Equestria vs Mordor?

[Bendy 1,820]

Would Equestria be able to aid against Mordor at its strongest? Second Age Mordor. Sauron has the One Ring in this scenario and is a coward and hides in his fortress of Barad-dûr, and just uses his near-endless legions of orcs and other monsters most of the time. He will only fight in the field if he has no other choice. Let's say in this scenario Mordor has more or less destroyed Gondor. Mordor won the Battle of Dagorlad. Sauron lost many orcs, but his legions are quickly recovering. Osgiliath and Minas Tirth are burning, most of their inhabitants are either killed or enslaved. Masses of refugees and what remains of the Last Alliance's armies are fleeing westward to escape, only parts of western Gondor are still alive. Isildur is still alive, and trying to flee west, but is being chased.

Equestria appears in far west Gondor, connected by a single land bridge, several miles across. What should Equestria do? They may only have about two weeks before Mordor's vast host of doom will come knocking on their door. Should they go on the offensive? Or be defensive? Should they allow Gondor refugees and the remaining armies of the Last Alliance to flee into Equestria? Should they try to save Isildur, the only surviving member of the High King of Gondor and Arnor? In this, case, just Arnor for the most part. Would Equestria be able to rally what remains of the resistance against Sauron? Their morale would be extremely low since the Kindom of Gondor has fallen, leaving most of Middle Earth wide open to be attacked by Sauron.

Edited September 26, 2020 by Bendy

[Cwanky 17,482]

Well at least for starters none of the Equestrians can wear the One Ring.

 

Unless the unicorns or alicorns were dumb enough to wear it on their horn...

[Bendy 1,820]

2 minutes ago, Cwanky said:

Well at least for starters none of the Equestrians can wear the One Ring.

 

Unless the unicorns or alicorns were dumb enough to wear it on their horn...

If unicorns or alicorns tried to wear it. They would just end up as another Dark Lord. Yeah.

[EpicEnergy 22,625]

I think Equestria would be able to stand against the armies of Mordor, especially if they have unicorns on their side.

[Goat-kun 2,516]

Equestria by itself would fall against any formidable dark army. Harmony is the only player that matters and it's not as cunning as Sauron who's been around the block since forever and even knows how to beat foes that are stronger than him. One way or another, the ponies would die without plot armor. Then there are other factors. Where's Witch-king at that time? Would Smaug and balrog of Moria ally themselves with Sauron holding the One Ring? Probably yes. Wraiths and balrogs generate fear, and unicorns are super weak against such psychological attacks. However, I believe that the dwarves still held the mountains at that point so Mordor would have to clash with them in order to obtain those allies.

[Splashee 28,543]

I found it very odd when rings are fitted on a unicorn's horn. It is "graphical" and "inappropriate".

 

As for the two different worlds. I rank them by how many fans there are, and I am sad to say, LOTR is too big and technical to be mixed up with MLP stuff.

[Monsoon 1,650]

They would probably have an advantage due to the quantity of magic they posses but they are sorely lacking when it comes to combat experience which would inevitably put them on the backfoot.