Pinkie Pie or Fluttershy?

[Dusty Soul 2,611]

FLUTTERSHY all the way!

[x Fluttering 14]

Fluttershy! I love PInkie though.

[RoadtoEquestria 59]

I'd probably pick Fluttershy because I can relate with her.

 

Pinkie is quite amazingly awesome though...

[Frankenbrony 16]

I don't know. Part of my problem with the whole best pony issue is that it's too much like apples and oranges. They are far too complex as characters to simply pick a favorite.

 

I love Fluttershy for her gentleness, kindness, and her etherial nature. She is like the Audrey Hepburn of the pony universe. And she can make me laugh too. Her episodes often turn out to be the funniest, and her personality serves to accent the humor of situations. That's why I liked "Putting your Hoof Down", "Green Isn't your Color" and "Stare Master" so much. Any episode starring Fluttershy is great, really.

 

I love Pinkie Pie for completely different reasons. While I like Fluttershy's soft-spokenness, I like Pinkie Pie's out-goingness. At first I just liked her because she was funny, but after watching "A Friend Indeed" and "Cutie Mark Chronicles", I began to see how much deeper she really is as a character. She spends so much time pursuing laughter, because laughter really is an important part of life. And we can see how selfless she is in her desire to make others smile. She'll do anything to bring cheer into the life of someone who is unhappy, and loves everyone unconditionally from the first time she meets them (i.e. Cranky Doodle Donkey). If there were more Pinkie Pies in this world, things would be much better.

 

I wouldn't want Fluttershy to be as hyper and bubbly as Pinkie Pie, and I wouldn't want Pinkie Pie to be shy and quiet like Fluttershy. What I would like to see are some episodes that feature mainly the two of them together. I think they would be a great pair.

[Scootaloo Is Best Filly 578]

This was a very hard choice for me . I really do love Pinkie Pie and Fluttershy about the same. If I have to choose though I think I'll go with Pinkie Pie.

[Drehgunklew 136]

Fluttershy of course. She's so cute :3

[Sorte95 46]

I voted Fluttershy because I like Fluttershy more than I like Pinkie Pie.

[Dose Most 4]

pinkie pie for sure. she has some of the best scenes in the series

[EWAN 31]

I have to go with Fluttershy.

[Shankveld 4,949]

Pinkie Pie,

Fluttershy is too cliché.

Pinkie Pie is always full of surprises and her episodes are some of the best ~

[Tom 891]

It's a tough choice, but I chose Fluttershy because she's losing the poll.

[SStwins 7]

I'd say Fluttershy. I don't know... she's so nice! And just so awesome! Its hard to explain.

[moneyshredderofdeath 414]

I think my avatar says all. Flutter's my favorite pony period, seeing as she's downright adorable plus I find her character quite relatable. Quite shy myself and I'm also fond of nature.

 

That being said though I do enjoy Pinkie. Her antics are quite amusing.

[Nikodemos 25]

Fluttershy, just cause.

[DeletedAcc 64]

Yeah, I'm gonna have to go with Pinkie on this one. Fluttershy may be cuter than a box of kittens, but Pinkie really gives this show a kicker. She is what gives the show it's energy.

[FairyDust 0]

Hard choice.. but my vote goes for Pinkie Pie! Shes so cute asdfghjkl.

[squee_ 6]

pinkie. hands down.

Edited July 4, 2012 by squee_

[Proctra Music 335]

Definately Pinkie. Just her being the most funny, most well animated. Her antics.

[Cupcake Ice Cream 436]

Pinkie Pie is indeed best pony. I loved her from the first moment and still do today. For a short time Rarity threatened to take over the number one spot but I just couldn't do it

[FruitRiver 355]

People that dont like pinkie....I dont understand them.

How can you not like pinkie?

Edited July 4, 2012 by pinkie

[Filly Pinkie Pie 208]

Pinkie Pie, duh!

She's like me, she has a great singing voice, she's my favorite pony, so yeah!

PINKIE PIE ROCKS!

[Carolina 212]

Pinkie Pie. Both are awesome, though!

[FruitRiver 355]

The weird thing is Fluttershy is the most popular pony, but shes losing to pinkie pie!

[Dundermiffly 27]

Fluttershy!

[Xievie 498]

Flutterpie? Pinkie Shy?

 

This is a tough question. You have comedic relief and Cuteness overload.

 

Though, I can find Pinkie Cute, and Fluttershy funny.

 

I have no answer to this. Don't want to get the stare, or be turned into a cupcake, now do I?