What did you first think of each of the Mane 6 when you started to watch the show?

[Chespin 180]

Twilight Sparkle: An average bookworm who is a slave of Celestia.

Applejack: A average stereotypical southern pony.

Rainbow Dash: a super awesome radical pony.

Rarity: A stereotypical fashion star.

Fluttershy: A pony i thought was everyone's favorite pony, but in the end she's my 4th 5th favorite pony.

Pinkie Pie: A pony with ADHD.

Edited November 2, 2012 by Danger Dashie

[Brave Hooves 113]

My first was the pilot so

 

Twilight: NEEEERRRRRD! Prefers to be alone and into her own stuff, just like me, ok.

Pinkie: lolwut?

AJ: lol redneck. She's into incest for sure! ...nice pony though

RD: ok she's the cool one for sure

Rarity: ugh, the uptight drama queen bitch.

Fluttershy: ...that is the girliest thing I've ever seen, why am I watching thi- *squeek* DAAWWWWWW OMG SO ADORABLE I LOVE HER! <3 <3 <3 :3

 

I love them all now though. I remember when Rarity was generally the most hated pony

[MintyNinjaPrincess 21]

Twilight: ...I immediately loved her. She was my instant favorite because she and I agreed that "All the ponies in this town are CRAZY!" And to this day she is the pony that I most relate to.

 

Pinkie Pie: I admit. She annoyed me at first. But it was an entertained sort of annoyed. I thought she'd probably been kicked in the head as a foal yet still enjoyed having her arround. These days I feel like the show wouldn't be the same without her antics.

 

Applejack: I was completely indifferent towards her. I thought she was borring. But now I like her and her family a lot.

 

Rainbow Dash: Wasn't my favorite, but I instantly liked her mane. Now I like both her and her mane.

 

Rarity: She was my least favorite for a while because I thought she was shallow. I was VERY wrong.

 

Fluttershy: Instantly loved her because asdfghjKGAAAAHHH!! THE CUTE!! And I still think the same about her.

[Castoro Chiaro 181]

Twilight Sparkle - Seemed like a nice girl, so it irked me she was the butt-monkey for the first episode. I kind of felt her annoyance as I watched the episode XD

Applejack - LOVED her almost straight off the bat.

Pinkie Pie - Super annoying.

Fluttershy - Cute, but not all that interesting.

Rainbow Dash - Eh. She didn't make much of an impression.

Rarity - Same for her, I didn't think much of her.

 

(I like all of them now!)