What would you chose?

[Modphase 1,271]

A question for OP before I commence a huge rant. Would you stay as a human, or would you be turned into a pony?

[silvadel 1,393]

Take the mystery box. In this case there is some genuine reason why they need you specifically in ponyville and you are starting on request of the mane 6 so you are not just going to be random pony #745.

[SonOfTheNorthe 412]

I'd drop everything and go. I'd be all "BYE MOM AND DAD, I'M LEAVING AND NEVER COMING BACK!"

And then I'd walk through the portal right in front of their faces.

 

And my special talent in this life is my special talent there?

God, I'm gonna be a blank flank forever.

[Mcayon 24]

At the moment I'd be very unsure about it... but I think I'd go with them, to escape everything bad here on earth. Sure, I'd like to bring something with me... but I think still having my memories would be a good compromise...

[pactor 29]

As fun as it would be to live in ponyville I would have to decline. It would e horrible to just leave my family like that.

[silvadel 1,393]

I think a lot of what goes into decisions like this is how deep the hoofprints are that you have etched upon the world.

[XUNUSEDXXX 3,459]

meh, i dont know. living in ponyville would be pretty awesome and life seems alot better there, but i dont know.

[OptimisticNeighsayer 478]

Dang, I can't bring anything but my memories? I wanted to smuggle in a few tomes to contribute to Twilight's library!

 

I'd go there just to figure out what my actual talent is, since I really don't know what it is in this world... so yes, of course I'd go.

[Commander Bubbles 1,343]

With all the shit I have going for me, leaving my world to Equestria would be pretty much impossible. Couldn't possibly abandon my studies, friends, and family for some magical world and bliss for myself.

Edited August 19, 2012 by La Li Lu Le Lo

[Liris 714 0]

I would totally go and i would not use my two days, i would rather leave without anything except a note saying what i thought of everyone and why i left.

[Charming Knight 56]

ya i would take that offer up... i don't got much of a family here any ways... nor do i have much friends here honestly everything that i had known family and friends are not even here nor true any more to me... to start over in a new place is something i would like... a brand new fresh start...that's what i need... but that's just me ya know...

[Batbrony 16,055]

Yeah, I'd definitely choose to stay here on Earth. As much as I love the ponies, I don't love them enough to leave everything here on Earth, my friends and family, behind. Plus, I'm just about to start my senior year in college, so I'm right on the cusp of starting my independent adult life, applying for my first jobs and such. That's just such an exciting time in anypony's life, that I can't imagine giving it up to move to Ponyville! Sorry ponies, but I know they'd totally understand if I had to explain it to them.

[SomeoneWhoUsedToBe 14]

I would stay, even if Pinkie was there. If I could bring my family, even though they don't like ponies, I don't care, I'll just force them to come. :3

[Jalaton 155]

I would stay since I wouldn't want to leave my family and friends behind and if I did go I would really miss them. Besides, here I don't have to worry about hydras and timberwolves and dragons etc.

[Unexard 50]

First of all, if Twilight came from nowhere to make that proposition I would probably elbow drop the shit out of her. I mean, seriously, I do not take house infraction lightly!

 

But if I met her in the street or somewhere like that, I would probably think I'm having an aneurism and that my brain is going coconut. Once the surprise is past, I would say no, without any hesitation whatsoever.

 

As they say in the show, friendship is the most valuable thing in life, and I would leave my friend for nothing, not even a promise of paradise.

Edited August 19, 2012 by Unexard

[Spatsi 151]

That would be a hard the decision to make. In fact, the only thing that would keep me here is my family. I'd really like to go to ponyville, but I know that by leaving my parents I would hurt them, especially that I'm their only child. So I guess I would stay here.

Edited August 19, 2012 by Spatsi

[kirbyboi 588]

Well, I hate to say it, but no.

 

I love MLP, but I love this world just as much. There are some bad things here, but there are good things here as well. I have people here who I love, and I would never leave them behind. I'm still trying to make friends, but I need to find someone of my own 'species'. Not to mention that there's no internet, good food, or all that good stuff. Or Pokemon, either. I would get seriously homesick too.

 

I love the Earth! Plus, I prefer watching the show than being in it.

[Abstract 832]

I don't really have friends anymore, which is a horribly depressing thing to admit, but yeah, no obstacles there.

 

However, I do have an amazing girlfriend, and a wonderful family that I just couldn't abandon like that. Hell, I want to move out of state so badly but I'm afraid to because of how much I know I will miss my family, and that's even knowing I'd get to visit!

 

It would be so wonderful to live in a world like Equestria. It has its issues of course, but they're nothing like the ones we deal with. It's an incredibly tempting offer, but I'm afraid that I simply could not deal with the fact that I'd never see any of them again, they mean way too much to me.

[Psych Ward 377]

My cats would be the deal breaker. XD Kidding. I need my parents and my cats. If I could bring my cats, then we might talk.....

[doomedaustin 0]

i would say 2 DAYS? ill post on my fb bye im going to live in ponyville and then grab my bronys friends and take them with me and my 1 stuffy like duh im going look at my blog its awsome http://luna-in-box.tumblr.com/

Edited August 21, 2012 by doomedaustin

[Princess Snowwie 126]

It would be hard but think about it, eventually you will get kicked out of the house (college) so i would rather live in Ponyville doing what i love and making money there plus i get to live in Cloudsdale!!!

[Jinx 2,292]

That's too difficult a question to ask, I need a test run to figure out how it would be over there. I'd be leaving quite a few people that I know would miss me, so I'd have to do thinking. I don't know if I could live in a world without my music, that would be difficult to overcome. I would totally become a musician there and create music those ponies have never heard before.

[Rizoel & Crepuscule 491]

I would LOVE to go!

 

My main attraction for going would be to meet the people there, especially Twilight and the mane 6.

 

 

"But what if they don't like you?"

 

I'm not perfect, but I believe I'm a very friendly person, and I don't see why Twilight wouldn't want to learn everything about me, I mean, I am an alien after all.

 

 

"There are no females of your species there.(Provided you're still a human once you're there.)"

 

Hey now, I thought it was what's on the inside that counts.

 

 

"Life there will be boring."

 

It certainly looks more interesting than daily life on Earth. I know, no internet, but I think that would be a good thing, It would force me to go out and spend time with folk, something I'm not to keen on here on Earth thanks to the possibility of getting stabbed in the face, which I would imagine would be a lot less likely in Equestria. So yeah, socializing FTW!

 

I've also been wanting to try my hand at artistic things like writing and music for a while - I'd love to learn how to play the violin. With my computer out the way, I would most likely spend more time doing productive things than sit on my ass all day doing nothing.

 

 

"Life there is difficult, you will still need to work."

 

I know life there won't be perfect, and I would have to work, but It certainly does look more fun than on Earth. It would be a pain to give up eating meat, but I think it's worth the sacrifice.

 

 

"You will need to leave everything behind."

 

I completely understand those that would choose not to go, but for me, I don't have much here.

 

All I have left that I would have to leave behind would be my family. I'm sure my family would want me to be happy, so they would understand. I almost think I have the most loving family in the world, But I know that I can't live with them forever, I will have no choice but to move out someday. Might as well be now.

[SomeoneWhoUsedToBe 14]

First of all, if Twilight came from nowhere to make that proposition I would probably elbow drop the shit out of her. I mean, seriously, I do not take house infraction lightly!

 

But if I met her in the street or somewhere like that, I would probably think I'm having an aneurism and that my brain is going coconut. Once the surprise is past, I would say no, without any hesitation whatsoever.

 

As they say in the show, friendship is the most valuable thing in life, and I would leave my friend for nothing, not even a promise of paradise.

 

What if........

That was a test to see if you would just leave your friends and family. And if you say no, you are able to come with the whole world, haters and all. And haters will be forced to come. How epic would that be....

[Dice The Titanic Brony 68]

I would go without looking back.

I wouldnt tell any of my friends or family. They would probably just think im dead and stop looking after a while.

In a way i think that would be better.

If they did not really know why i dissapeared it would be easier to forget.

Besides i lost most of my friends when i became a brony anyways.......

My parents still think im insane for liking mlp too.