Which non-villain is closer to being evil?

[Megachangeling12 110]

Hey guys in your opinion which non villain chracter in MLP comes closet to being evil . Before you answer keep this in mind. When I say evil I don't mean jerks ( Trixie LD , Diamond Tiara etc ) . I mean real leginate villains ( Nightmare moon , Discord , Chrysailis , King sombra and Tirek ). So what are your thoughs ?

[MysticShine 529]

King Sombra was pretty bad. He enslaved an entire race of ponies and completely scarred their minds.

Edited March 6, 2015 by Mountaineer28

[The Professor...8D 823]

Oops...........hmmmmmmmmm..............Fluttershy........Have you seen her rage...........Maybe PinkiePie, She has gone Coconuts a few times..............But Top of the List.........Twilight....She has the most potential to be truly evil

Edited March 6, 2015 by The Professor

[JonasDarkmane 19,790]

Non villain? Aren't they all villains? 

 

Well for me it would be Sombra. I agree with Mountaineer28. He enslaved a whole race of ponies. Not only that, he seems to have been really deep into dark magic (could make ponies live their worst nightmares, like with one of his traps that Twilight encountered). 

[Frostgage 7,981]

Honestly I can't think of any non-villain that I would consider close to being evil. I really don't think of Trixie is anywhere near that, and Diamond Tiara is still just a filly.

[Megachangeling12 110]

I think you guys are missing the point of the post I was trying to which non Gillian chracter had the most qualities of the Gillian's .

[MysticShine 529]

I think you guys are missing the point of the post I was trying to which non Gillian chracter had the most qualities of the Gillian's .

Your first post is worded oddly and kind of confusing.

 

Outside the main villains, I would say that Rainbow Dash is the most evil for having such a big ego.

Edited March 6, 2015 by Mountaineer28

[Megachangeling12 110]

Yeah sorry about that bit the great with grammar and a lot of times spell check messes up my spelling .( how ironic ).

[Silver Letter 1,832]

In my opinion, Trixie was a "legitimate" villain. She was evil and wanted to take over Equestria.

 

In regards to the main question, I don't there there are any non-villain characters that are really evil. Well, Angel Bunny isn't very nice but he's not that evil.

Edited March 6, 2015 by Silver Letter

[Gearbox10mm 794]

Sweetie Belle could make a pretty convincing villain if given the chance.

 

[Megachangeling12 110]

I always kinda thought that ! Perhaps a fan fiction where Sweetie Belle is taught magic by Discord , Chrysailis or Sombra would be a good idea !

[Jammo 986]

Discord is the most questionably evil, even when he was a straight villain. It was in his nature to be chaotic so some of his his actions don't seem as defined by the bad decisions he makes.

 

Chrysalis gets a fair share of defenders saying she only cares about the welfare of her hive. This is incorrect. The sadistic joy she gets from attacking Canterlot, using deception and covert warfare instead of negotiation for a food solution, exploiting Shining Armors feelings for his fiancé. She's evil, sorry.

 

Sombra is classical tyrant. Enslaving your populace is classic totalitarian evil.

 

Tirek is a barbarian. Compared to the other villains he's very hands on evil, just taking what he wants through violent force.

 

I'd actually say the last three are all pretty evil but evil in very different ways.

[sweetolebob18 728]

Non villain but coming close.  I would say Twilight by far.  She has a ruthless streak & a disturbing tendency to go for results & not much care how she gets them.

 

I would put Fluttershy 2nd.  She has serious Unresolved Anger Issues  In fact, 2 ideas for a fan fic

1)Fluttershy taking a court ordered Anger Management Class after the events in Putting Your Hoof Down

2)Discord conquered the world for Fluttershy, but she hasn't been able to figure out how to tell folks without upsetting them 

[Cosmik Vek 768]

Twilight, and you must be saying right now: WHY? WHY THE HAY WOULD IT BE TWILIGHT?! NONSENSE!

That's because I saw everything that happened, it was all planned right for her, and this is partially why she became an alicorn for no apparent reason. First Celestia asked her to joined the Ponyminati, Equestria's largest underground organisation then she said yes to join it. Then the plan took form in the background of the story and one day without a signal, she became an alicorn but now season 5 might be the time where all this thing will reveal itself to the eyes of the innocent public.

Then you respond "FAKE GIMME SOME PROOF!"

The only thing I can tell you as a proof is that I've done tons of research and hard work to find infos from the conspiracy.

Another thing I've gotta tell you all is that she will probably hear about me speaking of this to you and will probably find me on this thread then take possession of me... WHAT! WHAT WAS THAT NOISE.... NOOO SHES HEEEERE...

So you know about the story MLPForums? You saw nothing!

[Pastel 7,630]

It's a tricky question, they're all happy and kind ponies.

Except maybe Twilight (as others said), I don't see any of them becoming a villain.

Edited March 7, 2015 by Blobulle

[Megachangeling12 110]

Yeah Twilight would have the most potential to become evil . However if Dash continues to be arrogant she could end up like a certain boasting unicorn ...

[VitalSpark 1,830]

In my opinion, Trixie was a "legitimate" villain. She was evil and wanted to take over Equestria.

What the hell? Trixie is not evil.

 

In her first appearance, she was arrogant, a show-off, and greatly exaggerated her exploits. Arguably annoying, but certainly not villainous. And given her job as a travelling show pony, a certain amount of self-promotion should be expected from her.

 

In her second appearance, she was somewhat more villainous, but her ambitions were mostly limited to Ponyville, not all of Equestria. Most importantly though, she was under the growing influence of the Alicorn Amulet, which corrupts its wearer. Once she had been freed from its curse she showed genuine remorse for her actions.

 

Trixie is no villain. She ends up on opposition with the Mane 6 mostly because Twilight Sparkle happens to be more magically talented than her, which is inconvenient given Trixie's means of employment. Under a different set of circumstances it's quite easy to imagine her being good friends with Twilight. (And this is partly why Twilight and Trixie get shipped together so much.)

Edited March 7, 2015 by Vital Periwinkle

[Castle Bleck 19,453]

A tie between Sombra and Tirek.

 

Chrysalis comes in second--especially in the comics--but avoids ^their Complete-Monster-dom by treating her Changelings okay.

[Megachangeling12 110]

Yeah Trixie dosn't even come close to being evil .

[Castle Bleck 19,453]

Yeah Trixie dosn't even come close to being evil .

 

And the real "villain" of Magic Duel was the Amulet.

[Megachangeling12 110]

Very true people

And the real "villain" of Magic Duel was the Amulet.[/quote

Very true people seem to forget that Trix was under the control of the alicorn amulet the majority of that episode .

[Sazama Ichida 2,367]

@the people who said King Sombra: Wait what? How was Sombra not a villain?

[Castle Bleck 19,453]

@the people who said King Sombra: Wait what? How was Sombra not a villain?

 

We misinterpreted and thought this was just another "Most Evil Villain" thread.

[Sazama Ichida 2,367]

We misinterpreted and thought this was just another "Most Evil Villain" thread.

Ah I see now. Anyway it's sorta debatable but I would have to say either Trixie or Gilda.

[Megachangeling12 110]

Nwll Trixie had her shot with the amulet but after that disaster I'm sure she won't try anything like that again . As for Gilda her episode aired so long ago it would kinda awkward seeing her again .