You get reincarnated into the ponyverse and can choose MS for a mother, who?

[Azureth 687]

Okay, you kick the bucket but you will be reincarnated as a pony in the MLP universe and can choose any of the Main Seven to be your mother, who would you choose? For me, I'd say Rarity. Yes, I realize people will say she'd be to busy with her work to be a good mother, but honestly like for so many others I am sure she'd find a nice balance while still being able to adequately provide.

[Widdershins 9,964]

  Starlight Glimmer.

 

    Hmm, not entirely sure why... I just get the feeling, that with as much as she's been through, she knows well enough how to be loving.

Say whatever else you want about her, but she did found a town & have mass reserves of magical know-how. She didn't have most of her belongings and stuff just happen off screen. We don't know where Fluttershy got her cottage, Pinkie her live-in job, or Twilight's house just spring up outta nowhere.

   Girl founded a town, learned to live with her mistakes. I just seem to see her as a bit more mature I suppose.

 

 

   Maybe Applejack a close second. Maybe I'm bias on my wanton magiclust. (as in powerlust, you know?)

[Nightshroud 331]

I would want to be twilight why you may ask? magical powers or rarity dashie dr hooves derpy luna list goes on and on

[Steve Piranha 29,496]

Flutters, and I've been thinking that years ago 

[KrazyDashie 1,847]

kinda makes you wonder who the father would be..

[Jeric 46,878]

All of them have what it takes to be a mother if we are talking the MS at their current maturity levels. Season One would be AJ, but experience tells me that all of them would have become decent parents regardless.

 

Be better than being raised by Treehugger

[Tropico 226]

I would like an unicorn mother to be an unicorn myself. I know unicorns can be born without unicorn parents but i guess chances are so much lower.

 

-I also see Starlight as the most mature. Hopefully also I would inherite some of her super powerful magic.

-With Twilight I would learn a lot plus BE ROYALTY. Castles. Moneyyyy. AAA+ educationnnn. And small chance to born alicorn + also powerful magic.

-With Rarity I would be the most fashion pony for free xD also as headcanon I see her very lovely and caring as mother (thats what i think for how she takes care of her sister) even with her tons of bussiness. Thats why i see her as the second most mature, even with her drama queen traits. 

 

I dont know wich of these three I would choose 

 

Pinkie i can see her as an super cool aunt xD  

[Widdershins 9,964]

AAA+ educationnnn.

   A-heh...yeah. Thing is, with Twilight as your parent I do doubt you'd be able to so much as leave the room without getting a book shoved in your snout! She does seem the sort to hammer in the importance of studying... even if you aren't currently in school.

   "Mooommm! Stop lecturing my friends on the semantics of Saddle Arabian culture; they only came over for cookies!!"

 

 

 

Be better than being raised by Treehugger

   Actually, that sounds pretty neat! As laid back as she is, you know she'd always be there to lend a comforting hug! And can you even imagine the bedtime lullabies you'd get as a foal? And... you know, she'd make a pretty cool parent in your teen years since she would be... rather more accepting of certain 'recreations.'

 

    Of course... then there's the times she insists on making you your own clothes out of "natural fibers."

  "Mom...It's winter, I need a scarf, not a daisy chain. It's two feet of snow outside, how did you even find flowers?!"

 

 

Edited February 4, 2017 by Widdershins

[Luigi 7,871]

Let's use process of elimination here.

 

Pinkie Pie obviously is a good babysitter, but she's still a little bit crazy, so not her.

 

Fluttershy already being good with animals is one thing, but taking care of a baby is a whole different story, plus obviously she's pretty shy.

 

Rainbow Dash is obviously the coolest pony around, but she won't always be there for me because she's a Wonderbolt now.

 

Applejack is always true to her word, but she can be pretty weird sometimes.

 

Twilight Sparkle is very nice, but there's still something about having a princess for a mother that I just don't like.

 

Then there's Rarity. (I don't think Starlight counts) Rarity is very beautiful. She's not crazy in any way, shape, or form, so if one of the mane six were to be my mother in Equestria, I'd hope it's Rarity. I imagine Rarity holding me in her warm forelegs just moments after I'm born, and Sweetie Belle looks into her nephew's eyes, then both my mother and my aunt each plant a kiss on my little cheek.

 

(Sorrry, this whole topic put me in a trance)

[Steve Piranha 29,496]

kinda makes you wonder who the father would be..

Flash Sentry because.... reasons 

[Ganondorf8 11,689]

Unfortunately, Sunset isn't an option so I'd have to make some alterations if I were to be reincarnated into the human world.