Fanfic opinion: Choice in Love interest

[Mr. Critical 434]

     I am still in development for my fic, and I could use an opinion. My main character is a mute, intelligent human raise in a world of Bipedal Equine(Anthro Ponies). He was also raised along side Twilight, becoming a second Brother to her. So, as with most fanfics, there has to be some kind of love interest. For him, I was thinking of Pinkie. A hyper intelligent human mute, paired with a hyperactive... pony that talks continuously. What are your guys opinion on this?

[GaleFenrir 281]

Romantic couples need somethings in common with another. Yes, they can have contrasting traits, but you have to also consider what they share.

 

Chemistry is tricky like that.

[SharpWit 2,614]

I am painfully honest so don't get the idea that i'm just hating on you

 

1. Doesn't sound very interesting if it's just a love story

2. Anthro. Really? doesn't change the fact that they're only half human.

3. Sounds like something a teenager was daydreaming about while bored in class. in other words. unoriginal.

 

Sorry if it's harsh

[Away 2,077]

What would be the purpose of it? And that goes for adding ANYTHING to a story.

Edited April 5, 2014 by LatinoChurro

[Mr. Critical 434]

Hm, interesting. Pinkie is Hyperactive, ditzy but intelligent, and Generally fun to be around. Aaron is Calm, intelligent, and quite. VERY quiet. I should probably put some thought into it. Oh, its not a love story. ITs a HoE/anthro/retelling of the original series. ITs not about the lerb between the two characters. I was hoping to have it about the Human's experience as a brother to Twilight. Joining her adventure to Ponyville. HE's not an element, he's not a hero(yet), and he's not violent. He's just there for the ride.