Who would be the best baby-sitter?

[Cestler 9]

 Applejack. She knows how to have fun and enjoy herself, but she knows when to stop, and what things are appopriate for genders and ages.

[Forlong 1,726]

Pinkie Pie is best baby sitter!

 

Experience is the best teacher when it comes to kids.  Pinkie spends a lot of time with foals and has learned a lot about each and every one of them.  She just needed an opportunity to step up and show how responsible she could be (which was done in Baby Cakes).

[dekutree64 713]

I voted Fluttershy. Pinkie may actually be the best choice in the particular case of Pound and Pumpkin, because she's been around them their whole lives so she knows what they like and don't like, and they're comfortable around her already.

 

I wish Pinkie would have let Twilight come in and help. I'm sure she's read plenty about baby care, but it would be fun to see how well she can deal with reality, where nothing ever goes according to plan. There's also the Philomena incident where she was very forceful, but then Celestia was involved with that, which is what makes Twilight go crazy.