Should Discord lose his powers?

[LordDiscord 289]

I don't mean permanently, I mean as a form of lesson. Perhaps Discords plays a prank on the wrong pony that happened to have a way of taking Discords magic from him, and Discord can only get it back by learning some lesson, or maybe have his powers taken by someone intending to use them for their own agenda and not Twilight, Discord and the others have to retrieve his powers before things get out of hand. Whatever the reason, I would love to see this as a story plot sometime in the future.

And no I am not counting Tirek draining Discord of his magic because we barely got to see anything happen with Discord without his powers. I would like to see how the Mane 6 reacts to it. Would they be supportive of Discord and try to help him gain back his powers or would they tell Discord he got what he deserved but reluctantly helps him either do to him begging or do to Fluttershy convincing them that Discord would not be himself without his powers. 

[Aurelion Star 434]

yes, I just fell like it. even in a short time like 1 century only?   
is that too much to ask?

[PsychedelicPony 440]

I think it'd be cool to see, but I think for him to lose the powers he would have to do something bad. I bet it'd turn into a Fluttershy episode after that trying to get them to support him and such (not that I'm against a Fluttershy episode at all! )

[Retro*Derpy 3,186]

I think the whole thing of reforming the god of chaos was just, not the best move. I think Discord should of gotten the same thing Sombra did considering they both caused misery. Heck, Sombra only did it to the Crystal empire while Discord did it to all of Equestria. If they are going to keep him alive, I'd say revoke his powers permanently. 

[Jeric 46,852]

I don't mean permanently, I mean as a form of lesson. Perhaps Discords plays a prank on the wrong pony that happened to have a way of taking Discords magic from him, and Discord can only get it back by learning some lesson, or maybe have his powers taken by someone intending to use them for their own agenda and not Twilight, Discord and the others have to retrieve his powers before things get out of hand. Whatever the reason, I would love to see this as a story plot sometime in the future.

 

And no I am not counting Tirek draining Discord of his magic because we barely got to see anything happen with Discord without his powers. I would like to see how the Mane 6 reacts to it. Would they be supportive of Discord and try to help him gain back his powers or would they tell Discord he got what he deserved but reluctantly helps him either do to him begging or do to Fluttershy convincing them that Discord would not be himself without his powers. 

 

That would be a decent enough episode. Also akin to a Star Trek: The Next Generation episode Déjà Q and Q did learn a moral lesson at the end and sought to sacrifice himself to save the USS Enterprise. 

[LordDiscord 289]

I think the whole thing of reforming the god of chaos was just, not the best move. I think Discord should of gotten the same thing Sombra did considering they both caused misery. Heck, Sombra only did it to the Crystal empire while Discord did it to all of Equestria. If they are going to keep him alive, I'd say revoke his powers permanently. 

A little bit harsh don't you think?

[Jeric 46,852]

I think the whole thing of reforming the god of chaos was just, not the best move. I think Discord should of gotten the same thing Sombra did considering they both caused misery. Heck, Sombra only did it to the Crystal empire while Discord did it to all of Equestria. If they are going to keep him alive, I'd say revoke his powers permanently.

I missed this post. I would think that your idea would be extremely unpopular with the majority of the fandom as part of Discords allure is the humor and whimsical silliness that comes with his powers. A one off story dealing with a de powered Discord but more than that may be overkill and detrimental to the popularity of the character (and possibly the show as a whole)

[Wind Chaser 4,768]

What I think would make for a story with some nice tension would be if Discord's powers weaken from not using them for chaos, causing a kind of moral conflict; choosing between helping himself or helping others. Anyone who's seen "Santa Claus is Comin' to Town" and saw how the Winter Warlock's powers weakened after he was reformed knows exactly what I'm talking about.

[Wulfgar Von Heltzer 42]

Nah, he wouldn't be Discord without them, honestly.

[Stallion 0]

you  mean like what happend after he teamed up with tyrek

[ManaMinori 4,145]

what's a lord of chaos without his powers? Take away his powers, and you take away everything that Discord IS.

strong NO to this idea

[Jeric 46,852]

What I think would make for a story with some nice tension would be if Discord's powers weaken from not using them for chaos, causing a kind of moral conflict; choosing between helping himself or helping others. Anyone who's seen "Santa Claus is Comin' to Town" and saw how the Winter Warlock's powers weakened after he was reformed knows exactly what I'm talking about.

 

Not much to add to that outside of saying that this is an interesting idea. If they would be able to somehow modify his powers it would be more palatable to the fan base in general, but a slow ebbing of his powers due to his change of heart is a nice touch even if I would hate him losing them entirely. 

[Castle Bleck 19,376]

Discord = voice + personality + powers.

 

So:

 

[Visual Spectrum 1,932]

The thing is, he was reformed because Princess Celestia believed that he could use his powers for good. If he was reformed then lost his powers, there would really be no reason to reform him. The entire purpose for him being reformed was because of his powers. 

[LordDiscord 289]

The thing is, he was reformed because Princess Celestia believed that he could use his powers for good. If he was reformed then lost his powers, there would really be no reason to reform him. The entire purpose for him being reformed was because of his powers. 

I don't mean forever. Out of all of the possible years it was that Discord spread his chaos, is it not possible that it may have effected someponies that happen to either be unaware that he was reformed or believe the ponies fools for releasing him and take his powers as their form of justice. Or even it might be possible that he runs into a pony or group of ponies that don't take so kindly to his antics as the Mane 6 do. I could even see a weaken Discord appearing at Twilights castle to inform/ask for help with this problem.

Edited October 22, 2014 by LordDiscord

[Visual Spectrum 1,932]

I don't mean forever. Out of all of the possible years it was that Discord spread his chaos, is it not possible that it may have effected someponies that happen to either be unaware that he was reformed or believe the ponies fools for releasing him and take his powers as their form of justice. Or even it might be possible that he runs into a pony or group of ponies that don't take so kindly to his antics as the Mane 6 do. I could even see a weaken Discord appearing at Twilights castle to inform/ask for help with this problem.

 

Temporary (not 100 years. Maybe a few Discord episodes at the very most.) would be a good idea maybe if it relates to the plot. I don't know how ponies not trusting him and stealing his magic would work for the plot. Fluttershy would have something to say if someone stole his magic. 

[ggg-2 3,553]

that would be a good plot for an episode. (and then maybe we'd FINALLY get that mariachi band reference. I mean they referenced eating books)

[Anilewe 2,178]

It is interesting idea, because that way we could see more real and vulnerable side of his character. BUT Discord without his powers isn't Discord. Take them away from him and you have an empty shell. These powers make him who he is, he wouldn't know how to deal with life without them. While I find the concept interesting, I think it would work better in fanfiction. So my answer to the question of this topic is no.

[kanashimi purinsesu 244]

I could see it working in a context of really putting discord through the ringer. Like at the end of Season 4 where he got swayed to be mischevious again, maybe it could be an ep showing how he used to love chaos and is having a constant struggle between trying to be friends with the ponies and resisting the ever so tempting temptations to cause chaos. Maybe the Mane Six would have a bit more distrust of him causing him to consider it immensely.

 

Something like him getting under Twilights skin and challenging her to a contest of not using her magic and he can't use his. I don't know what lesson there would be to be learned from something like that though, but it'd be entertaining.

[Sazama Ichida 2,367]

I had this very same idea in mind. It would be interesting.

[LordDiscord 289]

It is interesting idea, because that way we could see more real and vulnerable side of his character. BUT Discord without his powers isn't Discord. Take them away from him and you have an empty shell. These powers make him who he is, he wouldn't know how to deal with life without them. While I find the concept interesting, I think it would work better in fanfiction. So my answer to the question of this topic is no.

But wouldn't that be the point? With Discord powerless we could finally get a glimpse of who he really is and see what he actually thinks of  the rest of the Mane behind his cocky attitude. 

[Dulset Tarn 441]

As has been mentioned, that's already a Star Trek episode.

[Sazama Ichida 2,367]

I think it would be cool if he temporarily lost them and somepony else got them and he had to get them back. Kinda like when The Joker got Mxyzptlk's powers.

[Po-Nonimous 583]

To those of you who are also STTNG fans (and I'm sure there's more than a few here) Think back to the episode where Q lost all his powers and was kicked out of the Continuum. How wonderful to see him mortal, capable of being wounded, even able to bleed! Q in that episode certainly did suffer as a mortal!

 

So, with that in mind, I'm thinking: yeah, Discord loses all his powers (supposedly forever, let's leave that up for grabs.) Being suddenly mortal and at the literal mercy of every single pony not only in Ponyville but all of Equestria would certainly be more than enough to motivate him to really, truly reform and, of course, I'm sure there's a ton of ponies out there, somewhere, who'd be more than happy to take revenge on the now-mortal Discord for all the chaos and misery he'd created in the past.

 

This, of course, would naturally create a lovely sub-plot in which the Mane Six would be required to protect Discord's life from the (probably) hundreds of thousands - let's just say raging hoard - that want's nothing more than to end him!

 

Yeah, sounds interesting to me.

[Rainbow Dash 1,472]

Because being a statue for all those years was not the same as him losing his powers. If Discord lost his powers, there would be no point to his character...correct me if i'm wrong but the only way he can exist is if he had those powers. Yes Tirek draining him didn't kill him, but seeing as how this is a family show; death is never addressed. I thought since Discord was made up of all different animal parts, without any powers he would cease to exist.

Anyways, Discord without his powers for an episode would be interesting to see. It could be argued that we already saw him without powers during the season 4 finale, but that wouldnt be good enough for some. Though, at this point it wouldnt do anything since we've seen Discord at his weakest.