My first pony purchases were a couple of blind bag ponies from Wal Mart a few weeks ago. Yes, I'm that new!
But today I had time so I raided Hot Topic & came home with a sticker, a button and a shirt! Fluttershy says 'yay'. <3
In the interim I found a couple of ponies at thrift stores, bought a couple offa ebay, and have a couple more coming from ebay now. Oh, and I got a Twilight Sparkle necklace from a gal on etsy.
ETA--wish I'd known you could tell what was in the packages. I got 3 of one pony. But I experimented on the spares and figured out how to mount them so now I have a keychain and a zipper pull. lol. And the excitement when I picked the last lonely bag out of the bottom of the box at Wal mart today and it was sparkly Twilight!! (dances)