Who is prettier?

[Wicked Funky 2,955]

I just wanted to say something unrelated to the actual question...

 

WHAT IS HAPPENING TO APPLEJACKS LEG IN THAT IMAGE?

[4april 374]

Who is prettier, appealing applejack or regular rarity?

 

 

Of course Rarity. It is always Rarity.!

She is the reason why I started watching mlp!

[Script Dangles 231]

Wow.  Tough call.  Can I just choose Fluttershy, instead?  

Okay, okay.  With just the two choices given...I'll go Rarity.  But if it was between regular AJ and Rarity...it's a dead heat, in my book.

[Chronamut 355]

I just wanted to say something unrelated to the actual question...

 

WHAT IS HAPPENING TO APPLEJACKS LEG IN THAT IMAGE?

she has her back shoulder to the "camera"

 

it took me a while to figure that out too - she is looking past her shoulder and blowing a kiss with the other hoof.

 

Also I find it amazing that people say that rarity is less "fake looking" - farmer rarity was probably as normal as rarity will ever get.

 

EVERYTHING about raritys appearance is fake.

 

She curls her mane and tail - she wears eye shadow and fake eyelashes - her entire construct is "enhanced".

[azbat 301]

AJ and Rarity always remind me of Betty & Veronica, which may explain why they are my two favorite of the mane 6.

 

I believe Rarity is prettier, but baby Applejack has caused more diabetes.

 

The shading on Rarity's tail and mane give her a 3-D look and everyone else looks flat in comparison.

 

The show's artists have put more effort into her design and it fits her character. She is literally high maintenance.

[cider float 2,537]

I'm going to go with Rarity.

 

Because dat voice...

 

 

[Radiance64 7,052]

Rarity man... Rarity 5ever

Though I gotta say, blonde hair/green eyes does something for me too, so Applejack also looks great, 'appealing' or otherwise.

[redshell 195]

Applejack no question that is the only answer I will give

[碇 シンジン 27,427]

Rarity is the prettiest no one can mach the lovely divine beauty that emerges from her

[Chronamut 355]

haha it is quite a heated debate - there are def. more applejack supporters than I would have expected