Make your own messed-up fanfiction plot! (read 1st post!)

[TailsIsNotAlone 3,696]

I sorta got this idea from Clarity's fanfiction contest, but don't blame her. I claim full responsibility. Now then! No doubt we have all seen our share of MLP stories out there that just made us go...

 

 

But let's look on the lighter side! It's good to have a creative fan community, and even if you don't want to read all of the ideas you run into, they can be good for a laugh. So why don't we get in on the fun? It's simple: just make up (but don't really write) the weirdest fanfiction idea/s you can think of for My Little Pony! Tell us what kind of monster you would create if you went totally off the deep end as a writer. Just let me lay down some ground rules before we cut to the crazy:

 

1. Follow the forum rules, obviously. Keep it safe for work. It's okay to say it's clop or gore or whatever, as long as you don't describe it explicitly.

 

2. But tell us the plot in some detail. No really short or vague plots like "Twilight goes nuts lulz."

 

3. No crossovers, AUs, or OCs, because not everyone will "get" them (especially me). Keep it within the world of MLP.

 

4. None of the ideas in this thread are to be taken seriously. i.e. don't call anyone crazy or sick just because they came up with something more twisted than you. xD

 

Here's your format, hypothetical authors!

 

Title:

Plot:

Genre:

Main Characters:

 

And one more thing...the main purpose of this thread is for all of us to display our creativity (or insanity). BUT. If it gets enough replies, I will choose one of your ideas, and then...I have to write it. For real. (Naturally I will credit you in the story.)

 

Think I'm kidding? Bring it on, fellow bronies!!

Edited October 30, 2012 by TailsAlone

[Winona the Dog 1,984]

Title: I Beleive i can Fly

 

Plot: Scootaloo is tranfered to Flight School in Cloudsdale. (She can fly but not well at all compared to the others and they make fun of her)

Genre: Comedy, Random

 

Main Characters: Scootaloo, Rainbow Dash , (Possible Cutie Mark Crusaders)

[OkBuddy 586]

Title: Pootis

Plot: About Pinkie pie eating a dispenser and starts to cause ear-rape all over town. She then teleports into space and kisses an orca. And everyone died.

Genre: Random, Comedy

Main Characters: Pinkie Pie, Dispencer, Orca, Your MOM, Gaypenls, Rubberfruit

 

P.S ,Who Gaypenls is:

P.P.S, the video is very quiet, so turn it up all the way.

Edited October 30, 2012 by DJ PINK-3

[Feather Spiral 1,892]

Title: Muffins and What-If's

 

Plot: Viscra's butt A group of background ponies get stuck (in a cave with a storm outside, in an elevator car waiting for a technician...) together, including Derpy who has a muffin. To kill time, they recount anecdotes; what happened, how they could've reacted differently, how that could've changed the way things turned out... And every time somepony talks about one event, Derpy takes a bite out of a muffin, chews while imagining herself in that situation; and when as the story is over, she invariably swallows and makes a brief silly comment.

 

Genre: random, sitcom-ish

 

Characters: Derpy, Octavia, Lyra (sitting like a human against a wall), Timelord (Clock Turner I think), Cherrilee, Berry Punch, Carrot Top... as many background ponies as plausible

 

 

[ PS: an alternative could feature fan character cameos, like a couple of famous bronies and/or Tumblr characters. ]

Edited October 30, 2012 by Figurehead Uprise

[LunarSolstice25 6]

On second thought, that was a bit much for this topic; I guess I should've read the OP a bit more. My bad, and sincerest appoligies >.<

 

As an extended appolgy, I wrote a new, much lighter hearted story n.n

 

Title: The Muffin Conundrum

 

Plot: One day Derpy and Pinkie get into a discussion about baked goods. At some point Derpy says, "Could you imagine if the whole world was made of muffins?!" to which Pinkie replies, "No, it should be made cupcakes!" "Muffins!" "Cupcakes!!" "Muffins!!!" etc... Until eventually Derpy closes her eyes and yells, "I wish the whole world was made of muffins, just to show you!"

 

When she opens her eyes, to her amazement, everything is made of muffins, or some form of dry pastry, including her friends. She must then learn to adapt to life where everything is made of her favorite dessert. (note: this is NOT meant to turn into a cupcakes or any other grimdark story)

 

Genre: Slice of Life

 

Main Characters: Pinkie, Derpy, and friends.

Edited October 30, 2012 by LunarSolstice25

[Cocodrillo 1,566]

Title: The Lily of a geometrical colour.

Plot: Screwball falls in love with @@Nouths fluffy blue carpet. Her daddy, Discord, does not allow her to get closer to the fluffy blue carpet, because he thinks it´s too ordinary for a Princess of Chaos. She refuses to give up and runs to see the fluffy blue carpet. Unfortunately, she finds out that the fluffy blue carpet is engaged (to Suntouched Coco aka me), and decides to end up her desperate life by poisoning herself and leaving the antidote in the middle of the party (so she wouldn´t get to it), but Pinkie Pie pushes her in. Then she tries to starve to death by putting a stranger into her kitchen. But the stranger is Applejack, so she makes plenty of food and brings it to her. She tries to kill herself by flying and putting off her flying cap. Rainbow Dash is here and catches her. Screwball´s last trial is to stab herself so she´d had to ask for help in the crowded lecture hall. Twilight, the nerd, is here, and as she smells the blood she uses her magic to heal her wound. So Screwball is even more desperate she can´t even die. She decides to go to the Fluttershy´s shed. She´s dead that day. As she´s dying, she hears the cello music. Octavia´s playing. The tones brings Screwball to the sky. She´s happy she finally found herself dead and that she might forget about the fluffy blue carpet. But then, something weird happens. She sees only darkness. Then the light. The doctor, and hears "Congratulations, it´s a filly". She realizes that she as the chaos itself is so chaotic, that her life ends up with starting to live. The Chaos can never die, it will be there forever. She can never end up her suffering.

Genre: Drama, tragedy

Main Characters: Screwball, the fluffy blue carpet, Discord, Rainbow Dash, Pinkie Pie, Applejack, Twilight Sparkle, Fluttershy, Octavia.

Edited November 29, 2018 by Cocodrillo

[RainbowDashie 767]

some guy kills terrorists but one day one of the terrorists is Pinkie pie, dun dun duuuuun. he becomes a terrorist too, watjathink