Which Pony do you trust the most or trust the least of the mane 6

[silvadel 1,393]

I mean you have a situation where what you are being told doesnt make much sense and needs to be acted upon. Which pony would you be most likely to act first and ask questions later and which would you be more likely to be suspicious of?

 

For me, if Fluttershy told me to do something I wouldnt even think about it. The one I would probably most question would actually be Twilight Sparkle. AJ, RD, Pinkie, Rarity would be the order of the middle with Applejack being the second most trusted.

[Twiliscael 3,960]

I'd definitely trust Applejack the most, followed by Twilight. Applejack represents honesty, and I just think that she would be the most trustworthy as well. It just seems in character for her.

 

Least trustworthy would probably be Rainbow Dash. She would probably mock whatever was so important and make fun of you for it instead of actually helping.

[Glaceon 793]

Twilight is the most logical of the group and will probably understand what I want her to do. (Keep a secret if that what the trust is about.)

Aj will be second for obvious reasons.

I would trust Rarity the least. (I still trust her a lot, I just trust the rest of the mane 6 more.)

[PonyPowaX1000 69]

Ponies I'd be suspicious of:

 

I would be suspicious of Pinkie cause she's too random to believe.(though that is proved false in swarm of the century)

 

Also twilight because she gets a few screws loose for being 'tardy'.

 

Rarity because she would most like be exaggerating.

 

Rainbowdash cause she would most likely be playing a prank on me (her being the element of Loyalty doesn't change that , how often has she displayed loyalty I see her as more of 'Element of Bravery').

 

Ponies I'd trust;

 

AJ- element of honesty, nuff said

 

Fluttershy- to kind to lie.

Edited September 4, 2012 by PonyPowaX1000

[Flying Whales 311]

Yeah I agree completely with @, I’d easily trust AppleJack the most, I’m pretty sure she isn’t capable of a lie unless under the influence of Discord or if she’s trying to hide a surprise party for Pinkie Pie She’d give you a good, honest opinion and I think she’d do her best to help. I think Rainbow Dash would be the least trustworthy, I mean in It’s About Time her and Spike were just messing with Twilight even though there may have been some sort of impending disaster.

Edited September 4, 2012 by Flying Whales

[Akemi Homura 7,680]

If I weren't subjected to each of the Mane 6's adventures they have individually or otherwise as a group, then I would raise my eyebrows at Rarity the most. The way she conducts herself, they way she uses her feminine wiles to her advantage (nothing inherently bad about it, though), the way she presents herself, and the especially the way she manages to sweet-talk to get what she wants would make me highly suspicious. In fact, I was expecting all of that when I first started watching the show... of course she turned out to be much more than just a pretty face.

 

That said, most trustworthy would be Applejack. Even if you're the kind of person who doesn't like ponies/people, you will still have difficulty not being convinced by her truths, as she says things in the best and appropriate tone to get her points across while also being as unbiased as possible. I would trust her with my life, like how Twilight did in the pilot episode.

[Lightning Fluttershy 1,844]

Rainbow Dash is the living embodiment of loyalty. Her very element states that she will be there for you so my vote for most trusted goes to Rainbow Dash. As for least trusted to be there for me I would choose Fluttershy just because she may be too afraid to do anything.

[My Little Mandy 838]

I think I could trust Twilight Sparkle. The reason why I wouldn't trust Rarity is due the the fact she's like a frickin

magpie with anything shiny. LOL!

[silvadel 1,393]

Well, with regard to Fluttershy and Applejack I would trust them at face value because I would figure what they were telling me to do was genuinely in my best interest to do, and they wouldnt lie about it. Especially Fluttershy because it crossed her threshhold of action.

 

Rainbow Dash could theoretically be going for a laugh at my expense -- assuming I didnt know her first. But in many/most situations I would find her as trustworthy as the two above.

 

Pinkie Pie I would be more worried that I didnt fully understand more than that she was trying to lead me astray in any way.

 

With Rarity it could be selfish the other way -- it could be something for her, or might be overstated.

 

Twilight on the other hand is another ball of wax completely. Not only does she rely on logic which could be flawed, but I could see her very easily asking you to do something that would benefit the group to your own detriment. She is complicated enough that I would first question her motives in my mind at least.

Edited September 4, 2012 by silvadel

[lomk 20,663]

I'm definitely going to say Fluttershy. Without a shadow of a doubt would I trust Fluttershy at first, mostly because that's the pony I relate most to. Very inconfident and super sensitive.

 

If I could get Pinkie Pie to hear me out, I'd make her pinkie promise not to blurt it out to everyone. After all, no pony breaks a pinkie promise!

 

Applejack could go one way or the other. I'd talk to her because she can offer some good down to earth advice but she might be so stuck in her ways that she'd offer advice that might work for her but not for me.

 

I would trust Rarity, but I'd still be somewhat careful. I could sort of trust Twilight who might give me some advice as to what to do, but at the same time I would want someone to help me from what they feel and not rely on what some books say. I don't think I could trust RD, especially meeting at first. I mean, to even think of pranking Fluttershy...glad Pinkie could figure it out that Fluttershy would get hurt over it, though I wouldn't be so hurt. I'd probably laugh at myself but only as a mask as to how upset I could actually be.

[Ion 279]

I actually think that Pinkie or Rainbow would be among the most trustworthy simply because of their nature. Rainbow is the element of loyalty and as such she wouldn't betray you ( ) and she would be there for you, and Pinkie will do anything for her friends (Never break a Pinkie Promise). I suppose then you'd have Applejack, but despite being the Element of Honesty, it doesn't mean she would keep secrets for you etc.

 

 

As for those ponies not being trustworthy, it'd probably be Rarity. Only because her over the top persona and lifestyle could mean that she would often put herself first.

[ZLTavs 87]

I trust Applejack a lot because she's the Element of Honesty damnit, but I wouldn't trust Pinkie, I like her and all, but she's extremely random, and will probably just tell you something crazy and random for a prank.

[weegeez 150]

Applejack for obvious reasons is trustworthy, and on top of that I've rarely seen her lie on the show, the only time I recall was Party of One, although she was being secretive in the Last Roundup.

 

Pinkie Pie is also very trust worthy, although she is a but crazy, she doesn'y really lie often and She always fulfills her promises

 

FLuttershy would be trustworthy but if you wanted her to keep a secret, she would give in easily I think.

 

Rainbow Dash I could never really trust

 

Rarity and Twi are kind of trustworthy, but I'm not too sure.

Edited September 4, 2012 by weegeez

[ZLTavs 87]

Fluttershy is cute, but I don't think the poor gal has the guts to be able to keep any sort of secret for a prolonged period of time

[Ion 279]

Maybe if she Pinkie Promised, but otherwise I think Fluttershy would likely crack under pressure, especially if somepony thinks she is hiding something.

[Gone Airbourne 21,977]

I'd have to go with Pinkie Pie & AppleJack! They have both proven themselves to being very loyal and trustworthy in the episodes! If you think about it though all the ponies in the main six watch out for each other. So I believe I could trust each one of them!

[NavelColt 22,881]

> Trust the element of loyalty the least.

 

Wat?

 

I get that Dash is the most likely to mock something, but:

A: It's not like that's going to be her go-to response for everything. True she'll poke fun at some things, but there's plenty of things she takes seriously.

B: Even if she does initially poke fun, once you take a minute to persuade her that it's serious to you, that's it, you can count on her to get it done. Ergo why she won't be at the bottom of my list.

 

Applejack, surprise surprise, for first place. Not just because of her element, but because she's the most mature and level-headed of the six of them from what I've seen.

 

Probably Fluttershy or Pinkie. Fluttershy for aforementioned reasons. Pinkie, because unless you get her pinkie promise into effect, I see her as being one of the most spontaneous and potentially scatter-brained of the six, who may forget, get distracted, have heard you wrong and do/get you the wrong result, or something similar.

[Homura Akemi 974]

Twilight is my favorite, but I would trust Applejack the most. She's the ELEMENT OF HONESTY for peet's sake.

 

As for least, I'm going for Rarity. One of the reasons being the popular belief she is the least capable of her own element, not to mention my least favorite of the 6, but then again, that should have nothing to do with it.

[Princess Lunaa 8]

I would trust Fluttershy the most because she wouldn't have it in her nature to go behind your back! I would trust rainbow dash the least because she is a bit of a trickster. But i have to say yah gotta love Rainbow dash XD

[ShyPinkieDash 2]

I would have to say I'd trust Applejack the most since she does represent the element of honesty. And though she's one of my favorites, RD would be the least simply because she's such a prankster.

[Regality 233]

I'd trust Twilight Sparkle the most, only because I can easily identify with her, and she's in a way the "leader" of the mane6. While she can have her crazy moments, they're usually only a result of her OCD in regards to accomplishing something. We've also seen several past situations where Twilight was doubted by all, but in the end was mostly right.

 

Rainbow Dash, however, I'd trust the least. Her action-oriented personality makes for an unpredictable character. Not to say she's corrupt, or not trustworthy in the least, but I'd always be watching my back around her.

~~

[Winona the Dog 1,984]

Hmmmm let me think.........Applejack would be the obvious choice you know being the Element of Honesty and all plus not to mention she has to worst poker face of all time so she couldn't lie for the life of her so id go with her first

 

Pinkie Pie Easily second all i have to do is just make a Pinkie Promise with her and she wont tell anypony not ever.

 

Fluttershy Maybe my third option of course because of her quiet nature shes less likely to talk about secret's and id trust her with anything personally

 

Twilight Sparkle: After seeing her break her Pinkie Promise in 'Green is not your Color' id have to say its a tough choice to see if i could leave her with any secrets then again it was pretty obvious so meh.

 

Rarity: I dunno about her she probably wouldn't even remember my secret

 

Rainbow Dash: obviously cant keep secrets to herself or at least that's how i see it i wouldn't dare tell her anything.

[DottyDoo 7]

Isn't RD the element of loyalty? I'd trust her a lot. Unless Pinkie Pie Pinkie-Promised, I wouldn't really trust her. C'mon people.

[Kittybelle 95]

Honestly I'd trust Pinkie Pie the most. She is a loyal friend and loves everyone equally... "losing a friends trust is the fastest way to lose a friend...foreveeeeeeeeerrrrrrrr"

She was the only one in the "MMMystery on the Friendship Express" that DIDN'T eat any of the cakes. I haven't seen her betray any of her friends trust ever! She's possibly the most reliable??

 

And I'd trust Rainbow Dash the least... she's usually out for herself.

[XUNUSEDXXX 3,459]

Probably Twilight or Applejack trusting the most because they are always serious and on task. Pinkie the least because she would probably just suggest to be at SCC.