You are allowed to live with a mlp character

[Moonstarleader10101 72]

As it says, you can choose one mlp character to live with, just one, who do you choose? Be careful about choosing your favorites, I can't imagine them always being the best roommates, (Pinkie pie sounds like she'd be a headache to even comprehend)
Personally I choose! FLUTTERSHY she seems like she'd be a decent roommate
Failing that I would choose Applejack, since well she also seems like she wouldn't mess with my stuff
Yes you can choose multiple ponies but assume you are only living with one of them, not all of them.
You can choose to live with them in your home or in their home, though if you choose their home yes you must become a pony but meh.

Edited Tuesday at 09:00 PM by Moonstarleader10101
Small adjustment to rules

[Sparklefan1234 187,409]

I've lived with my Best Friend, Rarity for many years. 

[Moonstarleader10101 72]

16 minutes ago, Sparklefan1234 said:

I've lived with my Best Friend, Rarity for many years. 

How is she as a roommate?

[Sparklefan1234 187,409]

Moments ago, Moonstarleader10101 said:

How is she as a roommate?

Rarity doesn't make a lot of noise while working and she tries not to work too early in the morning or too late at night. Best roommate ever! 

[Moonstarleader10101 72]

48 minutes ago, Sparklefan1234 said:

Rarity doesn't make a lot of noise while working and she tries not to work too early in the morning or too late at night. Best roommate ever! 

Now the ultimate test *Puts a tub of ice cream labeled as for you, it is Rarity's favorite flavor, can she resist?*

[Snoopy Fan 15,381]

I’m going with Fluttershy

[Sparklefan1234 187,409]

46 minutes ago, Moonstarleader10101 said:

Now the ultimate test *Puts a tub of ice cream labeled as for you, it is Rarity's favorite flavor, can she resist?*

Rarity always gets the ice cream. Always! 

[GoldenDawn 25]

Applejack as roommate. Up early, works most of the day, but so do I. We have alot in common...though when we disagree on something that might get interesting.

[gdnspk 28]

I'd go with Twilight(Golden Oaks)- I like libraries, and I like it when things are organized, and, well... she seems like she's good at that. Not that I wouldn't pitch in to help or anything, but still, she's a mare after my own heart, and I have a lot of respect for that. Although, I'm not sure what the line is between "roomate" and "3rd assistant"... don't wanna overstep boundaries when I'm the one moving in!

[Moonstarleader10101 72]

1 hour ago, gdnspk said:

I'd go with Twilight(Golden Oaks)- I like libraries, and I like it when things are organized, and, well... she seems like she's good at that. Not that I wouldn't pitch in to help or anything, but still, she's a mare after my own heart, and I have a lot of respect for that. Although, I'm not sure what the line is between "roomate" and "3rd assistant"... don't wanna overstep boundaries when I'm the one moving in!

Just don't stress the poor alicorn princess out too much

[gdnspk 28]

57 minutes ago, Moonstarleader10101 said:

Just don't stress the poor alicorn princess out too much

Alicorn? In the Golden Oaks? I guess it might be s4, but... I dunno, I was imagining Unicorn Twi. Probably ain't a major difference, though.

[Clawdeen 25,917]

I’d live with Inky Rose

[Moonstarleader10101 72]

11 hours ago, gdnspk said:

Alicorn? In the Golden Oaks? I guess it might be s4, but... I dunno, I was imagining Unicorn Twi. Probably ain't a major difference, though.

Eh, still Twi-Twi ain't it? Either way, she still got her triggers.

Edited Wednesday at 03:42 PM by Moonstarleader10101
Twilight Twilights a lot

[Moonstarleader10101 72]

18 hours ago, Snoopy Fan said:

I’m going with Fluttershy

I mean she's also especially good if you have any pets, be careful, she may spoil your pet rotten.

[Moonstarleader10101 72]

19 hours ago, Clawdeen said:

I’d live with Inky Rose

I kinda wish I could comment but I admittedly don't know much about Inky Rose...

[GlitchStarImponestor 163]

Starlight Glimmer and Zipp Storm. 2 of my favorite ponies.

[Ganondorf8 11,790]

I technically live with Sunset Shimmer since I do cosplay as her. I've actually not done so since May because she can be difficult to cosplay sometimes due to the yellow bodysuit I use. It makes switching between characters a chore.

[Dawnshine Wonder 4,487]

Favourites does not necessarily mean compatible personalities, I think I could learn a lot from being in Equestria, but about this topic, which Pony I'd like to live with in Equestria from My Little Pony Friendship is Magic, I'd have to think about this one carefully. Because had this wish of this fictional world scenario came true, I would not want to burden them, in fact doing anything which could harm them would defeat the point of being there in the first place. That said no Christmas gift would ever come close to being as good as friendship. I'd rather be loved and have nothing, than be spoiled and have no friends. My fan fiction I worked on, actually implied other individuals from our world (still fiction, Equestria does not exist) ended up in Equestria, and there were no exceptions based on nationality or anything else like that. I wrote that bit in, because I did not want this wish for just myself, anyone who desires this for the purposes of friendship and community spirit deserves this chance. You can imagine any timeline you desire, it doesn't have to be rebirth after passing on from natural causes like in my fan fiction, either, straight up ponification if you desire works too.

 

I've imagined a fan fiction scenario (this part of the script was my idea, not AI assisted, I used AI for formatting sentences and spelling correction, my English is lousy sometimes) where the first out of the Mane Six I met were Applejack, after found in Everfree Forest, after sleeping the night away there, which admittedly was risky but was left with no choice, after a lengthy and tiring trek through the badlands as an orphaned and poor adolescent Pegasus, not even trainsurfing got me very far, and not having enough wing strength I could not fly yet either, I still had to risk being a meal for timberwolves or being turned to stone by a cockatrice or harmed by other magical threats I was not aware of to find civilization in this fictional world scenario. What's an adventure without the challenge, right?  I suppose it would make sense to live with Applejack at Sweet Apple Acres, since my imaginary self and OC Dawnshine Wonder, out of concern for safety, was escorted by Applejack there to avoid hazards of the wilderness, no doubt her family including Apple Bloom, Big Mac and Granny Smith being at her home too. Events played out almost the same as the official show otherwise. Plus helping her with bucking for apples, I could imagine being fun.

 

I imagined speaking with a deep south American accent similar to Applejack as well, in real life I have a British accent, but being reborn in Equestria, circumstances would be very different and my language and how I spoke would be heavily influenced by their culture.

 

Second option, Twilight Sparkle, after turning up in Ponyville since rebirth there, it's obvious education would be needed and I'd need to learn how things work there, to truly be one of them means learning about them and to contribute to the greater good of their community. I'm not as smart as I'd like to be, but Twilight Sparkle's influence would definitely help.

 

On 2025-12-09 at 10:29 PM, Snoopy Fan said:

I’m going with Fluttershy

Why, so she can sing one of her beautiful lullabies for you? 

I get it, living with Fluttershy would be awesome.

[liujiadong 2,678]

I would choose Starlight Glimmer; she is very smart!

I would choose Princess Luna too; she makes me feel safe.

[Moonstarleader10101 72]

6 hours ago, liujiadong said:

I would choose Starlight Glimmer; she is very smart!

I would choose Princess Luna too; she makes me feel safe.

Either way you also live in a castle with them probably if living with them in their homes

[Dawnshine Wonder 4,487]

3 minutes ago, Moonstarleader10101 said:

Either way you also live in a castle with them probably if living with them in their homes

Perhaps Luijiadong could be one of their Royal Guards, with training of course. I suck at military, I never been in the service, but I know I am not the warrior type so that job would not be for me. There's more to it than that, but even being a commander people need to know logistics and stuff like that, it's hard work. Would that change if we were reborn in the fictional world Equestria? not likely.

 

Power would not be the reason for desiring to be there, though, of course they need some kind of social structure to keep their society stable, but there's some responsibilities I would not be fit for even if my wish had come true and we got to be there someday, which it never will.

It would not matter to me if I was not the most powerful or richest Pony of all Equestria, even living in the rural outskirts of Ponyville at Sweet Apple Acres where Applejack lives, even living in a wooden shack with a stone fireplace and thatch roofing would be home enough, as long as I could keep it warm as the seasons changed, and had a steady supply of palatable food and water, I'd be grateful.

Learning how to survive and earn a living there by contributing, those lessons would likely come from Applejack.

[GoldenDawn 25]

7 hours ago, liujiadong said:

I would choose Starlight Glimmer; she is very smart!

I would choose Princess Luna too; she makes me feel safe.

That would also be a solid choice. Smart, aware of potential problems, and doesn't assume everything will just work out like the Mane 6. Life experience.

[Moonstarleader10101 72]

7 hours ago, Dawnshine Wonder said:

Perhaps Luijiadong could be one of their Royal Guards, with training of course. I suck at military, I never been in the service, but I know I am not the warrior type so that job would not be for me. There's more to it than that, but even being a commander people need to know logistics and stuff like that, it's hard work. Would that change if we were reborn in the fictional world Equestria? not likely.

 

Power would not be the reason for desiring to be there, though, of course they need some kind of social structure to keep their society stable, but there's some responsibilities I would not be fit for even if my wish had come true and we got to be there someday, which it never will.

It would not matter to me if I was not the most powerful or richest Pony of all Equestria, even living in the rural outskirts of Ponyville at Sweet Apple Acres where Applejack lives, even living in a wooden shack with a stone fireplace and thatch roofing would be home enough, as long as I could keep it warm as the seasons changed, and had a steady supply of palatable food and water, I'd be grateful.

Learning how to survive and earn a living there by contributing, those lessons would likely come from Applejack.

Yeah but still, the pony's status and living situation should be taken into account, and if you are choosing Luna or Starlight you kinda have to go into it with the expectation of the castle involved, no? Unless they are coming to your house, which has its own issues, Luna being a controller of the night and Starlight being Starlight