If you could trade your human life to live as a pony in Ponyville would you?

[Twilie 184]

If you could trade your life as a human to live as a pony in Ponyville (and take 2 people from the human world with you) would you do it and why?

[Messershmitt 289]

Yes because i could work at sweet apple acres for Applejack, id also Hang out With Pinkie pie, and id probably visit Twilight's Library

[repsol rave 2,963]

i would not.

as much as equestria sounds like the perfect place, humans are not perfect.

just look at earth, where humans are, tragic will follow. also, i don't think i can handle losing all my friends just like that.

[Cactus 155]

No. My Little Pony is a television show. I can have a bond with reality without needing an escape into delusion. I don't hate humanity; I understand it.

[Smarts 1,622]

As a famous purple pony once said. yesyesyesyesyesyesYES!

 

I would do it mainly because I hate humans in general. Also, I would probably be able to actually enjoy life for once living in a place full of happiness and friendship.

[Guest]

If i went to ponyville, chaos would ensue. The world of Equestria is a perfect one. I dont think I would fit into a perfect world.

[Fanned 88]

Aw HELL YEAH!!

**** THIS WORLD!!! I'M GONNA LIVE WITH THE DAMN PONIES AND I'M GONNA FIRKIN HUG THEM ALL!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

BECAUSE PONIES >>>>>>>>>>> HUMANS!! EVERY, GOD, DAMN, DAY!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

[ReverseFaller 2,483]

Yes! Ponies are awesome. People are boring, and violent. Ponies are just so freaking cool! Of course I would 

 

Looks like I need 15 more characters...PONIES!! 

[Fire Bomb 121]

I have no idea, while i would want to, i would have to leave most of my friends behind and start basically my entire live over considering it mainly is things that dont exist in equestria. but I have always wanted to have a more exciting live and when three different ponies try to destroy equestria in three years, not much else can top that.

[Limey 524]

I'm sorry, but I'm going to have to disagree with your first point.

 

i would not.

as much as equestria sounds like the perfect place, humans are not perfect.

just look at earth, where humans are, tragic will follow. also, i don't think i can handle losing all my friends just like that.

 

Humans aren't inherently evil. If we were, we would have wiped each-other out a long time ago. In fact, I'd argue that ponies are very similar psychologically to humans. There are good humans and there are humans that are jerks, and there are good ponies and ponies that are jerks. Trixie? Silver Spoon? Diamond Tiara? The two guys that used to annoy Rainbow Dash at school? I doubt 3 humans could turn Equestria into an apocalypse.

 

And at the end of the day, MLP is just a TV show, and does not represent a fully developed society. For all we know, there could be a couple of murderers and lunatics here and there, the same way the big cities such as Manehattan could have massive dirty slums. We don't know because it's never shown, mainly because of the 'show for little girls' thing.

 

If the above makes no sense at all, then I apologize. I haven't had much sleep recently.

 

But to answer your question OP, yes. I would. As selfish as it sounds, I probably would.

[Commissar Alexer 763]

No, thanks. I love being a human and would never trade it for anything else.

Why people hate being a human is something i probably will never understand.

Edited July 25, 2013 by Gefreiter

[Psychotic Muffin 86]

Without a second thought yes, mainly since I don't have many things I rather miss here. And all I'd want to do there is help Pinkie Pie with parties.

[Remi 1,309]

Yes, I would trade my human life to live in the Pony Realm.

Equestria, although a monarchy, everyone is treated equally. Normally, there is no racism, no hate, no crimes commited.

Since it is a child-based show, everyone is a happy being, with, normally, no means or intentions of harm.

As for 's question about why humans 'hate' being humans, I find that this is the reason.

Although we humans are the 'superior species', we still are very immature and incompetent.

Intellectually, we are living in an atomic age. Emotionally, we are still living in the Stone Age.

Us humans have hate inside us. We can hate others because of their race, thoughts, beliefs, sexuality, or even gender, simply because we can. None of those things can affect us or others in any way, so why do we hate others so?

Equestria is, as the name mentions, equal. Whether or not you are a Pegasus, Earth Pony, Unicorn, or an Alicorn, you are always an important part of society.

Here, on this planet we call Earth, we believe that it depends on how you are academically to show how important you will be to society in the future.

If Adolf Hitler, a single man, could lead millions of others to kill the Jewish, would you not agree that every single human can have a great impact on society?

Also, we have committed various terrible atrocities, such as the Holocaust.

There are normally, no wars in Equestria, unless you consider overriding Discord's tyranny over Equestria a war.

So, back to the question of Would you trade your human life to be a pony, along with two others?, I would, yes.

However, I am not quite sure as to whom I would bring. Probably , since she is my waifu.

Edited July 25, 2013 by The Paris Swing Cake

[Kyoshi Frost Wolf 41,473]

Yes. There are things about this world that I like of course, but, even with the possibilities of other negatives existing in that universe, is still seems so much better. Too bad it is impossible, because my life as it is, well, it is pretty pointless to say the least. I would take this opportunity immediately if I had the chance. Besides, as a whole, humans kinda suck.

[Mywas 687]

No.

I am too evil, selfish, Cruel, and selfish to be in equestria.

If I went there I would get the Trixie treatment and get kicked out of ponyvill

[Sylentmana 271]

There are approximately a dozen fantasy worlds I would rather live in than this one.  Equestria is one of them.  I would have to be a unicorn thought because I don't think I would be able to get over the loss of my fingers otherwise.

[Serbon div 386]

No thanks.

 

I'm gonna stay where I am, who I am.

 

Equestria is like Elysium. It's perfect, but doesn't exist.

 

It's just a TV show after all.

[Sergios117 192]

I love being human. The people that annoy me are a mosquito bite on an otherwise proud race. Misanthropes might disagree, but Rousseau is right that deep down, no human is born evil and that we are all redeemable. Yes there are those who seek to cause us pain but is it fair to say that it is the human race that causes misery, or a few individuals we pay too much attention to? Think about it, are we doing evil right now? Are your neighbors and friends plotting to kill our race as we speak?

 

Besides, people like Martin Luther King, Ghandi, Jesus, Einstein and Stephen Hawking are more likely to be remembered as examples of true members of the human race that wished to cause good for all.

 

 

I still would love to live in Equestria as some sort of second life I could go in between every now and then.

 

Scratch that, I want to live in a humanized equestria as my OC the most.

[Chain Combo 135]

I don't know it'd be a chance I'd never have again, but the pony world doesn't have a lot of things over the human world, other than the ponies themselves. I wouldn't be able to take my parents or friends they wouldn't agree to it. However in Equestria I wouldn't have to deal with prejudice, violence, greed, and most other flaws that mlp doesn't have that we have(I guess it's a trade off for the lack of technology). 

[Apocalyptic_Unicorn 240]

Yes, without a shadow of a doubt, yes. Earth just doesn't compare to Equestria at all.
Even though I love my friends and I'm pretty well off, it sounds incredibly selfish, but I wouldn't care about losing it all to go to Equestria.
As other people have mentioned here, the positives of Equestria in comparison to Earth are infinite. 

And one of the two people I take would definitely be my best friend, who also happens to be a Brony who would also love to go to Equestria.

... And erm, I'd love to get to know Vinyl.. Maybe.. 

[Prince Midnight 817]

yes i would, without a second throught, honestly i would go in search of sombra or nightmare moon, or even chrysalis, it wouldnt matter to me x3

[Planty 1,053]

Nah i couldn't,

 

There is no way that I could leave my friends and family behind! Friendship is just as magic in the real world as in equestria !

[Sergios117 192]

 

 

Normally, there is no racism, no hate, no crimes commited.

 

The ponies use mules and donkey as insults. That is racism to me. There is some incidental sexism as well but it is not intentional.

 

There are countless times in a show like in Putting Your Hoof Down where ponies were being relatively mean. The Mane 6 themselves resort to bad behavior at times.

 

Plus, you saw the way pony snobs acted in Manehatten and Canterlot, it just so happens that our show is focused on the most genuine examples for Ponies. If humans were a TV show and the main characters were Jesus, Martin Luther King, Ghandi, Einstein, Bill Gates or any other nice human, our race would look amazing.

 

 

 

If Adolf Hitler, a single man, could lead millions of others to kill the Jewish, would you not agree that every single human can have a great impact on society?

 

 

You forget ponykind has Trixie, Sunset Shimmer and Nightmare Moon. Because MLP is restrained by being a kids show, none of them are allowed to exhibit true behavior.

 

Plus, Equestria is a place where status quo is God. You couldn't change things, even for the better.

[Discordian 6,015]

Absolutely. Love or hate it there's little denying that for the most part Equestria is a simpler world and I would rather live in that sort of world than live in one where it becomes increasingly impossible to live if you don't have money.

[Remi 1,309]

@@Sergios117

Although those points are very well explained points, nothing is perfect. Although the Canterlot people are 'snobs', they, normally treat the other residents of Canterlot equally.

Ponyville treats every resident equally.

Cloudsdale treats every resident equally.

The points you have explained are such as the 'human' side of Equestria, and although it may not seem like the perfect place, it is still a very happy place.