How much do you actually like each pony?

[PinkiePai 181]

Hold on... in polls for straight best pony, Fluttershy wins. But in this, she's in last place. I guess the people who want to fill this out just aren't big Fluttershy fans? 

Don't worry, I think I've missed some numbers and divided by a wrong amount. I'm calculating it all now, twice to be sure. Might take a while but it will be correct.

 

EDIT: She still has the lowest rating :/

Edited January 3, 2013 by PinkiePai

[Megas 27,491]

- Rainbow Dash - 97, My fav, despite some issues

- Twilight Sparkle - 96, While Rarity is my second favorite, Twilight has the edge due to being more relatable

- Pinkie Pie - 82, While a very fun character, sometimes I feel like she doesn't learn from some consequences

- Applejack  - 91, I kinda thought she was boring at first, but after a while, she really grew on me

- Rarity - 95, due to making a really girly girl great without making her shallow

- Fluttershy - 83, Would be higher if it there was more shown about her other than being shy/being a wuss

- Spike - 87, He's always there when they need him, but sometimes he can be a real dick at the worst times(Winter Wrap up comes to mind)

 

- Derpy - 57, I'm sick of hearing about her, it's especially frustrating when I hear "lack of Derpy" as a legit complaint about season 3

- Vinyl Scratch - 82, my favorite BG pony, I'm kinda meh on dubstep, but I love her mane and glasses 

- Octavia - 78

- Lyra - 80

- Colgate - 75

- Berry Punch - 77

- Dr Whooves - 70

- Bon Bon - 68

 

- Sweetie Belle - 85, I think she's really adorable as well has having a great singing voice

- Applebloom -79, I like her and all, but I think they've given us a little too much of her, and I'm a little tired of her

- Scootaloo - 92, my favorite CMC, especially with Sleepless in Ponyville showing that there's more to her than just being Mini-Rainbow Dash or RD obsessed

- Babs - 83, I hope we get to see more of her soon

 

- Big Mac - 85, will be higher if they give more lines than just "eeyup" or "enope"

- Spitfire - 84, I was a little neutral about her, but I adored her in Wonderbolt Academy

- Trixie - 60, A decent antagonist, but like with Derpy, some people's obsession with her makes me cringe

- Cheerilee - 88, my favorite secondary character, so it's kinda disappointing not to see her in S3 much

- Shining Armor - 83, like with Babs Seed, I need more of him

[Circadian 1,273]

Twilight: 80 (needs more character flaws, but getting there)

Applejack: 90 (finally got some episodes!)

Dash:75 (she's improving)

Rarity: 95 (went from my most hated pony to favorite)

Fluttershy: 93 (fav episode of season 2 was Putting Your Hoof Down, the dynamic between Pinkie, Rarity and Flutters was priceless)

Pinkie Pie: 85 (unpredicably occillates, but in a way fitting for her character; most likeable when she's being down to earth, think Kaylee from Firefly)

 

Celestia: 95 (used to think she was a condescending bitch, but now she's like the Dumbledore of Ponyville; funny too)

Luna: 90 (could use a more central role, her culture shock is great)

Cadence: 85 (like that she is coming into her own, she's just now realizing her potential)

[PinkiePai 181]

People, PLEASE stop rating Spike/Luna/Bon Bon/whatnot. Only rate the characters that are listed. Bon Bon and Dr. Whooves have been removed due to their rating dropping under 50.

 

EDIT: Circadian needs the rest of the listed ponies, and no princesses, or I won't count his vote. If you are going to do this edit your post saying that you will, because I can't be bucked calculating it all again if you add it when I'm finished.

 

EDITEDITEDIT: Will wrap up what I have now. Will add any ratings made after this post tomorrow/whenI'mnotlazy.

Edited January 3, 2013 by PinkiePai

[duidamasterXD 9,626]

Rainbow Dash: The scale is broken, it's been 100/100 since season one but it's gone up so much since then.

Pinkie Pie: 96/100, I love her

Fluttershy: 90/100 was lower before Hurricane Fluttershy, subject to going up or down depending on her performance in season 3

Applejack: 90/100, Season three has really bumped her up

Rarity: 87/100, her stock really rose with me recently. I'll see how her episode this season impacts me.

Twilight: 85/100, I've started to enjoy the rest of the six a bit more but she's still a lovable dork.

 

 

- Derpy 10/100

- Vinyl 25/100

- Octavia 20/100

- Lyra 25/100

- Bon Bon 5/100

- Colgate 5/100

- Berry Punch 15/100

- Dr. Whooves 20/100

 

- Sweetie Belle 85/100

- Applebloom 60/100

- Scootaloo 95/100

- Babs 50/100

 

- Big Mac 70/100

- Spitfire 88/100

- Trixie 50/100

- Cheerilee 60/100

- Shining Armor 75/100

Edited January 3, 2013 by DashForever

[Blizzard Gale 272]

Rainbow Dash - 85/100
Rarity - 95.7/100
AppleJack - 90.3/100
Twilight Sparkle - 94.8/100
Pinkie Pie - 94.9/100
Fluttershy - 99.2/100

---------------------------------------

Octavia - 88/100
Minuet "Colgate" - 96/100
Big Mac - 87/100
Spitfire - 90.8/100
Flim & Flam - Equally 79/100 for both of them.
Discord - 95/100
Luna - 96/100
Celestia - 95/100
Cadence - 93/100
Scootaloo - 80/100
Sweetie bell - 94.6/100
Applebloom - 91/100
Spike - 76/100
Babs seed - 81/100
Granny Smith - 91/100
Derpy - 99/100
Lyra Heartstring - 97/100
Trixie - 98/100

Pretty simple.. but it's how I like it. x3
 

Edited January 3, 2013 by Claudia

[Awesome Dashie 30]

-Rainbow Dash 100

- Twilight 93.5

- Pinkie 74

- Applejack 70

- Rarity 73

- Fluttershy 89.7

 

- Derpy 62

- Vinyl 82

- Octavia 70.01

- Lyra 70

- Colgate 66.8

- Berry Punch 50

 

- Sweetie Belle 73.2

- Applebloom 73

- Scootaloo, 67

- Babs, 75

 

- Big Mac 80

- Spitfire, 75

- Trixie 83

- Cheerilee, 70

- Shining Armor 84

Edited January 3, 2013 by Awesome Dashie

[PinkiePai 181]

Rainbow Dash - 85/100

Rarity - 95.7/100

AppleJack - 90.3/100

Twilight Sparkle - 94.8/100

Pinkie Pie - 94.9/100

Fluttershy - 99.2/100

 

---------------------------------------

 

Octavia - 88/100

Minuet "Colgate" - 96/100

Big Mac - 87/100

Spitfire - 90.8/100

Flim & Flam - Equally 79/100 for both of them.

Discord - 95/100

Luna - 96/100

Celestia - 95/100

Cadence - 93/100

Scootaloo - 80/100

Sweetie bell - 94.6/100

Applebloom - 91/100

Spike - 76/100

Babs seed - 81/100

Granny Smith - 91/100

Derpy - 99/100

Lyra Heartstring - 97/100

Trixie - 98/100

 

Pretty simple.. but it's how I like it. x3

 

 

Oh god Dx

 

After 2 warnings not to add characters other than those in my first post here we go again. And you haven't even rated all of the ponies I asked people to... Just because your avatar is amazing I'll add the ratings that cover the ponies you did rate, and put my own ratings instead of those you didn't.

[Scootaloo Is Best Filly 578]

Rainbow Dash    100

 

Twilight Sparkle     99.5

 

Fluttershy: 90.5

 

Rarity: 89.9

 

Apple Jack: 65.9

Pinkie Pie     59.4

 

 

 

Derpy Hooves     100

 

Doctor Whooves    75

 

Vinyl/DJ PON3       91 

 

Octavia                  80

 

Colgate                  65

 

Lyra                       54

 

Bon Bon                49

 

Berry Punch          7.4/100

 

Scootaloo            100/100

 

Sweetie Belle         91

 

Apple Bloom          50.3

 

Babs Seed            77

 

Spitfire                20.5

 

Cheerilee             30.5

 

 

GA Trixie              85.5

 

Big Mac                40.5

 

Shining Armour    55

 

Luna                   87

 

Cadance             78

 

Celestia              64.7

Edited January 3, 2013 by Scootaloo Is Best Filly

[Blizzard Gale 272]

Oh god Dx

 

After 2 warnings not to add characters other than those in my first post here we go again. And you haven't even rated all of the ponies I asked people to... Just because your avatar is amazing I'll add the ratings that cover the ponies you did rate, and put my own ratings instead of those you didn't.

^^" Sorry about that.. I guess I missed a sentence in your original post. I tend to do that especially without my glasses. Sorry if I troubled you with my post... DX

[PinkiePai 181]

^^" Sorry about that.. I guess I missed a sentence in your original post. I tend to do that especially without my glasses. Sorry if I troubled you with my post... DX

Nah, don't worry about it, that's just minor inconvenience. I guess I should bold and underline that so other people can see it properly.

[Blizzard Gale 272]

Nah, don't worry about it, that's just minor inconvenience. I guess I should bold and underline that so other people can see it properly.

Would be a good idea. @.@ Still I feel like such a noob for making that mistake in the first place. ;~; I wish I could find my glasses though. > w>

[PinkiePai 181]

Ok, I'm not going to add any new ratings until tomorrow. I spent 2 papers ( both sides (!) ) on this. Time to give my hand a rest. You can still add your ratings, just read my post first, and I'll add them tomorow.

[Motion Spark 7,807]

Mane6

• Rarity                100
• Fluttershy           90.5
• Applejack            87.5
• Pinkie Pie            80
• Twilight Sparkle   72.4
• Rainbow Dash     15

 

Princesses

• Princess Celestia 89.5
• Cadance                 83.7
• Princess Luna         80.1

 

Secondary Characters

• Shining Armor 85.4
• Spitfire               85
• Lightning Dust   75
• Big Macintosh    71
• Cherilee             71
• Trixie                  70
• Granny Smith     44
• Mr. Carrot Cake 39
• Mrs. Cake           2

 

CMC & Fillies and Colts

• Sweetie Belle       89.5
• Applebloom             77.5
• Scootaloo                75.2
• Rumble                    74.8
• Featherweight          52
• Babs                         31
• Twist                         22
• Silver Spoon             19
• Pipsqueak                18.9
• Diamond Tiara           5  
• Snips                          3
• Snails                        0.9

 

Background Characters

• Thunderlane                 83.5
• Dr. Whooves                  75
• Carrot Top                     69
• Milky Way                       65.1
• Octavia                           55.7
• Cloud Chaser                 49.5
• Berry Punch                   45
• Bon Bon                         41.1
• Caramel                         40
• Roid Rage (Snowflake)  29.9
• Lyra                               25
• Vinyl Scratch                 23.3
• Colgate                         19
• Derpy                            13

 

 

 

Edit: I just noticed my list was very messy so I cleaned it up a bit

Edited January 3, 2013 by Motion Spark

[Starswirl the Trixie 975]

- Dash, 99.6 (20% cooler than Rarity)
- Twi, 88
- Pinkie, 92
- AJ, 50
- Rarity 83
- Fluttershy 68

- Derpy, 100
- Vinyl, 85
- Octavia, 95
- Lyra, 65
- Colgate, 65
- Berry Punch, 60

- Dr. Whooves - 70
- Bon Bon - 30

- Sweetie Belle, 80
- Applebloom, 62
- Scootaloo, 84
- Babs, 55

- Big Mac, 65
- Spitfire, 75
- Trixie, 10000000007 (wait, I can only do up ro 100? 100 then)
- Cheerilee, 30
- Shining Armor 60.62

And with that AJ is out of the lead for Mane 6. Go Dashey!

Edit: We need a better system for rating, or at least a clarification on what numbers mean (I said that 50 is neutral, but I've seen some people putting 30 as neutral).

Edit 2: How does a user named "TGAPHaven" give Trixie a 85.72? Traitor.

Edited January 3, 2013 by Starswirl the Goateed

[The-Master 1,176]

- Dash 96

- Fluttershy 91

- Pinkie 85

- Twi 79

- Rarity 60

- AJ 40

 

- Dr. Whooves 99

- Derpy 98

- Vinyl 89

- Octavia 88

- Lyra 75

- Bon Bon 69

- Colgate 65

- Berry Punch 60

 

- Scootaloo 80

- Sweetie Belle 79

- Sweetie Bot 79.45332656781121076

- Applebloom 59

- Babs 31

 

- Spitfire 78

- Shining Armor 60

- Trixie 55

- Cheerilee 40

- Big Mac 5

Edited January 3, 2013 by The-Master

[TailsIsNotAlone 3,695]

Well, I couldn't vote for any of those poll options. (1) It's not too long to read. (2) It's a totally unnecessary idea but the execution is fine. (3) It doesn't look fun to me. (4) I'm not lazy. (5) You and other people may like the idea and that's totally fine. Don't feel bad about it.

[Starswirl the Trixie 975]

I know it can be heard to do this because there's no blank template...so I made one!  You can find it below.

 

 

 

-Rainbow Dash:

- Twilight Sparkle:
- Pinkie Pie:
- Applejack:
- Rarity:
- Fluttershy: 

- Derpy Hooves:
- Vinyl Scratch:
- Octavia:
- Lyra:
- Colgate:
- Berry Punch:

- Dr. Whooves: 
- Bon Bon: 

- Sweetie Belle: 
- Applebloom:
- Scootaloo:
- Babs Seed:

- Big Mac:
- Spitfire:
- Trixie: 
- Cheerilee:
- Shining Armor:

 

Terms of Usage: By using the template above, the user agrees to rate Trixie at least 1 point higher than (s)he would have done otherwise (up to a maximum of 100 points).  Violators will be persecuted.

 

 

Edited January 3, 2013 by Starswirl the Goateed

[Scootalove 10,689]

Mane 6:

Dash - 88

AJ - 75

Twilight - 70

Rarity - 69

Fluttershy - 79

Pinkie - 86

 

Derpy - 96

Vinyl - 87

Octavia - 65

Lyra - 78

Bon Bon - 55

Colgate - 59

Berry Punch - 50

 

CMC:

Apple Bloom - 67

Sweetie Belle - 65

Scootaloo - 66

Babs - 70

 

Shining Armor - 65

Cadance - 89

Trixie - 55

Big Mac - 40

[Vicke 3,188]

- Dash 80
- Twi 100
- Pinkie 40
- AJ 90
- Rarity 40
- Fluttershy 80
 
- Derpy 50
- Vinyl 50
- Octavia 10
- Lyra 70
- Bon Bon 10
- Colgate 70
- Berry Punch 50
- Dr. Whooves 70
 
- Sweetie Belle 90
- Applebloom 90
- Scootaloo 100
- Babs 70
 
- Big Mac 60
- Spitfire 80
- Trixie 80
- Cheerilee 20
- Shining Armor 90

[PinkiePai 181]

I know it can be heard to do this because there's no blank template...so I made one!  You can find it below.

 

 

 

-Rainbow Dash:

- Twilight Sparkle:

- Pinkie Pie:

- Applejack:

- Rarity:

- Fluttershy: 

 

- Derpy Hooves:

- Vinyl Scratch:

- Octavia:

- Lyra:

- Colgate:

- Berry Punch:

 

- Dr. Whooves: 

- Bon Bon: 

 

- Sweetie Belle: 

- Applebloom:

- Scootaloo:

- Babs Seed:

 

- Big Mac:

- Spitfire:

- Trixie: 

- Cheerilee:

- Shining Armor:

 

Terms of Usage: By using the template above, the user agrees to rate Trixie at least 1 point higher than (s)he would have done otherwise (up to a maximum of 100 points).  Violators will be persecuted.

 

 

:/ oh man, I forgot about the blank template. Thanks for making one though, mind if I use it? Anyway, since this is really helpful I'll count your rates 2 times.

[Carolina 212]

Do these count???

 

Konoiche

Meg - 92/100

Elani - 91.5/100

Cheryl - 97/100

Katrina - 95/100

Lesley - 96/100

IBM62 - 98/100

Gin - 90.5/100

Flora - 97.5/100

Candace - 93/100

Caro - 99/100

Georgie - 94/100

Jutta - 95/100

 

Other

Erick - 89/100

Griffin - 90/100

Goodwin - 85/100

Sobo - 88/100

Kimchi - 91/100

Chelsa - 75/100

Morgana - 85/100

Raymond - 87/100

Hiroshi - 88/100

Dani - .01/100

Reyna - .02/100

 

Lol. Whoops, wrong thread! Disregard, please. My bad.

Edited January 5, 2013 by Carolina

[Clarity 3,094]

Applejack - 100

 

Rarity - 80

 

Twilight - 75

 

Everypony else - 50

 

Braeburn - 0.05

 

Vinyl Scratch - 0.05

 

Big McIntosh - 0.05

 

 

Derpy Hooves - 0.01

 

-Rainbow Dash: 50

- Twilight Sparkle: 75
- Pinkie Pie: 40
- Applejack: 100
- Rarity: 80
- Fluttershy: 45

- Derpy Hooves: 0.01
- Vinyl Scratch: 0.05
- Octavia: 30
- Lyra: 30
- Colgate: 30
- Berry Punch: 30

- Dr. Whooves: 0.05
- Bon Bon: 30

- Sweetie Belle: 75
- Applebloom: 30
- Scootaloo: 65
- Babs Seed: 30

- Big Mac: 0.05
- Spitfire: 50
- Trixie: 75
- Cheerilee: 75
- Shining Armor: 50

 

[Rainbow Dash 1,472]

I di this wrong but im too lazy to do it right

` Dash 100

- Twi 99.99

- Pinkie99.97

- AJ 99.98

- Rarity 90

- Fluttershy 99.96

 

- Derpy 1

- Vinyl 99.8

- Octavia 99.81

- Lyra 99.82

- Bon Bon 99.84

- Colgate 28

- Berry Punch 0

- Dr. Whooves .01

 

- Sweetie Belle 96

- Applebloom 98.96

- Scootaloo 90

- Babs 0.02

 

- Big Mac 100.99

- Spitfire 23

- Trixie 40.98

- Cheerilee 12

- Shining Armor 99.78

[AngelofDeath 259]

-Rainbow Dash: 60/100

- Twilight Sparkle: 95/100
- Pinkie Pie: 50/100
- Applejack: 100/100
- Rarity: 85/100
- Fluttershy: 70/100

- Derpy Hooves: 85/100
- Vinyl Scratch: 60/100
- Octavia: 90/100
- Lyra: 75/100
- Colgate: 70/100
- Berry Punch: 60/100
- Dr. Whooves: 65/100
- Bon Bon: 75/100

- Sweetie Belle: 85/100
- Applebloom: 100/100
- Scootaloo: 65/100
- Babs Seed: 50/100

- Big Mac: 85/100
- Spitfire: 70/100
- Trixie: 100/100
- Cheerilee: 75/100
- Shining Armor: 85/100