MLP Forums Banner Contest Poll

[SCS 7,537]

Wasn't Adorkable's Twilight Sparkle banner supposed to be up after this one?

Yes. That banner will be up until the end of the voting period for this contest.

 

---

 

These are all great banners, and choosing one was a bit of a difficult decision for me. While they are all great, my favorites are numbers 11, 12, 14, and 15. I think 12 and 14 are well-made, and it's been some time since there's been a Luna banner. In fact, I can't remember off the top of my head the last time there was one, but I'm sure there must have been one at some point.

 

15 is excellently made, and is probably my second favorite overall. It's very high quality and beautiful, and the effect of Rarity twisting the fabric through MLP Forums is really cool.

 

However, I ended up deciding my favorite is 11, so I voted for that one. It's always nice to see banners with the entire mane six in them. The image itself is very high quality, the composition just flows naturally and makes sense, and the use of lighting is superb. I also love the stylization and coloring of the MLP Forums letters. Overall, the banner evokes a sense of calm within me, similar to how art from the show itself does. The fact that this banner so effectively captured and represented that spirit is probably the main reason why I voted for it.

[Ships are magic 8]

my personal favorite was 11! It looks so professional and well made that I just fell in love with it, good luck to the others who made banners

[Cherrijack 5]

I love 11 so much! The artistry and colours are very smooth! I think I'm going to make it into a magnet! 

[Vermillion 613]

none of them had trixie in 

but i voted for number 10 xD

[-Nobody- 519]

I voted for entry 6, but I won't mind if entry 11 wins. Both are really good.

[ghostfacekiller39 23,860]

When I was looking over them, I got to the bottom and said to myself "Well, I wonder which one Ghostie picked".

 

Since there was a major lacking of something Great and Powerful, out of the rest, 11 is the one I manely liked. 

 

 

Not making this up; right when I saw banner 15 I was like "Ghost is definitely voting for this one." Looks like I was right lol

I am tempted to vote for 11 because it looks like pinkie is about to lick that ladybug

One of these days, there will be two Rarity banners up for vote, and you people will have no clue which one I'll choose

[The Mane-iac 1,648]

One of these days, there will be two Rarity banners up for vote, and you people will have no clue which one I'll choose

 

The one with bedroom eyes. Or the one that has the best plot, because banners must have a good plot or no one will know what the site is about. 

[ghostfacekiller39 23,860]

The one with bedroom eyes. Or the one that has the best plot, because banners must have a good plot or no one will know what the site is about. 

...and I would've gotten away with it, too, if it wasn't for you meddling kids :okiedokielokie:

[Complexity 181]

There's a grammar mistake in Entry 4....

[Shayla (Cadance) 8]

How in the world do i look at the banners to make my pick 

[Complexity 181]

How in the world do i look at the banners to make my pick

 

Just gotta click on the spoiler tag.

[Omega Centauri 317]

I think that the banner should have all of the mane 6 in them, so I'm glad 11 is winning

Edited July 15, 2014 by Omega Centauri

[ghostfacekiller39 23,860]

1st place: 68 votes

 

2nd place: 19 votes

 

Number 11 is OP (._. )

[Guest90210 3,568]

Entry 2, 13, and 15 are my favorites.

 

- 2 has a good idea but I'm not a fan of the color scheme.

 

- 13 is really nice too.

 

- 15 is my choice in the end. I like the string going through the words, and the colors. Plus I don't think I've seen a Rarity banner in a while

Edited July 15, 2014 by Mutant X

[The Mane-iac 1,648]

1st place: 68 votes

 

2nd place: 19 votes

 

Number 11 is OP (._. )

 

11 Got my vote because of my OCD artistic tendencies. I won't point things out, I'll just say that I think it conveys the group unity the best, which is what a forum should be about.

[AppleLover 146]

I was torn between 14 and 12 and 4, but 14 won my vote. Who doesn't like a picture of Luna eating an apple. 

[eowyn3399 7]

How in the world do i look at the banners to make my pick 

SERIOUSLY! I can't find em anywhere!!!

[Jennabun 1,579]

Number 11 is where it's at!!! It's so beautiful. It has just the right amount of detail without being overwhelming. I love the eye-catching, yet classy font. I adore how the entire Mane 6 is featured. Most of all, I really enjoy how the artist utilized all the space and made the banner feel balanced. It's a stand-out all around. WIN, 11, WIN! *waves pom poms*

 

Edited July 15, 2014 by Jennabun

[rainbowdashbrony1 130]

none of them had trixie in 

but i voted for number 10 xD

Thanks for voting for my banner Spectral!

[Retired Commissar 305]

Number 10 is the best banner, in my opinion.

[Guest]

 

SERIOUSLY! I can't find em anywhere!!!

 

 

In the very first post, almost at the bottom, there's a little square button that says 'Spoilers', if you click it, below will show all the banners.

[WilsonWilson 11]

Hmm 11 is my favorite but all the banners are very good.

[The Crimson Cross 7,532]

Number 1 is quite good, picked it and noticed such little votes, went to see what the fuss was over No. 11 and damn. That's good! 

[Paianis 489]

I'll be honest, most of them seemed quite amateurish to me, compared to the usual efforts with the alternating banners. 15 was my fav of that bunch, as it had the stylised font without looking to cheesy.

[Zygen 6,066]

Man, all these banners are beautifully made! All very different overall, and all have something to like I find.

 

However I voted 11, just because it's just so well made looking! Something about it just appeals to me...