I've posted a thread similar to this some 11 months ago, but after about 15 new episodes I'm wondering if people's opinions have changed.
Since I've said everything I needed to in the first thread, you can read it here:
In the last thread some people requested princesses, so I've added them. The rules haven't changed. I will do my best to update the results often (I'll be using Excel so it shouldn't be a problem).
Please don't add/remove any of the ponies you're supposed to be rating, I haven't added some for a reason (I'm lazy).
The most important thing is to try and have fun while doing this.
I'm doing this because I'm curious about people's opinions, so I'm not going to add my own ratings.
Lowest rating in each group will be Italic, highest rating in each group will be bold.
Overall highest and lowest ratings will be blue and red, respectively
Since some people were discussing how exactly the ratings should work, if you really want a rule set for that imo it should be: 100 = Favorite pony, <50 = Failing, and you can rate the characters you really hate with less than 50 (For example, a Rarity fan might rate Trixie with 0.01 for turning Rarity's mane green, or something like that), but I'll make a poll for it and see what happens.
All ponies that remain unrated in a post are given a default 50 for convenience's sake (would be counted as a 0 in Excel, and that would set the rating off by far too much).
Based on 9 ratings so far
Mane 6
- Dash, 77,29
- Twi, 86,2
- Pinkie, 85,61
- AJ, 86,24
- Rarity, 86,79
- Fluttershy, 82,37
Princesses
-'Tia, 78,48
-Woona, 80,48
-Cadence, 69,52
BG
- Derpy, 79,01
- Vinyl, 69,69
- Octavia, 77,64
- Lyra, 61,37
- Colgate, 61,18
CMC
- Sweetie Belle, 82,15
- Applebloom, 82,57
- Scootaloo, 82,18
- Babs, 63,23
Recurring
- Big Mac, 77,3
- Spitfire, 72,61
- Trixie, 69,1
- Cheerilee, 70,72
- Shining Armor, 66,12
Ctrl+c; ctrl+v, fill out: