Would you still watch MLP if...

[Bronyshock 3]

It was set in World War II? Like it would be like The Pacific HBO mini seris. Would you still watch it? I for one would still watch it. Who knows if it was like that, could be interesting. So would you still watch it?

[(MARVEL) Blue Blood 991]

An odd premise, but it would make better fan material than actual show material.

[OkBuddy 586]

As long as the writing is still good, I would probably stick with it.

[Pinkamena-Pills 6,840]

That..is a odd premise. 

 

Does it still have Pinkie in it? If so then im going to watch it and enjoy as she brings smiles to the theater of war. 

Edited August 30, 2014 by Pinkamena-Pills

[Commissar Alexer 764]

Wait!

 

Do you mean ponies fighting with the axis or against them?

[ghostfacekiller39 23,882]

Rarity.

 

Don't care. Just gimme ze waifu.

[Banul 3,831]

Probably not. I'm kind of tired of World War 2, and the idea of shoving the ponies into it is just....eh. Ponies wouldn't improve WW2 and WW2 wouldn't improve ponies. I don't see it working out.

[Bronyshock 3]

That..is a odd premise.

 

Does it still have Pinkie in it? If so then im going to watch it and enjoy as she brings smiles to the theater of war.

Yes it would. She'd be a flamethrower wielding marine. Saw that in some fan art and know it makes sense.

[Pinkamena-Pills 6,840]

 

 

Yes it would. She'd be a flamethrower wielding marine.

 

Spreading the flames of joy of-course. Everyone needs to feel the flames of joy..it burns..and it feels good.

[Bronyshock 3]

Spreading the flames of joy of-course. Everyone needs to feel the flames of joy..it burns..and it feels good.

No spreading the flames of napalm in Japanese pill boxes. Not very joyful on the Japs end.

Wait!

 

Do you mean ponies fighting with the axis or against them?

Fighting for the allies. Fighting on Okinawa in WWII.

[Espurr 449]

Maybe? I don't know. It probably wouldn't have interested me if that's how it originally started out. I probably would have been like:

 

A new My little pony show? Oh. Well, back to Pokémon.

 

Wars don't interest me. Unless it's fire emblem awakening.

[Pinkamena-Pills 6,840]

 

 

No spreading the flames of napalm in Japanese pill boxes. Not very joyful on the Japs end.

 

Who said Pinkie must adhere to the logic of your illogical proposal? 

[Bronyshock 3]

Who said Pinkie must adhere to the logic of your illogical proposal?

Pinkie must listen to here superiors. If they say to burn out a pill box she has an order to fulfill and if she didn't her fellow marines would die. But she wouldn't be sad she would be the marine that makes everyone laugh.

[Jeric 46,894]

If there was a chance that THIS image would be a reality on screen ...

 

[Soldier Surplus 232]

Don't knock it til' you try it I guess. It sounds interesting enough

[Jeric 46,894]

Pinkie must listen to here superiors.

 

Not if she is General Pinkie.

 

She is a bit out there are times as most great Generals were ... perfect MacArthur if you ask me.

 

 

[Pinkamena-Pills 6,840]

 

 

Pinkie must listen to here superiors.

 

Not really,but i digress. 

 

 

 

the marine that makes everyone laugh.

 

As out of place as this premise is to begin with,fair enough considering the theme i guess. 

[碇 シンジン 27,442]

Not if she General Pinkie.

 

 

 

Something like this maybe?

 

[Bronyshock 3]

Not if she General Pinkie.

 

She is a bit out there are times as most great Generals were ... perfect MacArthur if you ask me.

No she'd be an enlisted member of the USMC. Generals didn't fight much less given flamethrowers that if hit with a bullet would turn them into the sun.

[Jeric 46,894]

No she'd be an enlisted member of the USMC. Generals didn't fight much less given flamethrowers that if hit with a bullet would turn them into the sun.

 

Forget the flame throwers ... and I do have to change Generals ... Pinkie is more of a Patton.

 

Patton did lead from the front.

[Bronyshock 3]

Forget the flame throwers ... and I do have to change Generals ... Pinkie is more of a Patton.

 

Patton did lead from the front.

Patton wasn't on the front line fighting. He was in a base. He wasn't given a rifle and told to kill the enemy.

[Jeric 46,894]

Patton wasn't on the front line fighting. He was in a base. He wasn't given a rifle and told to kill the enemy.

 

There was no Allied base near the Sauer. His TD relied on drops and basic supply lines at that point.

 

Anyway ... Generals in Equestria World War 2 mash up do fight on the front lines ... cause reasons!

[Bronyshock 3]

There was no Allied base near the Sauer. His TD relied on drops and basic supply lines at that point.

 

Anyway ... Generals in Equestria World War 2 mash up do fight on the front lines ... cause reasons!

No they wouldn't. If a general died then the whole marine organization would collapse.

[Jeric 46,894]

No they wouldn't. If a general died then the whole marine organization would collapse.

Nah, they just get pelted with pies and POW's get held temporarily in Tartarus or a nexus like Celestia's YouTube Heaven

[Bronyshock 3]

Nah, they just get pelted with pies and POW's get held temporarily in Tartarus or a nexus like Celestia's YouTube Heaven

No it'd be real war. With bullets and bombs and ponies dying all around you. I'd watch it if the writing was good and it was realistic. But your version I wouldn't watch. No offence.