Pewdiepie vs. Tobuscus

[Pentakill 68]

Okay so I have a question, which is better, Pewdiepie or Tobuscus?  Now let's clear the water here.  When I ask this question I want you to base your response on mutiple characteristics.  They are quite simple, how funny, how good at the game, and how original and colorful (if you know what I mean).  So keep those factors in mind when answering this.  I personally like both but like Pewdiepie more.  Nothing against Tobuscus I just like pewds.

 

Now in Pony form too 

 

Oh, and you might have noticed that I added a few more gamers to the poll.  The poll is multiple choice enabled so I decided to add some other gamers that I watch.  Just pick your choice between Pewds and Toby then simply vote for others that you like on the side and talk about why you like them.  Anyways that's all for now and I hope to read many good replies to this topic in the future.

[An Old Head 4,816]

I honestly think that none of them are particularly special. When you get a large audience like they do, you have to pander to keep them, and act as they want you to. That's why I preferred PewdiePie when he had about 1,000 subscribers and he acted himself, instead of always putting on that Pewds voice. That's also why my favourite LPer is Markiplier, because he's not one of the highest names up there and just acts normally.

 

With that in mind, I prefer Tobuscus. Personal preferences, I wouldn't watch either, but Tobuscus' videos aren't seventeen minutes of "Stephano! Piggeh! BARRELS!!"

[Naught Important 434]

TotalHalibut > All

 

He's British, Intelligent, Actually knows what's good in the world, And he has more Youtube money than God!

He also is a part of "The Game Station," who have relatively good senses of humor.

 

To be honest, I hate both PewdiePie and Tobuscus.

[Cocoa23 2]

I like pewdiepie's videos better but tobuscus does AWESOME songs. i prefer pewdiepie because i cant really understand tobuscus very well

[Apocalyptic_Unicorn 240]

PewdiePie and Tobuscus come across as way too overrated for me. Everyone I know just keeps talking about them and it really just puts me off. 
I watched some videos of them, and I thought "Is that it? What's the big deal about 'em?" 

[Scootalove 10,689]

Well I have heard of both PewDiePie and Tobuscus. But the thing is, I don't really watch them on Youtube, I basically watch anything even the Creatures.

 

To me, I think Nova pretty much is entertaining to me.

[Zygen 6,066]

I like tobuscus a bit more, but only because I never really watched pewdiepie. I hardly watch tobuscus to be honest, but I do like his comedy style.

 

I also like his literal trailers alot

[jw5587 182]

I think they're both entirely overrated, though if I had to choose I'd go with Tobuscus, if only for his Halo Reach literal trailer a few years back. That was genius. The people I watch on Youtube are EatMyDiction1, Chilled Chaos, Gassy Mexican, Hutch and Seananners. 

[Just some guy 1,070]

They're both meh to me.Pewdie just got annoying the more you watched him do the same thing over and over in every.Single.Goddamn.Game.He.Plays.Toby is just not even funny to me,though I do like his sideburns song.Outside of that one song,Toby is really lackluster IMO.

 

The only two guys that I like watching playing video games are Cr1TiKaL and Criken,and they don't even do LPs.

[Betez 1,734]

I don't like either of them very much. However, I like Tobuscus a bit more. To me, he has better jokes. All PewDiePie ever seems to do is scream.

[PinkiePie Forever 65]

I prefer Tobuscus over PewDiePie. I think he's very annoying and obnoxious. I try to watch the videos but I just think they're so stupid. ._.

[~Scootaloo 440]

I don't really like either of them much at all to be honest...

 

Pewdiepie:

 

-Doesn't even try to play the game

-Screams for no reason

-Makes a fool of his homeland

 

Tobuscus:

 

-Nice animation, but usually nothing too interesting for my tastes

-Has 4-5 different channels

[Moog the Kvlt 1,460]

I'm not a huge fan of PewDiePie at all, and I absolutely hate Tobuscus, he really isn't funny at all to me, though on the occasion PewDiePie can make a half decent joke, and plus his Conker's let's plays are actually alright. My personal favorite gamer is Azurite, he plays a variety of games and he is actually funny to me, though that's just my personal preference.

[Flying Space Badger 84]

I never could stand Tobuscus' videos to be honest. And the last PewDie video I really enjoyed was his Journey Let's Play.

 

As jackw545 above said, Diction, Gassy, Chilled and their little circle are some of the better channels IMO. Then there is Captain Sparklez and his amazing music videos.

[sxp 404]

Pewds > Tobuscus. I simply don't like Toby. Pewds isn't that great these days, as his jokes are getting old and boring. Still better than Tobuscus though.

 

Other youtubers I like: Yamimash, Markiplier, Youalwayswin aka Dumb and Dumber aka Meaty and Gunns, Scott Manley, Harv from HOC gaming