How much do you actually like each pony?

[Zygen 6,066]

In order of favorites for the mane 6.

 

90.00 Fluttershy: Because I can relate to her so well, and because she also has a beautiful singing voice and is very adorable kind and sweet .

86.31 Twilight: I've actually grown to like her alot, she tails behind Fluttershy pretty closely. Shes relatable on some things for me, can be funny, has magic and is a unicorn(Favorite type of pony) And has my favorite singing voice in the show personally. I also like her design alot like her art. And her filly version is a rival to Fluttershy for adorableness. Shes not quiet as relatable or adorable as Fluttershy though.(For me)

 

79.95 Pinkie Pie: Her random humor and 4th wall breaking ability and not to mention still be adorable at times, then go back to being Super random . I really like her humor and stuff especially all the random 4th wall breaking and the totally random things(Latest episode mustache anypony?) Spy Fluttershy Outfit.. And thats just naming some in S3. Theres plenty in S2 and S1 . Oh and I actually really like her singing voice to, I mean she sings some really catchy tunes , She might be a rival for Twilights singing for me, maybe tied with Fluttershy somewhere around there.

 

75.20 Rainbow Dash: At first I really didn't like Rainbow Dash that much and would not have rated her around here, but I've grown to like her alot more as shes progressed, Especially in S3. Shes developed alot, maybe the most of all the characters. Except for maybe Twilight. She has a pretty good singing voice, but never really sings.. So. And who doesn't like being 20% cooler?

 

70.10 Rarity: I use to think of Rarity as very snobby and I didn't like her very much, but after watching "Suited for Success" and her other episodes and hearing her sing I've grown to like her more, I've also slowly grown to appreciate her humor .(And drama) Still shes not the most relatable for me, but oh well. Her singing voice is also pretty good, beyond Pinkie and Twilight I have mostly very close ties in that category.

 

68.00 Apple Jack: Your probably wondering why I have AJ all the way down here. Well the thing is that even with all the recent screentime and development shes got (and even a song!) She was pretty bland for me for alot of the show, so I'm still deciding on how much I like her, however since S3 she has most certainly become more likeable for me . (Heck shes had more Screentime then alot of the pony's by now .) So I have grown to like her more, She tails right behind Rarity for me, and may pass her up in time, who knows.

 

 

Whew, ok thats my ratings for the mane 6, I know the numbers might get a bit low, but I don't dislike any of the mane 6 at all, I like they all alot , the ratings are just kinda to give good ideas of how close each one is. Relative to the others.

Edited January 5, 2013 by Zygen

[Roi 100]

` Dash 27/100

- Twi 50/100

- Pinkie 75/100

- AJ 75/100

- Rarity 30/100

- Fluttershy 45/100

 

- Derpy 65/100

- Vinyl 45/100

- Octavia 75/100

- Lyra 70/100

- Bon Bon 32/100

- Colgate53/100

- Berry Punch I'm too drunk to rate this one.

- Dr. Whooves 30/100

 

- Sweetie Belle 68/100

- Applebloom 99/100

- Scootaloo 50/100

- Babs 20/100

 

- Big Mac 30/100

- Spitfire 10/100

- Trixie 55/100 YUS

- Cheerilee 70/100

- Shining Armor 40/100

[ReGen 1,466]

- Dash 100!

- Twi 95

- Pinkie 100!

- AJ 99.999

- Rarity 75

- Fluttershy 88

 

- Derpy 97

- Vinyl 100!

- Octavia 100!

- Lyra 80

- Bon Bon 80

- Colgate 80

- Berry Punch 80

- Dr. Whooves 80

 

- Sweetie Belle 99

- Applebloom 99

- Scootaloo 100!

- Babs 99

 

- Big Mac 98

- Spitfire 97

- Trixie 99

- Cheerilee 99

- Shining Armor 95

[spas-ticShotty 3,584]

- Twilight Sparkle: 90/100
- Pinkie Pie: 85/100
- Applejack: 100/100 (If I could rate her 1000001 without cheating, I would )

- Rainbow Dash: 79/10
- Rarity: 93/100
- Fluttershy: 77/100

- Derpy Hooves: 70/100
- Vinyl Scratch: 78/100
- Octavia: 80/100
- Lyra: 70/100
- Colgate: 65/100
- Berry Punch: 68/100
- Dr. Whooves: 60/100
- Bon Bon: 65/100

- Sweetie Belle: 80/100
- Applebloom: 85/100
- Scootaloo: 79/100
- Babs Seed: 75/100

- Big Mac: 88/100
- Spitfire: 80/100
- Trixie: 75/100
- Cheerilee: 70/100
- Shining Armor: 85/100

[Starswirl the Trixie 975]

:/ oh man, I forgot about the blank template. Thanks for making one though, mind if I use it? Anyway, since this is really helpful I'll count your rates 2 times.

 

Sorry for the late reply.  Feel free to use it, but don't count my vote twice.  That sort of beats the point of the poll (I assume this is more of a quasi-scientific poll, not a contest.)

[Dusty Sparkle 23]

- Dash - 65/100

- Twi - 100/100

- Pinkie - 90/100

- AJ - 80/100

- Rarity - 80/100

- Fluttershy - 80/100

 

- Derpy - 80/100

- Vinyl - 66/100

- Octavia - 80/100

- Lyra - 92/100

- Colgate - 65/100 

- Berry Punch - 30/100

 

- Sweetie Belle - 80/100

- Applebloom - 80/100

- Scootaloo - 70/100

- Babs - 88/100

 

- Big Mac - 60/100

- Spitfire - 30/100

- Trixie - (before magic duel ep - 5/100) 50/100

- Cheerilee - 67/100

- Shining Armor - 40/100

Edited January 8, 2013 by Dusty Sparkle

[chattydash 62]

- Dash, 100

- Twi, 35

- Pinkie, 75

- AJ, 25

- Rarity 15

- Fluttershy 50

 

- Derpy, 100

- Vinyl, 75

- Octavia, 50

- Lyra, 45

- Colgate, 25

- Berry Punch, 25

 

- Sweetie Belle, 50

- Applebloom, 75

- Scootaloo, 100

- Babs, 25

 

- Big Mac, 100

- Spitfire, 75

- Trixie, 0

- Cheerilee, 35

- Shining Armor 50

[NavelColt 22,881]

- Dash Best Pony/100

- Twi 80/100

- Pinkie 72/100

- AJ 85/100

- Rarity 35/100

- Fluttershy 44/100

 

- Derpy 10/100

- Vinyl 50/100

- Octavia 10/100

- Lyra 10/100

- Bon Bon 10/100

- Colgate 10/100

- Berry Punch 10/100

- Dr. Whooves 25/100

 

Asides from Vinyl I just don't give a shit about BG ponies, honestly. The doctor only gets some points for some cool media I've seen of him and because I'm familiar with Doctor Who due to my British step-dad.

 

- Sweetie Belle 50/100

- Applebloom 50/100

- Scootaloo 95/100 (Scootalurv)

- Babs 65/100

 

- Big Mac 30/100

- Spitfire 92/100 (Stupid Sexy Spitfire)

- Trixie 25/100

- Cheerilee 20/100

- Shining Armor 74/100

Edited January 10, 2013 by ~Chaotic Discord~

[Lord_sm 20]

- Dash            45/100

- Twi               75/100

- Pinkie           95/100

- AJ                80/100

- Rarity          90/100

- Fluttershy    85/100

 

- Derpy            95/100

- Vinyl              55/100   

- Octavia         50/100 

- Lyra              80/100

- Bon-Bon        60/100  

- Colgate          45/100

- Berry Punch  55/100

- Dr. Whooves 60/100

 

- Sweetie Belle   95/100

- Applebloom      90/100

- Scootaloo        85/100   

- Babs                75/100   

 

- Big Mac           70/100

- Spitfire             75/100

- Trixie                85/100

- Cheerilee          65/100

- Shining Armor   80/100

[MeowLord Noraasha 135]

- Dash, 100

- Twi, 98

- Pinkie, 96

- AJ, 91

- Rarity 87

- Fluttershy 88

 

- Derpy, 65

- Vinyl, 80

- Octavia, 65

- Lyra, 65

- Colgate, 80

- Berry Punch, 60

 

- Sweetie Belle,85

- Applebloom, 91

- Scootaloo, 75

- Babs, 35

 

- Big Mac, 45

- Spitfire, 75

- Trixie, 50

- Cheerilee, 45

- Shining Armor 70

[PinkiePai 181]

Holy crap, this took a long time to calculate. Probably because I wasn't in the mood to. At least it's here. Not that anyone cares, but I still did it.

Edited January 10, 2013 by PinkiePai

[Commander Urdnot 2,680]

Here's what I think:

 

- Dash: 50/100

- Twi: 80/100

- Pinkie: 100/100<3

- AJ: 85/100

- Rarity: 50/100

- Fluttershy: 50/100


- Derpy: N/A

- Vinyl: N/A

- Octavia: N/A

- Lyra: N/A

- Colgate: N/A

- Berry Punch: N/A


- Sweetie Belle: 70/100

- Applebloom: 70/100

- Scootaloo: 50/100

- Babs: 50/100


- Big Mac: 50/100

- Spitfire: 70/100

- Trixie: 50/100

- Cheerilee: 50/100

- Shining Armor: 70/100

 

I'm not giving ratings to background ponies, I don't know enough about them to rate them.

Edited January 10, 2013 by Urdnot Pinkie Pie

[prinsess cadance XD 1]

These are my favorite ponys:

 

CADANCE: over 9000!! 9000/100 because she is just awersome and shining armor have made a really good choise

 

Luna: 100 because luna is cute and awersome

Celestia: 90 because she is the princess and she likes twilight

Twilight: 90 because she is lovely and nise

[Pinkazoid 3,493]

85/100- Dash

80/100- Twi

100/100- Pinkie <3

90/100- AJ

95/100- Rarity

30/100- Fluttershy 

 

HELL TO THE F*CK NO/10- Derpy

90/100- Vinyl

90/100- Octavia

99.99/100- Lyra

80/100- Colgate

80/100- Berry Punch

 

95/100- Sweetie Belle

80/100- Applebloom

80/100- Scootaloo

85/100- Babs

 

60/100- Big Mac

85/100- Spitfire

90/100- Trixie

70/100- Cheerilee

75/100- Shining Armor 

 

 

OP Y U NOT LET ME CHOOSE MY OWN COLORS?

Edited January 13, 2013 by Pinkazoid

[Sanic Screwdriver 345]

Well I cant really put a number on it Ill just rank them and say something

1. Fluttershy: 'Cuz D'AWWWWW!

2. Pinkie Pie: She's crazy and it's funny.

3/4. Applejack I can't decide between AJ and RD so I put 'em together. Aj is is pretty cool

3/4. Rainbow Dash: Well I almost put her at 5 but she is kind of awesome but... reeeeaaally arrogant/ cocky...

5. Twilight Sparkle: Twilight can be funny but nothing about her ever stood out to me enough to rank her higher.

6. Rarity: Don't get me wrong I like all the ponies but she just is my least favorite... IDK why... MAYBE it's the diva thing or maybe not.

[Steve 290]

- Dash 75

- Twi  90

- Pinkie 100

- AJ 60

- Rarity 10

- Fluttershy 80

 

- Derpy 100

- Vinyl 90

- Octavia 80

- Lyra 75

- Colgate 70

- Berry Punch 30

 

- Sweetie Belle 100

- Applebloom 95

- Scootaloo 80

- Babs 2

 

- Big Mac 50

- Spitfire 20

- Trixie 60

- Cheerilee 40

- Shining Armor 30

[silvadel 1,393]

- Dash 100

- Twi 85

- Pinkie 93

- AJ 60

- Rarity 80

- Fluttershy 97

 

- Derpy 40

- Vinyl 30

- Octavia 70

- Lyra 92

- Colgate 20

- Berry Punch 50

 

- Sweetie Belle 82

- Applebloom 82

- Scootaloo 85

- Babs 60

 

- Big Mac 60

- Spitfire 75

- Trixie 70

- Cheerilee 60

- Shining Armor 50

[PinkiePai 181]

85/100- Dash

80/100- Twi

100/100- Pinkie <3

90/100- AJ

95/100- Rarity

30/100- Fluttershy 

 

HELL TO THE F*CK NO/10- Derpy

90/100- Vinyl

90/100- Octavia

99.99/100- Lyra

80/100- Colgate

80/100- Berry Punch

 

95/100- Sweetie Belle

80/100- Applebloom

80/100- Scootaloo

85/100- Babs

 

60/100- Big Mac

85/100- Spitfire

90/100- Trixie

70/100- Cheerilee

75/100- Shining Armor 

 

 

OP Y U NOT LET ME CHOOSE MY OWN COLORS?

O.o When did I say anything about colors? I said that in the overall ratings in my post the highest rating is blue. I never said anything about you coloring/bolding anything in your post. I just said you can't add your own ponies. Even after saying that multiple times, people still add their own ponies, or they don't rate all of them.

 

These are my favorite ponys: CADANCE: over 9000!! 9000/100 because she is just awersome and shining armor have made a really good choise Luna: 100 because luna is cute and awersome Celestia: 90 because she is the princess and she likes twilight Twilight: 90 because she is lovely and nise

Holy sweet Celestia... What is this? Have you even read my post? Please, read before posting.

 

 

Well I cant really put a number on it Ill just rank them and say something

1. Fluttershy: 'Cuz D'AWWWWW!

2. Pinkie Pie: She's crazy and it's funny.

3/4. Applejack I can't decide between AJ and RD so I put 'em together. Aj is is pretty cool

3/4. Rainbow Dash: Well I almost put her at 5 but she is kind of awesome but... reeeeaaally arrogant/ cocky...

5. Twilight Sparkle: Twilight can be funny but nothing about her ever stood out to me enough to rank her higher.

6. Rarity: Don't get me wrong I like all the ponies but she just is my least favorite... IDK why... MAYBE it's the diva thing or maybe not.

How am I supposed to calculate the average rating for each pony if you didn't even rate them? You didn't rate anything. You have to put a number on all of them, because that's what I'm asking you to do.

[Wingnut 7,000]

This DOES look like fun!  I can't believe I haven't noticed it until now...

 

- Dash                     90/100 The “perfect flawed” hero.

- Twi                        85/100 A better egghead than I'll ever be.

- Pinkie                    67/100 Why does she have to be so random?

- AJ                          88/100 The most well rounded personaltity of the Mane 6.

- Rarity                    82/100 Too often she acts like her EOH is greed instead of generosity.

- Fluttershy              95/100 Her love for her friends and devotion to animals far outweigh her shortcomings.

 

- Derpy                    60/100 I should just ignore this fanon phenom...but I can't.

- Vinyl                      60/100 She can MC at my wedding...

- Octavia                  65/100 ...but only if Octavia isn't available.

- Lyra                       73/100 Only because she's Bon Bon's BFF.

- Colgate                 50/100 Totally neutral to me.

- Berry Punch          80/100 Her reaction to Apple Bloom's sales tactics was priceless.

 

- Sweetie Belle         85/100 Best CMC.

- Applebloom            70/100 Would be 65 if she weren't modeled after Blossom.

- Scootaloo              80/100 Is now my second favorite CMC.

- Babs                      55/100 For now, 55 is the most I can give her.

 

- Big Mac                 72/100 Eeyup. 'Nuff said.

- Spitfire                   65/100 One hot babe (rimshot).

- Trixie                     50/50 Trick...C? Didn't she have to take up rock farming?

- Cheerilee              76/100 Being modeled after Ms. Keane earns her extra points.

- Shining Armor       60/100 Not his fault, but not knowing about his existence sooner hurts him.

 

Nobody is perfect, therefore nopony gets 100. Celestia, Luna, Cadance, Spike, Dr. Hooves, and Bon Bon should be rated too, but I didn't want to mix their numbers into the official tally so I'll rate them here:
 

-Celestia                 70/100 Hopefully she won't send me to the moon for a 70.

-Luna                      75/100 I'm not alone in liking Luna more than Celestia.

-Cadance                60/100 Being in only four episodes, she's barely on my radar.

-Spike                      77/100 The little guy always gives it his all.

-Bon Bon                 64/100 The mare of 1,000 voices would make Mel Blanc proud!

-Dr. Hooves             53/100 In the big scheme of things, he's unimportant.

[PinkiePai 181]

This DOES look like fun!  I can't believe I haven't noticed it until now...

 

- Dash                     90/100 The “perfect flawed” hero.

- Twi                        85/100 A better egghead than I'll ever be.

- Pinkie                    67/100 Why does she have to be so random?

- AJ                          88/100 The most well rounded personaltity of the Mane 6.

- Rarity                    82/100 Too often she acts like her EOH is greed instead of generosity.

- Fluttershy              95/100 Her love for her friends and devotion to animals far outweigh her shortcomings.

 

- Derpy                    60/100 I should just ignore this fanon phenom...but I can't.

- Vinyl                      60/100 She can MC at my wedding...

- Octavia                  65/100 ...but only if Octavia isn't available.

- Lyra                       73/100 Only because she's Bon Bon's BFF.

- Colgate                 50/100 Totally neutral to me.

- Berry Punch          80/100 Her reaction to Apple Bloom's sales tactics was priceless.

 

- Sweetie Belle         85/100 Best CMC.

- Applebloom            70/100 Would be 65 if she weren't modeled after Blossom.

- Scootaloo              80/100 Is now my second favorite CMC.

- Babs                      55/100 For now, 55 is the most I can give her.

 

- Big Mac                 72/100 Eeyup. 'Nuff said.

- Spitfire                   65/100 One hot babe (rimshot).

- Trixie                     50/50 Trick...C? Didn't she have to take up rock farming?

- Cheerilee              76/100 Being modeled after Ms. Keane earns her extra points.

- Shining Armor       60/100 Not his fault, but not knowing about his existence sooner hurts him.

 

 

Nobody is perfect, therefore nopony gets 100. Celestia, Luna, Cadance, Spike, Dr. Hooves, and Bon Bon should be rated too, but I didn't want to mix their numbers into the official tally so I'll rate them here:

 

-Celestia                 70/100 Hopefully she won't send me to the moon for a 70.

-Luna                      75/100 I'm not alone in liking Luna more than Celestia.

-Cadance                60/100 Being in only four episodes, she's barely on my radar.

-Spike                      77/100 The little guy always gives it his all.

-Bon Bon                 64/100 The mare of 1,000 voices would make Mel Blanc proud!

-Dr. Hooves             53/100 In the big scheme of things, he's unimportant.

They should be, but it takes an awful lot of time to calculate all that, and I'm a pretty lazy person, so I just settled for 21 ponies...

[Wingnut 7,000]

They should be, but it takes an awful lot of time to calculate all that, and I'm a pretty lazy person, so I just settled for 21 ponies...

Well, it is a lot of number crunching.  I'm glad you like ponies enough to compile this. 

 

Just curious...how much longer will this be open for new people to add their own ratings?  Nobody can do this forever. 

[PinkiePai 181]

I don't really think there will be so many replies that I won't be able to catch up with them. I'll probably stop once the thread dies away. As long as I don't get 50 replies a day I could probably go on for ever.

Edited January 13, 2013 by PinkiePai