda stretching it. I don't think she is

[RDDash 19,195]

Is that my time to be a scarecrow?

Rainbow's earth pony cousin looks cute by the way.

[Castle Bleck 19,376]

15 hours ago, CloudMistDragon said:

I'm surprised no one is jokingly theorizing that Ember from G1 is actually the adorasexy Dragon Lord just because they happen to share the same name. 

Wouldn't be the first time FIM completely 180'd a past-gen character:

[Widdershins 9,960]

On 11/1/2018 at 4:37 PM, A.V. said:

Given the title, I was expecting this to involve a certain, adorasexy Dragon Lord.

 

On 11/1/2018 at 5:59 PM, CloudMistDragon said:

that Ember from G1 is actually the adorasexy Dragon Lord

 Is adorasexy just the new way of saying Sexy now?  ...girl owns her own kingdom, complete with scepter & throne & owns her own battlearmor. Yeah. Full kudos in all regards I'd say, cartoon or not.

Anyhow!

 As to the topic, think this depends heavily on one faulty lynchpin.

On 11/1/2018 at 12:31 PM, Nightmare Muffin said:

and told that she'd become a 'very special pony'. Interestingly enough, in g4, Fizzlepop ends up befriendsing g4 Twilight, and learning that she is, in fact, a very special pony at the end of the MLP movie.

 Yeah, no. Tempest Shadow/Fizzlepop Berrytwist isn't special. 

 She has no actual role, so much as a unique life. She's had to struggle, become a competent villain & warrior. (considering the culture of being kid-friendly in Equestria, that's saying alot actually) But I don't see how any of that applies to making her Important. 

 For one, clearly, she'll never be in the show. (Don'tyoudarelinkmetoanewepisodeIhaven'twatchedandentirelydemolishmyentirecounterpointhere,younitpickinglittle-) Because she was kind of a one-off for the movie & doesn't really have much to prop an episode on. She mostly learned the opposite, that she can move on with her life & just enjoy being normal, enjoy living.

 Secondly, she doesn't have any title. She doesn't run some nation, city or arbitrary-title-made-up-to-sound-important (Shots Fired!) like the alicorns do. She doesn't have anything any newspaper article would write about. 

 "Special" is such a vague word here. Like what or who would she be important to? Kind of seems like just something you'd reassure a little kid with in its original context.

 And if simply sharing a color scheme made you the same pony in Equestria, half the population would be gone, wouldn't it? 

[Jeric 46,854]

Updated the title since both Gens have a character named Ember

[ManaMinori 4,145]

On 11/2/2018 at 8:24 AM, Widdershins said:

 

 Is adorasexy just the new way of saying Sexy now?  ...girl owns her own kingdom, complete with scepter & throne & owns her own battlearmor. Yeah. Full kudos in all regards I'd say, cartoon or not.

Anyhow!

 As to the topic, think this depends heavily on one faulty lynchpin.

 Yeah, no. Tempest Shadow/Fizzlepop Berrytwist isn't special. 

 She has no actual role, so much as a unique life. She's had to struggle, become a competent villain & warrior. (considering the culture of being kid-friendly in Equestria, that's saying alot actually) But I don't see how any of that applies to making her Important. 

 For one, clearly, she'll never be in the show. (Don'tyoudarelinkmetoanewepisodeIhaven'twatchedandentirelydemolishmyentirecounterpointhere,younitpickinglittle-) Because she was kind of a one-off for the movie & doesn't really have much to prop an episode on. She mostly learned the opposite, that she can move on with her life & just enjoy being normal, enjoy living.

 Secondly, she doesn't have any title. She doesn't run some nation, city or arbitrary-title-made-up-to-sound-important (Shots Fired!) like the alicorns do. She doesn't have anything any newspaper article would write about. 

 "Special" is such a vague word here. Like what or who would she be important to? Kind of seems like just something you'd reassure a little kid with in its original context.

 And if simply sharing a color scheme made you the same pony in Equestria, half the population would be gone, wouldn't it? 

well, see, here's the thing though.....both ponies have actually been confirmed to be quite special, as Twilight (g1) and Twilight (g4) admitted to. For Ember, it was when she encountered an angel pony on a night of pure magic, and for Fizzlepop, well, not only did she dream of being a Princess in Canterlot (as confirmed by the book 'The Stormy Road to Canterlot"), but she's the first unicorn without a horn, but still powerful as heck and perhaps made even more special without one (as g4 Twilight confirms in the movie). Both have undergone very unique circumstances and had special dreams/goals. If Ember did grow up to be Fizzlepop, then her line of thinking- from meeting the angel pony and seeing how beautiful she was, to dreaming to becoming a Princess, equaled in beauty, as the only  example she would've to compare by would be Celestia, then this would make sense.