Removing One of the Mane 6?

[Arrow 236]

Of course you can't remove any of them without it being noticeable, but I'd pick Fluttershy, she'd be forgotten soon enough after her house is made inte a local disco.

[Sunny Fox 5,950]

Of course you can't remove any of them without it being noticeable, but I'd pick Fluttershy, she'd be forgotten soon enough after her house is made inte a local disco.

 

What about all the animals she cares for?

[Arrow 236]

What about all the animals she cares for?

 

Well, they'd just move out while creating an army, conquering the Everfree Forest in progress :3

[Juggler 345]

I couldn't remove anypony. I would miss her too much

[Leo dash 79]

rarity first fluttershy secound

[Zerul 554]

It wouldn't be MLP without them lol

But probably Rarity.. I hope this whole thread doesn't offend any Rarity fans

Edited July 14, 2012 by OdinForced

[shotoku 47]

Rainbow Dash easily, because that means she finally joined the Wonderbolts and is traveling all over Equestria fulfilling her dream, happy ending.

[WhenI'mDerpy 0]

Ok, so I decided to make this to see if the show would still be complete without our beloved ponies and Spike. Personally, I would boot Rarity, seeing she doesn't exactly make a difference to the show.

[Clarity 3,094]

Please, don't even make topics like this. The "least favorite pony" thread is already enough, but saying about booting somepony from the show...I can't imagine the flamewars that would be caused here.

 

ALL of the ponies are absolutely ESSENTIAL to the show. Even if my least favorite character is booted, it wouldn't be the same. Again, don't make topics like this, please.

Edited September 25, 2012 by Clarity

[Flying Whales 311]

I agree with the above statement, but I’ll humor the question. *deep breath* I’d have to say Spike, I’m sorry, I love Spike, I really do, I love his sarcasm and his antics but as far as plot goes the show does not need Spike. That was kind of hard to say as I’m a big fan but, that’s who I’d boot.

[One 498]

I think this is a great thread. What ever those above statements are talking about is nonsense,

 

I'm gonna have to say Spike, so now Twilight can write her own letters.

[Verde Wub 52]

You could possibly change it to something along the lines of what would you change about a pony from the Mane 6 if you had to or could, that way it makes people happier, but I'd have to say Spike too, just because of the importance to all the ponies. (It's painful to say because such a good character.)

[ceresbane 61]

no shining armour? that sucks... I woulda had him gone above all else. I just hate his existence because he essentially has no purpose for existing.

 

Captain of the royal guard? great work on fightin off the horde of changelings that 6 little girls can beat up en masse. The guys useless.

 

Naturally cadence would follow.

Edited September 25, 2012 by ceresbane

[Starshine 16,333]

What, you can't pick Snips or Snails or maybe Diamond Tiara? That sucks

 

if I really had to choose one to remove, then I'll pick Derpy... At least the main story can still continues without her

[ToridAkbolto 170]

Sorry spike, looks like according to the poll you're the least favorite pony on the show. And you're not even a pony... Life really sucks.

[aaaaaaaaaaaaaaa 55]

a

Edited April 16, 2022 by throw

[spas-ticShotty 3,584]

What, you can't pick Snips or Snails or maybe Diamond Tiara? That sucks

 

if I really had to choose one to remove, then I'll pick Derpy... At least the main story can still continues without her

 

Great minds think a like. I really don't think Derpy is essential enough for the show. However, I don't actually wish her gone, I just think she's not needed. Maybe I'm still butthurt that she took the spotlight in one of AJ's very few dedicated episodes -_-

[Starshine 16,333]

Seems like a certain someone voted to remove everypony but Derpy

 

What would the show looks like if everypony got replaced by Derpy Hooves and her clones?

[Clarity 3,094]

@,

Seems like a certain someone voted to remove everypony but Derpy

 

What would the show looks like if everypony got replaced by Derpy Hooves and her clones?

 

I would just quit watching, because I don't like her. Come at me, fans.

@,

I'm moar butthurt than you!

 

Anyway, since everyone else is voting, I'll vote. I still don't think this thread is fair, but I'll give my opinion on it.

Derpy is unneeded, I don't even need to explain.

Well...everypony else is still needed.

Edited September 25, 2012 by Clarity

[Acoustic Cloud 2,202]

Ugh... i loved those ones all too much, normally i'd say spike, but too many puns have been done with him to say he needs to go, i like all the mane 6 too much, and i like Derpy

ahhh! I'll just put celestia....

Though that's not a real answer

if i chose anypony it would be diamond tiara.

[spas-ticShotty 3,584]

@,

I would just quite watching, because I don't like her.

@,

I'm moar butthurt than you!

 

Anyway, since everyone else is voting, I'll vote. I still don't think this thread is fair, but I'll give my opinion on it.

Derpy is unneeded, I don't even need to explain.

Well...everypony else is still needed.

 

Someone's still striving to be the #1 AJ fan . Nice try, missy

 

Anyways....

Seems like a certain someone voted to remove everypony but Derpy

 

What would the show looks like if everypony got replaced by Derpy Hooves and her clones?

 

Shit would go down. It'd be an even bigger mess than when Discord transformed Ponyville into Chaos Central .

 

Also, off-topic, but am I the only one who HATES the name "Ponyville"? It's just so bland an generic.

Edited September 25, 2012 by spas-ticShotty

[Gone Airbourne 21,977]

Not going to receive a vote from me... eeynope... Every character is unique & love each one for who they are individually. No need to boot anypony/critter from the show.

[Clarity 3,094]

Why is Applejack the second most chosen? I don't think anypony notices just how much AJ does for the group. She's like the glue that holds the group together and the best supporting friend there is.

 

I think this is just another best pony poll. Disappointing...

[Yellow Diamond 7,569]

The recent thread regarding removing one of the Mane Six or major character from the sho was merged with an older thread which discussed practically the same topic. Therefore, if you voted in the new thread, make sure to recast your vote---unless you voted in the old one previously.

[Starshine 16,333]

The recent thread regarding removing one of the Mane Six or major character from the sho was merged with an older thread which discussed practically the same topic. Therefore, if you voted in the new thread, make sure to recast your vote---unless you voted in the old one previously.

 

 

I voted to remove Derpy, how in the white Cloudsdale do I recast my vote? D:

 

Oh well, I guess Rainbow Dash- err i mean Rarity should go away