which of these fan-games should I make first?

[Binary Blast 27]

Hi so I have 2 fan game ideas but it seems for the time being I only have the budget (and attention span of the rest of my team) to make one. I will get the other done eventually but I would really like to know which of these I should make right now.

 

1. A guitar hero style rhythm game with where you play as Vinyl Scratch and you must save Equestria with your music by Guitar Hero style playing various songs from the show, as well as remixes of them.

 

2. a top-down rouge-like dungeon crawler game, In this one twilight effs up a spell and the Mane6 get teleported to a secret dungeon underneath the Canterlot castle, as they try to escape they find some deep and disturbing secrets about the princess.

 

that's about all I'm going to spoil about the plots of either game, so please tell me which one I should start working on first. Thanks

[Billy-Rex 54]

It'd be nice to see a rhythm game like rhythm heaven /)°3°(\

[Moonlight 7,279]

I think the first one sounds better of the two. I love music games.