Imagine if Grimdarks ended up being canon in MLP canon?

[LittleHarmøny 34]

So I had this brewing in my mind.. What if Grimdarks like Cupcakes, Rainbow Factory, Apple sleep experiment, the more take Creepypastas like those; Imagine if they were canon? Or made canon in a way via the Cutie Remark.

Season 5 opens the idea of the smallest shift in the timeline would cause different Alternate universes

King Sombra, Changelings, Nightmare moon, etc.

So, think a small shift in the timeline that would end up causing each Creepypasta

Pinkamena, to Rainbow Factory

A whole new invented Rarity because LMR is pushing it haha

Discord's puppet, Vinyl, Octavia

All that! Twilight ends up meeting each creepypasta and has to evade each one, hijinxs insues, and the rest is up to the writing team to figure out

 

Haha I just thought this was a fun imagination moment

 

ALSO ALSO it would a musical part of the episode! Because of the Creepypasta.. songs.. and- Yeah!

[kyribun 34]

every time I see pinkie and rainbow alone my mind immediately goes to cupcakes lol  

[LittleHarmøny 34]

58 minutes ago, kyribun said:

every time I see pinkie and rainbow alone my mind immediately goes to cupcakes lol  

Hahahaha Same! Its just the common trope of P and RD in the same sentence

[Metemponychosis 1,259]

I would probably have stopped watching the cartoon much earlier.

But did you have any particularly interesting insight about any of that? Or are you just throwing the idea out there to see what people think?

Because I'm not particularly interested in the creepypast stuff, but I could live with higher version of the cartoon with a higher age rating and all that it entails.

[Espy Vibe 4,252]

I get queasy at really gorey stuff so I'd probably stay away from the show if it were specifically like that.

[kyribun 34]

2 hours ago, Metemponychosis said:

I would probably have stopped watching the cartoon much earlier.

But did you have any particularly interesting insight about any of that? Or are you just throwing the idea out there to see what people think?

Because I'm not particularly interested in the creepypast stuff, but I could live with higher version of the cartoon with a higher age rating and all that it entails.

completely agree, maybe even having two versions!! one rated y like normal and one rated teen maybe but honestly that would just cause plot issues ://

[Megas 27,566]

Thanks, I hate it

Edited August 16, 2023 by Megas

[EpicEnergy 23,174]

I probably wouldn't have watched it if I got that dark.