What Would You Change/Rewrite About The Aspect of MLP:FIM?

[SunsetShimmerStan 35]

On 2024-04-20 at 4:36 PM, Props Valroa said:

I've stated many times what I would change. Main aspect is having no Student 6, No Pillars, no School of Friendship. Also Grogar would be real, remove any instances of the villains calling themselves villains - and have more focus on background characters and world-building. That about covers the vast majority of where my focus would be.

Then how would we get the moments of exploring other species? Like, how would we get to see more interactions between different species without the Student Six?

[SunsetShimmerStan 35]

On 2024-04-20 at 4:36 PM, Cheerilee said:

I've stated many times what I would change. Main aspect is having no Student 6, No Pillars, no School of Friendship. Also Grogar would be real, remove any instances of the villains calling themselves villains - and have more focus on background characters and world-building. That about covers the vast majority of where my focus would be.

So then what would have been the main plot for seasons 7 and 8 without the Pillars and School of Friendship? Like what would take the place of being the two-parter finale for seasons 7 and 8 and the season 8 premiere two-parter? As well as who the main villains for seasons 7 and 8 would be?

How come you don't like the idea of having more than one group of six friends who have the magic of friendship?

[Megas 27,568]

Newbie Dash gets obliterated from existence. Of all the episodes they had to drop the ball on....

Like, even having RD become a WB offscreen would have been much better than what they decided churn out

[Rafa Stary 2,894]

Now that I'm not a fan anymore, I must say that I would've changed a lot of things, so many things that the show would pretty much be completely different, and I don't think that would be necessary as a lot of people like the show the way it is, so I prefer to not say what would've changed now, but I'll say that I still keep the things I said that I would've changed when I was still a fan, whcih are:

1: The Student Six should've more time to develop their characters, the way it was done was too fast, they learned things too fast.

2: Twilight shouldn't have become Ruler of Equestria in the end of the show, for me Celestia and Luna were better because I saw them as deities, Twilight should continue in her csstle in Ponyville.

3: Make more 13 episodes for Season 3

4: This one is the worst for me, for me it was really a bad idea to focus so much in Nostalgia, Fanservice and in rehashing ideas from previous Seasons in Seasons 5-6 and specially Season 9, repeating ideas from old episodes in a less interesting way and bringing back villains we already saw, in Season 5's finale they go back in time and show us a past event we already saw and show us past villains again, Season 6's beginning is King Sombra's attack but without him and Season 6's finale repeats the attack of the Changelings, Season 9 does worse by making us believe that they are going to have a final original villain, Grogar, but they reveal that he's not real, the final villains of the series are 3 villains we already saw before, that was a very bad decision in my opinion, specially because none of them brought anything new, they should've been minions of Grogar in my opinion, with Grogar bejng the final threat. I have the same problem with Dragon Ball Super, but there the returning villains at least bring something new, it was more creative, here in FiM they don't do anything new with the returning villains, it's worse, Season 9 felt more like a celebration of the entire series with its returning villains and characters and repeated ideas than a season that actually tries to tell a story, which maybe makes sense for the final Season of the series, but I still didn't like it very much.

That's pretty much it, I actually don't care much about these things anymore now that I'm no more a fan, but I still think would've made these changes if I had the opportunity 

Edited October 16 by Rafa Stary Mini