Pinkie or Fluttershy? Who is cuter?

[firekillerpwns 32]

well out of those videos pinkie pie because fluttershy got  annoying but not by those videos fluttershy i mean come on she's soooooo adorable

[Diamond* 531]

I don't think Pinkie Pie is cute at all. When it comes to crazyness then its Pinkie Pie. Fluttershy is the cutest pony in Equestria.

[~Luminiferous Ether~ 107]

Wait, what.

 

People thought Pinkie was cuter than Fluttershy what.

 

Honestly, Fluttershy wins the battle with sheer grace alone.

[Shred Guitar Brony 85]

I'm going with Fluttershy, I mean she's just the cutest, also her shy personality really relates with me. Although I like Pinkie too... Fluttershy is just another level of adorable!  

[Sunny Fox 5,961]

Wait, what.

 

People thought Pinkie was cuter than Fluttershy what.

 

Honestly, Fluttershy wins the battle with sheer grace alone.

But the question isn't who you find more graceful, it's who you find to be cuter. Just like the question isn't who you find more moe. Besides there is no battle to win. You can say Flutters is cuter, I can say Pinkie is cuter and we can both be right, it's just our perceptions.

[Bookworm Brony 2]

To be honest, I'd say Pinkie is (Far) more funny than she is cute, so I'm gonna have to go with Flutters on this one! I mean, I'm kind of like her, too. But you know, to each their own! 

[~Luminiferous Ether~ 107]

But the question isn't who you find more graceful, it's who you find to be cuter. Just like the question isn't who you find more moe. Besides there is no battle to win. You can say Flutters is cuter, I can say Pinkie is cuter and we can both be right, it's just our perceptions.

 

Eh, depends on your perception of cuteness I guess.

 

Like, I don't think people look good because of how they look, I prefer their personality.

[Gone Airborne 22,007]

Pshhh... yeah Fluttershy may be cute and all be she has nothing on Pinkie Pie.... 

 

 

Yeah you can't get any more Daaaww than that right there... end of story Pinkie Pie wins bar none :3

[Sony 106]

Of course Fluttershy with her fluttershy yay :3 even as a filly.... nothing beats fluttershy's adorableness when she is a filly

[dash360 102]

I would say Fluttershy, because im not to fond of loud things. Pinkie pie is still cool though. Plus Fluttershy is slowly taking over as my favorite.

[Shawn Parks 1,799]

It is difficult for me to look at the question objectively, because I love Pinkie Pie so much.  So, while I do vote for Pinkie Pie as the cuter pony, take that opinion with a grain of salt. 

[Smarts 1,626]

Fluttershy, hands down. Her very shy and caring personality are two factors that instantly make her cuter to me. Not only that, but it is also her soft and gentle voice that just melts my heart. It doesn't matter to me who you pit her up against. Fluttershy would always win as the cutest pony and that's a fact. At least in my eyes that is.

[Raiden21 804]

To me it is Fluttershy. Just her overall emotion and how she acts makes me go "awww". If it was her against Sweetie Belle, I don't know. Fluttershy's shy actions or Sweetie Belle's squeaky voice.

[NavelColt 22,883]

Rainbow Dash.

 

 

Of the two though, probably Pinkie. Referring to my Pony Cuteness Analysis chart, Fluttershy is the least unique style of cute, for me. It's classic, but to me, it's overdone. I'm partially biased because she's the least interesting of the six to me, but what can you do. 'Bubbly Cuteness' is more appealing to me than 'Vulnerable and Shy' cuteness.

 

Also, this seems like a Show Discussion thing. Moved.

[HunterTSN 1,444]

Obviously Sweetie Belle.

 

Out of the options though, Pinkie is much cuter, mostly because I hate Fluttershy beyond words can express.

 

What's that? Sweetie is an option? Hell yeah!

Edited July 16, 2013 by TheSteampunkNinja (TSN)

[hawkflame 3,315]

Why is everyone ignoring choice 3 in the poll?

 

SQUEAKY BELLE!

 

Seriously, try to listen to these and *not* go "D'awwww!

 

 

Pure adorableness.

[ReverseFaller 2,484]

Pinkie Pie can be cute, but not always. Fluttershy, on the other hand is always cute as hell in my opinion. Just her shyness, and the little things she does is cute, in general. I choose Fluttershy, but only by a little bit. P

[Onylex 2,837]

This should be an easy choice to anypony with good taste. Of corse its Fluttershy, Pinkie Pie is cute in a really annoying way but, how can you look past that soft voice and she is just way too cute when she was a filly.

Edited July 16, 2013 by Onylex

[Jokuc 8,174]

Well all three of them are very cute. Though I must say Pinkie Pie. And even though I am a Pinkie fan, it's not just that. Fluttershy is cute, but she is soooo shy and well I like some playfull...ness? And well the fact that Pinkie is happy almost all the time makes her very cute to me

[FadedSkies 1,874]

Both are so cute but i would go with Fluttershy. The first time i saw her i was like AWWW! She actually used to be my favourite pony. Hurricane Fluttershy kinda got me feeling all mushy. But i thought this was cute 

 

Edited July 16, 2013 by Dashie~

[Psychotic Muffin 86]

If you would've asked me when I was new too the fandom, no doubt Fluttershy. But after a change in opinions regarding the two of these ponies (Me being part of a rather "odd" group of writers on 4chan, that write about Fluttershy). Pinkie Pie now rather literally "takes the cake!"

 

And besides, all it takes is one look at my pic to know who I like best

Edited July 16, 2013 by BraveLilPyro

[FruitRiver 355]

I have to say Pinkie Pie. I like Fluttershy a lot, but I think Pinkie takes the cake. She is just so silly and adorable. I love how hard she tries just to get a smile out of her friends.

 

@Pyro

Haha, I said the same thing "Takes the cake" Having Pinkie Pies love for cake in mind.

Edited July 16, 2013 by Pinkie

[Ihei 714]

Fluttershy is best pony! (( Other than myself, of course. No one can beat me. ))

It's kind of weird that you have this poll, considering they're voiced by the same person. x3

[tranglam 28]

Fluttershy Fluttershy Fluttershy! Always the cuter one. No matter who you compare to. I'm not obsessed... Seriously...

 

It's mostly because of the voice and actions. I view submissive, calm, quiet, kinda needy as cute. I view loud, outgoing, partier as obnoxious...

[Psychotic Muffin 86]

Fluttershy is best pony! (( Other than myself, of course. No one can beat me. ))

It's kind of weird that you have this poll, considering they're voiced by the same person. x3

Obviously for controversy my good fellow! I guess what you could infer by pointing out that they are the same person, you could rephrase the question to "Which of Andrea Libman's performances do you believe is cuter?"