Who would win in a fight between the Mane Six? (without using magic!)

[Jeric 46,851]

Unicorns can have no magic ... but Pegasi can fly? In that scenario I have to go to Dash. If all Ponies were grounded and no magic was allowed, then I would say it would be a toss up between Rarity (aestheticism and strength are canon for her), AJ, and Dashie.  

[Gernia 691]

I side with RD due to her competitiveness and her overall speed. I think it will outmatch the others.

[Stone Cold Applejack 381]

Either Applejack or Rainbow Dash.

 

Applejack has spent many years bucking apples on her farm. So I'm sure her kicks a pretty powerful.

 

Then Rainbow Dash is fast. If she flew at you with that speed and punched you that'd feel like getting hit by a missle.

 

Also Applejack's stubborness and Rainbow Dash's competiveness will probably make them more prone to not giving up.

Edited January 17, 2015 by Semper Fi

[spade 88]

I'm so happy to see the Rarity love. Never underestimate anypony.

[inactive09 61]

If I'd where to consider everyones ability out of memory from the episodes (please correct me if I'm wrong)

 

Dashie's got the speed

Fluttershy's got the ability to turn agressive and dominant at points

Pinkie is able to break the fourth wall and she is unpredictable yes, but could also turn completely bat shit insane if she gets mad or sad.

AJ's a hard worker and can kick butt with her hind legs like it's nobody else's business
Rarity may be proper but it's proven she'd go trough dirt and hard work to get where she wants if needed, or in case of someone else (reminder from the time she proved herself to be a good sister to Sweetie Belle)
And Twily's got the brain even without her magic, and she is persistent.

So if I'd imagine a big brawl with all of them, I think Dashie would take the lead since she's got the brain of a winner and won't back down until she've given it all. But even Rarity and AJ would fight to get to where they want. Twilight would probably stay for quite some time in the battle but eventually drop out, she's a genius but not the physical power. Fluttershy would've gotten to a point where her dominance would get ruled out by Dash.

So all in all I think actually Rainbow Dash would win this one.

[Bird Mom 900]

A flying pony can be counted as magic, right? Assuming that, it would be between Pinkie Pie, Fluttershy(she's pretty mean when she wants to be), and Applejack.

 

1. Pinkie Pie: She has a party cannon, she can easily choke you with confetti as seen in Rainbow Rocks.

 

2. Fluttershy: So, do I need to explain? There's so many references to my claim in the show, it's not even necessary.

 

3. Applejack: She is easily one of the strongest ponies in Ponyville winning multiple 1st, 2nd, and 3rd place ribbons in the Equestrian Rodeo Competition(s).

 

Rainbow Dash isn't on this list because her main strength is flying, which would count as magic. Yes, I am aware that in Fall Weather Friends, she beat Applejack multiple times, and a few of those times were when she did use her wings, so it would count off a few times.

[KillerKingBakudan 702]

Twilight's too smart to get into this one without cheating. If she can't use her magic, she'll drop by Zecora's place and ask her to whip up a steroid potion.

But if we're to assume they get no prep-time, and it just happens, then it goes to Rainbow Dash. She tried to help Applebloom get a cutie mark in karate, and only a master could be in the position to do that. Plus, even without wings, she's still ridiculously fast.

[CupcakeEmpire 58]

Does this include "passive" magical abilities, such as pegasi being able to fly and the enhanced physical strengh of Earth ponies?  If so, I'd imagine that Rainbow Dash or Rarity, who both know martial arts, would emerge victorious.  If it's just an all-out brawl between them with no flying or such, I imagine one of the two ponies who actually know martial arts would excel.  

[knuckles 150]

Pinkie pie can win because she can warp to any location

 

I consider pinkie pie warping is ability rather than magic so she can use it freely in the fight

 

If the fight is without using magic or ability I think apple jack will win cause she have great strength :okiedokielokie:

[Arctofire 227]

If it was without magic, then Apple Jack. She is easily the strongest and most able bodied out of all of them.

[spade 88]

I almost forgot, Pinkie Pie never leaves home without her cannon.

 

Also anypony who can get the the mirror pool can double themselves exponentially. Game over.

[FluffyGoat13 375]

Fluttershy. Who said you needed to fight to win a fight? Hide. Wait until there is one person left. surprise stare attack.not even dash could beat a dragon. Stare = terrified dragon.

[Invincible 2,091]

RD will probably 'boom the shit out of everypony else. Though Pinkie can teleport through space and time and isn't subject to mortal physics. Ugh, i'm just not sure.

Edited January 20, 2015 by Sleepwalker

[KiwiPony 125]

Now then I think we all know when it comes to damage output RD will destroy, as has been said RD can literally crate the force of an atomic bomb HOWEVER does anypony really think Pinkie would be affected by it? Pinkie could just use pinkie sense and her weirdly unnatural speed of basically teleporting to move... We've seen in episodes like Griffon the Brush Off Pinkie can move as quick as RD when she was underneath RDs head in the opening scene. So, I always figured that Pinkie would be an unstoppable fighter... IF she ever faught... There is no way she would fight the others so I think the winner would be RD unless Pinkie wanted to show off her talents

[Sazama Ichida 2,367]

Kind of a tough question but my money's on Twilight. What she lacks in physical strength she makes up for greatly with intelligence and magic.

[Imagine 284]

Yikes, this is a toughie... All six would put up one hell of a fight. Okay, maybe not Rarity. My first thought immediately was Rainbow Dash, knowing how assertive and aggressive she is. Then, I thought about Twilight until I read on the title, "Without magic." The others do have their strengths and weaknesses, but in the end, I'm gonna go for Rainbow Dash, and Applejack as a close second. 

[Tao 7,756]

I'd have to go with AJ on this one given she is the toughest earth pony and

a peggy flying is magic so Dash would be grounded and not saying she could

hold her own,  AJ all around farm and tough girl!

[#1FluttershyFan 206]

I think it would be rainbow dash all the way. Her strength plus speed is not a force to challenge.

[Star Racer 198]

Obviously, twilight, rarity, and fluttershy would be out of the question.

However, rainbow dash has strength and speed, as well as stamina. Applejack has strength, a little less speed, and plenty of stamina. Pinkie pie can just break physics, so i wouldnt count her out.

In the end, i would have to say a tie between rainbow dash and pinkie, simply because rd has flight on her side, and pinkie is a wild card. You dont know what to expect.

[NFM2013 29]

Pinkie Pie, of course.

She can teleport at the speed of light, she have a party cannon,...

Game over for RD and AJ.