She sigh as she watched them go back and forth between each other, even putting her hoof over her face after a while....stallions...
"Okay, listen you two. We need to break this down to its simpilist elements. Nightfall was the first friend I made here. He made some stupid...and I mean STUPID mistakes. They were, however, mistakes. They don't make him a bad pony. If he was a bad pony he wouldn't feel regret or remorse or try to make it as right as he can. He has suffered for what he has done. I don't even think he thought of what he was doing as rape when he did it. I think he just took advantage of a situation, which he now admits was wrong. Admitting he was wrong is what makes him a GOOD pony. I also don't think he would have ever done what he did if he knew we were related. I believe he truly wants to do whats best.
That being said, NIGHTFALL...stop being an arrogant jackass. If word got out about this kid being yours we would both be ruined. Whirlwind is willing to help us and I think you should be more grateful. Being Alicorns as we are, regardless of how power or not powerful we are, regardless of how royal or not royal we are, we are rare. Ponies notice us. We MUST tread careful."
She took a deep breath
"Whirlwind, I know you love me. I know that. I love you too and I am thankful for all you are willing to do for me, but your temper is so great and you let it guide you more time then not. I know you hate what he did. I know you hate how selfish he can seem but he is young, very young and you were almost as foolish in your younger days. Who knows where you would have been with me at your side. There is no sense on fighting over me with Nightfall or Nightfall fighting over me with you because I am not with ANY of you."
She motions to Vinyl.
"I'm with her and I'm happy with her now. I can't stop you both from trying to convince me to be with another, nor can I convince you to leave me be. I know neither of you can. Nightfall won't because I carry his bloodline inside me and you won't Whirlwind because you love me so much and because of our deep and rich history. I can't say what the future holds but I am happy where I am right now. The important thing to work together now. Whirlwind will claim the foal as his own regardless what it is. Nightfall, you will agree to this or I will kill the foal inside of me, right now, before your eyes. I won't risk destroying BOTH of our lives."
She took another deep breath
"Whirlwind, Nightfall will be apart of this foals life regardless your feelings on the subject. Maybe he messed up, but he is the gentlest pony I have ever met and the foal deserves to know who the other half of him or her is. Please Whirlwind...please do this for me. Do it for our little one we lost. Don;t ruin the future with hatred. This little one deserves better."
She looked between them for a few moments and lowered her head feeling exhausted. She had class in the morning and needed som rest. She stepped over to Vinyl and nuzzled her neck.
"I'm tired Vinyl, can you please teleport us home? My magic is spent."