Superman vs Mane 6 (EoH allowed)

[TheUltimateAvenger 16]

Well seeing how it got kinda confused with the last one and it still remains meh in opinio. How about something more interesting.

 

Rules

1.) Mane 6 use all of their abilities and have EoH

2.) Fanon Speculation is allowed

3.) Only Golden Age, Post-Crisis, and New 52 Superman is allowed. Need it to be somewhat fair.

4.) Supes gotta face them all at the same time.

 

Lets see how this works out.

[silvadel 1,393]

Well first off the elements of harmony would not work against Superman. Superman is not evil, and is not against any of the things the elements represent so that would be meaningless.

 

That in itself would give the ponies pause to negotiate.

 

Regardless again I see an easy win for Superman. Only this time even easier.

[Lord Pretty Pie 64]

I can't imagine why they would get in a fight with Superman in the first place. I don't think Either side would win, because neither side would fight.

[Evilshy 5,090]

Twilight Sparkle synthesizes kryptonite in her room GG

 

In all seriousness, though, more details are needed. Where is this taking place? Does either side have information about the other (since superman didn't even know the mane 6 existed until this fight, and vice versa)? Do they get prep time? Are the in character? Is either side trying to kill? Have the ponies already tried to negotiate, and have concluded that fighting is the only way, or will they try to talk him down first (and same question for superman. Can't see him beating up on colorful ponies unless absolutely necessary)?

 

Sorry, years of debating on anime boards has made me take X vs Y topics quite seriously XD

Edited August 31, 2012 by Evilshy and His Own Ego

[TheUltimateAvenger 16]

Twilight Sparkle synthesizes kryptonite in her room GG

 

In all seriousness, though, more details are needed. Where is this taking place? Does either side have information about the other (since superman didn't even know the mane 6 existed until this fight, and vice versa)? Do they get prep time? Are the in character? Is either side trying to kill? Have the ponies already tried to negotiate, and have concluded that fighting is the only way, or will they try to talk him down first (and same question for superman. Can't see him beating up on colorful ponies unless absolutely necessary)?

 

Sorry, years of debating on anime boards has made me take X vs Y topics quite seriously XD

 

Well heres a scenario ive got

 

Mxyzptlk and Discord have finally met each other afte Discords imprisonement, they have a chat about heroes and what not and start to argue whos goody two shoes are better. So they decide to have a match up between the two sides, Superman and the Mane 6 are put onto a dead planet with good atmosphere and oxygen (And a yellow sun) they know nothing about each other. Mxyzptlk discovers that they wont fight each other so he makes the deal a little sweeter, whoever loses, loses the ones closest to them. All they have to do i knock the other out but killing is allowed. Both sides are hasty to reactions but ready to protect their loved ones. Mxy also says that the EoH are allowed but since they arent on the Planet if won affect him and Discord. So they start the match and go.

 

Thats all i got.

[silvadel 1,393]

Actually in that case myx would probably say "Sure go ahead and try to stone Discord if you like but you are just wasting time and power and then you would surely lose."

[TheUltimateAvenger 16]

Actually in that case myx would probably say "Sure go ahead and try to stone Discord if you like but you are just wasting time and power and then you would surely lose."

 

True, i doubt Mxyzptlk would be stupid enough to get hit by that beam while standing still.... then again this is the guy who constantly gets his butt sent back to the 5D Dimension because he keeps on saying his name backwards.

[Evilshy 5,090]

Well heres a scenario ive got

 

Mxyzptlk and Discord have finally met each other afte Discords imprisonement, they have a chat about heroes and what not and start to argue whos goody two shoes are better. So they decide to have a match up between the two sides, Superman and the Mane 6 are put onto a dead planet with good atmosphere and oxygen (And a yellow sun) they know nothing about each other. Mxyzptlk discovers that they wont fight each other so he makes the deal a little sweeter, whoever loses, loses the ones closest to them. All they have to do i knock the other out but killing is allowed. Both sides are hasty to reactions but ready to protect their loved ones. Mxy also says that the EoH are allowed but since they arent on the Planet if won affect him and Discord. So they start the match and go.

 

Thats all i got.

 

Superman takes it easily then. He's just so much faster than the Mane 6, he blitzes immediately. They wouldn't even have time to react.

[PonyEcho 1,610]

hhmm just out of curiosity is this just an attempted to make lightning strike twice trust me when i say this thread will be the same as the superman VS celestia one

 

also i play the trap card 'DC continuity' meaning action comics super man or at least use superman prime for evilness

 

Super man still wins due to his speed advantage he move around with and of the mane six noticing he only need to take one out

[TheUltimateAvenger 16]

hhmm just out of curiosity is this just an attempted to make lightning strike twice trust me when i say this thread will be the same as the superman VS celestia one

 

also i play the trap card 'DC continuity' meaning action comics super man or at least use superman prime for evilness

 

Super man still wins due to his speed advantage he move around with and of the mane six noticing he only need to take one out

 

... maybe.

 

But i thought it would be beter if i use the less powerful versions of Superman for this fight and have him face 6 opponents instead of one AND ones with actual feats. And i bored

 

Superman takes it easily then. He's just so much faster than the Mane 6, he blitzes immediately. They wouldn't even have time to react.

 

If you take in Supermans grasp not to kill even in the face of Death hed probably not Speed blitz them early on. And Golden age and New 52 Superman arent all that fast.

[silvadel 1,393]

I hate to say it but there is only ONE being in all of Equestria who would have any chance against Superman -- and that is Discord.

 

It would make for an interesting conversation though between the Mane 6 and a purposefully freed Discord trying to get him to help them after Superman had defeated Celestia. Their best chance would be in making it personal -- villians hate when an outside adversary comes in and defeats their hero.

[AppleTreeBrony 228]

What if the Element's of Harmony were made of Kryptonite? And they touched Superman with them.

(I'm just joking with you guys! ) Fillerdelphia

[TheUltimateAvenger 16]

I hate to say it but there is only ONE being in all of Equestria who would have any chance against Superman -- and that is Discord.

 

It would make for an interesting conversation though between the Mane 6 and a purposefully freed Discord trying to get him to help them after Superman had defeated Celestia. Their best chance would be in making it personal -- villians hate when an outside adversary comes in and defeats their hero.

 

But remember, Supes got Mxyzptlk (sorta) on his side, and he doesnt like it when someone tries to kill his favorite victim. THAT would be a fight though.

 

What if the Element's of Harmony were made of Kryptonite? And they touched Superman with them.

(I'm just joking with you guys! ) Fillerdelphia

 

It matters if the Elements of Harmony work on those who arent evil. If they do then they could take down Superman, though i dont hink he would stand still.

[Jason Achilles 2]

But remember, Supes got Mxyzptlk (sorta) on his side, and he doesnt like it when someone tries to kill his favorite victim. THAT would be a fight though.

 

 

It matters if the Elements of Harmony work on those who arent evil. If they do then they could take down Superman, though i dont hink he would stand still.

 

Well if you put it like that i guess it would be more even. Though i doubt if Superman, if hes affected by the EoH, can get away fast enough to not get turned to stone. Be a nice edition to the garden.

[XUNUSEDXXX 3,459]

I'm sorry, but the Mane 6 would all get pummeled to death if they got in a fight with Superman. Especially if there was no kryptonite around.

[Jason Achilles 2]

I'm sorry, but the Mane 6 would all get pummeled to death if they got in a fight with Superman. Especially if there was no kryptonite around.

 

Well he did say he was doing the weaker versions of Superman. And if its Early Golden Age Superman, its not gonna be that hard for the Ponies to beat him. He couldnt even fly back then.

[Zerul 554]

Fannon is allowed? Pinkie Pie solos.She has a good mix of ToonForce and Reality Warping but then again she's never used it offensively so Supes would probably stomp here too

Golden age was only faster than a Bullet,Rainbowdash was dodging instruments flying at her while she was inside a hurricane she could probably keep up for a while..

Edited September 2, 2012 by OdinForced

[I used to be a stranger 7,993]

I still don't understand if Superman can fly or if he just jumps really high.

Because if he can only jump, it's physically impossible for him to reach orbit unless he can double-jump like The Scout in Team Fortress 2 (generating extra thrust mid-air.) If he can only have one point of velocity change, his flight path couldn't be anything but parabolic and he would inevitably return to the Earth- and while at his apsis in space, he basically couldn't do anything other than sit there falling sideways.

 

What relevance does this have?

Well it's not every day people have a Superman discussion on this forum.

Edited September 2, 2012 by Blue

[TheUltimateAvenger 16]

Fannon is allowed? Pinkie Pie solos.She has a good mix of ToonForce and Reality Warping but then again she's never used it offensively so Supes would probably stomp here too

Golden age was only faster than a Bullet,Rainbowdash was dodging instruments flying at her while she was inside a hurricane she could probably keep up for a while..

 

Well even Golden Age Superman has some speed on him, though early on no he couldnt fly but that was REALLY early on, which became a moot point after 1941, but its unclear how fast he was but he was at least Mach 10 speeds and how some good reflexes.

 

And if Superman can beat Bugs Bunny in a crossover issue i dont Pinkies got what it takes.

 

I still don't understand if Superman can fly or if he just jumps really high.

Because if he can only jump, it's physically impossible for him to reach orbit unless he can double-jump like The Scout in Team Fortress 2 (generating extra thrust mid-air.) If he can only have one point of velocity change, his flight path couldn't be anything but parabolic and he would inevitably return to the Earth- and while at his apsis in space, he basically couldn't do anything other than sit there falling sideways.

 

What relevance does this have?

Well it's not every day people have a Superman discussion on this forum.

 

He could jump 1/4th of a mile in a single leap (Able to leap small Building in a single bound) later on he could 100% fly. He could breathe in space

[Zerul 554]

Well even Golden Age Superman has some speed on him, though early on no he couldnt fly but that was REALLY early on, which became a moot point after 1941, but its unclear how fast he was but he was at least Mach 10 speeds and how some good reflexes.

 

And if Superman can beat Bugs Bunny in a crossover issue i dont Pinkies got what it takes.

 

 

He could jump 1/4th of a mile in a single leap (Able to leap small Building in a single bound) later on he could 100% fly. He could breathe in space

 

Only 1/4? If he gets banished to the moon it's physically impossible for him to jump back to earth.

Full flight supes takes it eventually

 

Just because Storm beat Wonder Woman in a corssover issue that doesn't mean Storm>Wonderwoman. if you look at their actual feats Bugs would beat supes in about 10 seconds

Edited September 3, 2012 by OdinForced

[Dusty Soul 2,611]

Well I highly doubt they'd even battle at all... They'd probably just negotiate their terms and reach common ground... At least that's what I think.

[TheUltimateAvenger 16]

Only 1/4? If he gets banished to the moon it's physically impossible for him to jump back to earth.

Full flight supes takes it eventually

 

Just because Storm beat Wonder Woman in a corssover issue that doesn't mean Storm>Wonderwoman. if you look at their actual feats Bugs would beat supes in about 10 seconds

 

Well by beat i mean that Superman used common sense to kinda defeat some of Bugs over the topness. Like the whole "Oh no you wont oh yes you will" thing with a bomb that Bugs made up and Supes going "You're right i dont want it".. The look on Bugs face, PRICELESS.

 

Yeah he probably could, though Pinkie would get some good hits on him i doubt she has anything that would hurt him explicitly, unless she pulls a Nuclear Bomb out of her pocket. That and other Fanon interpretations such as Twilights magic and Rainbow Dash moving at the speed of light MAY prove early Supes downfall.

 

Well I highly doubt they'd even battle at all... They'd probably just negotiate their terms and reach common ground... At least that's what I think.

 

Already explained this in a scenario with another user, they are forced to fight or someone close to them DIES. So its kinda mandatory.

[Dusty Soul 2,611]

Well by beat i mean that Superman used common sense to kinda defeat some of Bugs over the topness. Like the whole "Oh no you wont oh yes you will" thing with a bomb that Bugs made up and Supes going "You're right i dont want it".. The look on Bugs face, PRICELESS.

 

Yeah he probably could, though Pinkie would get some good hits on him i doubt she has anything that would hurt him explicitly, unless she pulls a Nuclear Bomb out of her pocket. That and other Fanon interpretations such as Twilights magic and Rainbow Dash moving at the speed of light MAY prove early Supes downfall.

 

 

Already explained this in a scenario with another user, they are forced to fight or someone close to them DIES. So its kinda mandatory.

 

(oh sorry) Ok then I'll change my answer, I guess Superman would win, unless of course somehow they found kryptonite... So yeah I think superman would win.

[TheUltimateAvenger 16]

(oh sorry) Ok then I'll change my answer, I guess Superman would win, unless of course somehow they found kryptonite... So yeah I think superman would win.

 

Fair enough but i am allowing Fanon ponies (like the one in fan fiction stories and over ridiculous one) and the weaker Supermen to make it more even.

 

BTW perfectly fine just pointing it out.

Edited September 3, 2012 by TheUltimateAvenger

[Zerul 554]

Well by beat i mean that Superman used common sense to kinda defeat some of Bugs over the topness. Like the whole "Oh no you wont oh yes you will" thing with a bomb that Bugs made up and Supes going "You're right i dont want it".. The look on Bugs face, PRICELESS.

 

Yeah he probably could, though Pinkie would get some good hits on him i doubt she has anything that would hurt him explicitly, unless she pulls a Nuclear Bomb out of her pocket. That and other Fanon interpretations such as Twilights magic and Rainbow Dash moving at the speed of light MAY prove early Supes downfall.

 

Yeah ToonForce is pretty much all gags but that doesn't mean Supes can work his way around Cannon Bugs Bunny. LOL I've always wondered how Bugs would react to that.

 

Fannon speculation and Fannon are two different things.

Fannon Pinkie could would slaughter Supes no questions asked.Even Pre-Crisis Supes would be in for a hell of a fight against Hot Blooded Pinkie.

 

Fannon Speculation is what we THINK they can do based of their cannon feats.Then again Cannon Pinkie is probably as far from Violent as it gets xD I doubt she'd even know how to fight back properly despite her being perfectly capable of it.

Supes has dodged a single punch from the flash and goes Light-Speed casually I don't think that'll be enough IMO.Ignoring the fact that Supes could easily keep up with any form of the Mane 6 I doubt they have the reflexes to react to anything Supes can do