Pony Battle Thread

[TailsIsNotAlone 3,695]

If Scoots was fighting plain old Sweetie Belle, she would probably win.

 

But if she was up against Sweetie Bot? Different story.

[NavelColt 22,883]

This thread appears to be discussing MLP:FiM in some way, shape or form. Thus, it has been sentenced to Show Discussion.

 

This is an automatically generated message, by the way.

[zues986 3]

I voted scootaloo based on a 1v1 open brawl.  If the circumstances required more cunning(say a fight in the forest where hiding/traps and other things could be employed) then sweetie belle would probably win.  Also, applebloom could take them both

[Sir.Flutter Hooves 2,953]

So, guys it's been a week and Scootaloo has won! I knew it. Great job voting guys. This week, it's Fluttershy VS Applejack. Who do you guys think will win?  Vote up above!

 

The Winner:

 

Edited April 22, 2013 by Sir.Flutter Hooves

[Tual 152]

Applejack or Rarity? .o. Um. You wrote Rarity up there, but your status and the poll says Applejack..  

I'm guessing Applejack. I would also vote Applejack. She's got  a ton of physical strength, and probably wouldn't hold back. Fluttershy may have strength, but it's too hard to see her as a fighter. It REALLY pushes away from her personality, and whenever she's assertive in any way, she ends up being all shy again after, so she probably couldn't do it. :/ 

 

Applejack!  

[Shanks 10,816]

Applejack and not just because of favorite pony bias, seriously Applejack is a beast when it come to pure brute strength, has decent speed and her skills with a lasso will also prove very useful. Fluttershy is not much of a fighter and would really only stand a chance if she went into full rage mode which dosen't happen very often, she can fly but not that well so that wouldn't give her too much of an advantage.

[Rainbow Dash Loyalty 1,275]

Fluttershy and AJ this round huh?

My first thought was obviously going to Apple Jack since she's got a ton of strength with years of hard work on the farm and bucking millions of trees, but then again I just saw Fluttershy as a shy weakling without thinking about it. But then I remembered her advantages in a fight, she's got hundreds and thousands of animals on her side, even a bear to keep her back! Plus she's got her special movie,'The Stare' which basically works on everyone (except Discord xP). So I think Apple Jack might have a bit of trouble going through all that unless you don't count the animals on Fluttershy's side.

[zues986 3]

Well, again, if assuming 1v1 brawl, would have to vote for Applejack.  If they could call for help.......probably still Applejack, just because of big mac.....he could take most anything fluttershy could call upon.  Really though.....Fluttershy......fighting?  Meh.  Also, it says that I already voted in the poll and I don't actually remember voting.  Is there a way to find out who I voted for, when, and to change it to what I wanted to vote for if it isn't?

[Rainblow H. Ash 5,091]

Definitely Applejack. I like Fluttershy and all, but I seriously don't see how she could beat Applejack, even she was trying and wasn't scared or against fighting. Applejack has brute strength and is used to a rough and tumble lifestyle, and has been in a few brawls on the show and likely in her past. Fluttershy... well, she's used to nature, sure, but she avoids dangerous situations and prefers to settle things peacefully.

 

So...

 

Applejack wins!

 

[MyLittlePonyTales 273]

Hmmm... the poll claims I already voted, but I didn't vote in the AJ VS Fluttershy one, just the Scoots VS Sweetie one. I guess I can't change or update my vote even when the poll changes? :/ Well, I would choose Applejack, anyway. Fluttershy is just too sweet, even with her stare and random rage, she only does those things to defend others, not herself.

[Argumedies 1,748]

Fluttershy WINS!... ADOR-A-TALITY!! *squee*

 

Can't stop the cuteness overload

 

I can't wait till the new and improved fighting is magic

[zues986 3]

Hmmm... the poll claims I already voted, but I didn't vote in the AJ VS Fluttershy one, just the Scoots VS Sweetie one. I guess I can't change or update my vote even when the poll changes? :/ Well, I would choose Applejack, anyway. Fluttershy is just too sweet, even with her stare and random rage, she only does those things to defend others, not herself.

I guess I am not the only one this has happened to.  I've been thinking maybe it was a bleed vote from the previous poll, meaning it kept the vote in the same spot?  Other than that I don't know either.

[Phoenix237 353]

I'm here for my analysis

Like I mentioned on the previous battle post I will put my analysis and determin a winner.

I'll try to keep this short so let's start.

 

 

Applejack

Strengths/ Abilities:

•Applejack is an athletic pony, capable of running for long periods of time.

•After years of working at Sweet Apple acres she has developed strong rear legs. She is doubtfully the strongest of the mane six in terms of kicking abilities.

•She wields a lasso, which is strong enough to hold down most objects. She is very capable with this lasso and can even snare moving objects.

•She can handle herself in a fight as shown in the "Canterlot Wedding" episode.

 

Weaknesses:

•She prefers a fair fight and challenge instead of one where she has the advantage.

•Since she spends most of her time working it is possible that she never had time to improve her skills.

•She also suffers from a bad case of pride. This pride at time clouds her judgment and makes her make unwise decisions.

 

 

Fluttershy

Strengths/ Abilities:

•as a pegasus she can also manupilate the weather, though she does not seem to do that.

•She has "the Star" a glare that brings fear to the toughest of creatures.

•Most of the times she is kind and would not fight, but give her a reason, or push her too far and she will push back.

 

Weaknesses:

•She tends to relay on her friends when in a dangerous situation.

•She does not like fighting

•"the Stare" appears to only work on animals, however this can be disproven.

 

 

@Sir.Flutter Hooves

Why do you give me one sided fights to analyze.

(wait no on told me to do this. True but I want to. So stop complaining. Fine)

 

Anyways once again the fight is one sided. Combat wise Applejack has a huge advantage over Fluttershy. Not to mention most of the times when in danger Fluttershy relies on her friends to get her out of trouble.

 

Winner

Applejack

 

Edited April 24, 2013 by Phoenix237

[wickedjr89 7]

At first I thought "no contest Applejack is stronger" but then I thought of how weak and shy she is and no one wants to hurt her so I picked her thinking Applejack might feel sorry for her and let her win, plus she does have a lot of animals on her side to help her if it does become an all out brawl.

[Guest]

Fluttershy has animals on her side but applejack is much stronger and faster, not to mention fluttershy's passive nature.

[Antismurf9001 1,271]

Yeah, I'm not allowed to vote either, because I've apparently already voted...

 

Anyways, I'd bet on Applejack.  Fluttershy would probably refuse to fight, though her animal friends would try to defend her.  Even so, Applejack took down a pack of timberwolves; so bunnies, butterflies, birds, and a bear shouldn't pose too much of a problem.

[Almar ZeWizard 60]

I think Scootaloo Would win in a fight with Sweetiebelle, Scootaloo has the power of speed on her hoofs but if she were to lose her scooter I think Sweetiebelle Could cause some major damage but I don't think she knows any attack spells In case sweetiebelle can't do any attack spells then it would all lead up to a Hoof to Hoof fight And I think they both have the same amount of strength which could end in a tie,But I like scootaloo more so she would win.

[Concord Discord 35]

Fluttershy WINS!... ADOR-A-TALITY!! *squee*

 

Can't stop the cuteness overload

 

I can't wait till the new and improved fighting is magic

 

I agree, AJ wouldn't even be able to hit Fluttershy (the only time I ever could consider hitting her was in s2 ep2)

Plus, Fluttershy has THE STARE.

If it were any other fight, AJ would definitely win

[DarligPegasi 315]

I have to say Applejack because Fluttershy would probably forfeit as she wouldn't want to hurt her friend. But of course Applejack being as generous as she is might not even try to win and instead just make it so that they tie or something.

[Mr. Changeling 132]

I would have to go with Aj. Aj is the most atheletic pony, rivaling rainbow dash. And although fluttershy has the STARE, it wouldnt be enough to take down Aj. Sorry fluttershy, your to much of a subaru

[Half-Note 273]

Fluttershy would win. She just has to whip out THE STARE and it would all be over. Applejack May be more athletic but she can be intimidated just like any other pony.