What do you think about Cupcakes?

[Steelfire Strings 27]

Cliche, OOC, boring, more plot holes than a block of Swiss cheese.

 

The only benefit is that it spawned "A Precious Rainbow." (DEM FEELS)

[Odyssey 5,719]

The fanfic is terrible, but the video (Is it the MisterDavie version?) is simply hilarious. In my opinion, what I thought the video did better was all of the torture was not played seriously, which kind of feels like a parody of the fanfic itself. Not only that, but the torture is fast-paced and doesn't mourn over the sight of a gory pony for too long. I've always had a thing for black comedy, so I had so much fun watching this version of Cupcakes.

[spits 71]

I'm not much into grimdark stuff.  I'm curious though as to where the show originated and whose brain child it is.

[nevergrowingup 28]

I hate anything gruesome, I'm scared of sharp objects and surgery alive, I read the first paragraph and nearly cried. Yup.

[Mirror Silver Spoon 125]

I hate Cupcakes. Too scary.

[The Shyest One 808]

I read the fanfiction, but gave the videos a big NOPE.

 

I could read grimdark, but seeing is what really gives me the jeebies. 

 

 I've read other fimfics with more gore and insanity. To me, it was only all right.

[Simon 4,557]

@@-ThunderChaser-,

 

We already have a thread about Cupcakes here: http://mlpforums.com/topic/45684-your-thoughts-on-cupcakes-creepypasta/

 

As a result, I've locked this thread, but feel free to continue the discussion over on the original thread.