Humans must've existed in equestria!

[\/ 651]

Yes through a mirror that leads to another dimension

 They're not Humans. It's only inferred. We have no idea exactly what they are, but they're humanoid.

[Scootaloodle 1,623]

I would have put forth evidence like the fact that all their cups have handles on them (despite ponies not having fingers).

 

 

How about this car tire? That's rubber, folks. Ponies don't have rubber tires, only wooden wheels.]

 

bscap0081.jpg

 

 

SolarFox's point is good. But I don't think your historical argument works. While horses may have been bred by humans, the ponies in this show are not the same thing. Spanish horse breeders couldn't have existed if Spain doesn't exiat. It's a different world entirely.

 

 

What if the ponies in Equestria actually didn't evolve from horses...  what if they actually evolved from humans?  O__o

 

Aren't some over thinking it a bit?

 

I always figured it is the way it is because it’s a fictional universe in a cartoon, created by humans in a real universe aka this one, hence the odd human inventions popping up, like tea cups, which looks better than a troff for the record and recognizable to people.

[Ohnhai 69]

Equestria is it's own world with its own distinct evolution of life. That Twi and all her pals resemble RL Earth ponies is an example of convergent evolution and should not be used to assert that they are the same, or indeed have a similar history. The Tasmanian Wolf was a marsupial yet on that isolated continent evolved into the same role as canines elsewhere, to the point where, at first glance, you would confuse the two.

 

EQ Ponies don't need, and are unlikely to have the same evolution history as their RL counterparts, so any argument posited on an assumption of a link is on desperately unsound ground

 

Therefore the argument that humans must have existed in Equestria because RL ponies owe a lot of their current form to selective breeding by humans is faulty as there is no conclusive evidence that EQponies have any biological link with RLponies. (Their morphological diferences, wings, horns, binocular vision, intelligence, ability to use tools with hooves!! , speech all seem to suggest that there is no link at all)

Edited February 24, 2014 by Ohnhai

[MistyStarBright 9]

Well maybe that was just a mess up when Ashleigh Ball was reading the script and no one noticed.

Or maybe the scriptwriter got it wrong.

Also, in one episode, Rarity said "on the other hand" and in another didn't know what ponies where supposed to wallow in.

She also didn't know that ponies don't usually wear clothes.

SECRETLY A HUMAN?

[Nameless Knight 1,001]

Or maybe the scriptwriter got it wrong.

Also, in one episode, Rarity said "on the other hand" and in another didn't know what ponies where supposed to wallow in.

She also didn't know that ponies don't usually wear clothes.

SECRETLY A HUMAN?

*inception sound* DUUUUUUN

[MistyStarBright 9]

*inception sound* DUUUUUUN

MAYBE SHE SPREAD THE RUMORS ABOUT LYRA TO GET THE FOCUS OFF OF HER.

They're not Humans. It's only inferred. We have no idea exactly what they are, but they're humanoid.

They're humans. They just made them the same color as the other universe so they wouldn't "offend" anybody by making certain ponies a certain race.

[lomk 20,663]

How about this car tire? That's rubber, folks. Ponies don't have rubber tires, only wooden wheels.

 

Maybe humans did once exist in Equestria, and MLP takes place long after their existence so any evidence that humans were ever there is gone, buried under thousands-no, millions-of years of weathering and erosion. 

And maybe the portal that Twilight passed through in EqG was actually a portal to the past. 

[Spartan 433]

Yes through a mirror that leads to another dimension

not what i meant xD like they live in another Nation of the world.. 

[M'aiq the Liar 5,804]

Maybe humans did once exist in Equestria, and MLP takes place long after their existence so any evidence that humans were ever there is gone, buried under thousands-no, millions-of years of weathering and erosion. 

And maybe the portal that Twilight passed through in EqG was actually a portal to the past. 

Maybe equstria takes place in the same world as Adventure time.

[Scootaloodle 1,623]

They just made them the same color as the other universe so they wouldn't "offend" anybody by making certain ponies a certain race.

 

Well maybe:

 

But couldn't it be that the characters in MLP FIM and all the MLP generations, as well as the toys that started it, are pastel coloured and unlike real ponies anyway, so they kept it simple and didn't try to fix what isn’t broken and stuck with that concept for human equivalents?

 

Tons of kids and adult animations have characters with the skin colours most people have in the real world: such as Ben 10, how many people wrote or write complaint letters because the Ben 10 character is white? or that Karl from the Simpsons is black?

 

(sorry for going off topic btw people)

Edited February 24, 2014 by Asherdangerdash

[MistyStarBright 9]

Well maybe:

 

But couldn't it be that the characters in MLP FIM and all the MLP generations, as well as the toys that started it, are pastel coloured and unlike real ponies anyway, so they kept it simple and didn't try to fix what isn’t broken and stuck with that concept for human equivalents?

 

Tons of kids and adult animations have characters with the skin colours most people have in the real world: such as Ben 10, how many people wrote or write complaint letters because the Ben 10 character is white? or that Karl from the Simpsons is black?

 

(sorry for going off topic btw people)

Good point there, but I think it's still true.

But here's an example;

okay, so, Twilight is a nerd, she does magic, is very well educated and has pointy eyes.

If she were Asain people would flip it.

If she was white, people would flip it for the nerd part.

Also, lots of bronies would flip it if anypony was any race, because it wouldn't match their headcannon, they'd get upset that Hasbro gave them a race, etc.

So it would be best to just leave it.

[Castle Bleck 19,364]

I would have put forth evidence like the fact that all their cups have handles on them (despite ponies not having fingers).

 

We've seen time and time again that they can just grab things with their hooves.

[GenderIsAnIllusion 2,177]

How about this car tire? That's rubber, folks. Ponies don't have rubber tires, only wooden wheels.]

 

bscap0081.jpg

That looks more like a grain grinding stone than a tire meng... Js

[Rarity Paige Belle 1,854]

We've seen time and time again that they can just grab things with their hooves.

I've never understood how they manage that. Maybe it's an evolutionary throwback, as ancient horses never used to have hooves, but toes instead!

[Never2muchpinkie 211]

SolarFox's point is good. But I don't think your historical argument works. While horses may have been bred by humans, the ponies in this show are not the same thing. Spanish horse breeders couldn't have existed if Spain doesn't exiat. It's a different world entirely.

The problem with that theory is from "suited for success." Fluttershy clearly asks for FRENCH haute couture. French= from France. So if there is a France in Equestria, there being a Spain is not out of the realm of possibilitiy.

[caramba2654 602]

How about this car tire? That's rubber, folks. Ponies don't have rubber tires, only wooden wheels.]

 

bscap0081.jpg

 

To quote Cheese Sandwich:

 

"Pretend you have no bones and do the rubber chicken dance!"

The problem with that theory is from "suited for success." Fluttershy clearly asks for FRENCH haute couture. French= from France. So if there is a France in Equestria, there being a Spain is not out of the realm of possibilitiy.

 

Then there's a Hawaii somewhere, cause Cheese Sandwich's song had a Hawaiian shirt in it.

[Equin Starbeat 22]

All evidence seems suprising because I never thought people looked as much, but I agree they must have got ideas from Humans or archeology

[Tigerpop198 696]

Humans will destroy Equestria. So no, there no place for humans in Equestria

What if it was the ponies that killed all the humans, the names of there places are fairly similar. The ponies took over. 

Edited February 25, 2014 by pony12343

[Adente 1,000]

See, this is why I don't make a habit of reading these types of threads...

[~Silver Essence~ 2,625]

Huh....

 

Well, if it's anything like G1, I would be down with that.

 

But if it's anything like the real world.......... no..

[Moved to Elsewhere 11,331]

Don't know where that logic came from, especially since the ponies take care of themselves.

[Oblivion 20,266]

How about this car tire? That's rubber, folks. Ponies don't have rubber tires, only wooden wheels.]

 

bscap0081.jpg

Think Equestria Girls! Maybe every now and then stuff gets teleported from the humane world into the equine one, or maybe the Equestria Girls verse actually USE to be a pony verse, but then something changed, or the ponies started to evolve in some way thus creating humans, or making them take on the appearance of humans any way!

[Luximus 482]

.......or, you know, it's just a show about talking, candy colored ponies.

[DubWolf 17,264]

Are you alluding MLP to the Planet of the Apes? The one thing that's missing is that there aren't any savage humans lurking around the ponies' crops for the ponies to hunt .

[SharpWit 2,669]

 

 

You couldn't fit a full sized horse down a mine could you!

well you could if you dug a bigger hole. that's just the result of laziness. problem solving.

 

I think that at one point Equestria had more advanced technology, but due to something like a war, or disease, or famine, or all three, population went down and much of the technology was lost, banned, or is used currently in moderation. Because of the ponies natural/magical abilities being able to be used for everyday needs, the old technology wasn't seen as something required, so it was given up. But every once in a while some of this old technology springs forth again such as flim and flam's locomotive whatever, and vinyl's equipment. 

 

Possibly the war was with the griffons, and they lost. as a means to pay for war debts they conducted trade with Equestria, which is why we see things like cups with handles, although applejacks mugs can fit pony hooves, so who knows. this is all head canon.

 

As for their ever being humans. no. sure ponies in our world may have been bred for spanish mines, but for MLP, I don't that works, especially with all of the history. Maybe those griffons made more than just cups since they don't have magical abilities we know of other than standing on clouds

 

 

The problem with that theory is from "suited for success." Fluttershy clearly asks for FRENCH haute couture. French= from France. So if there is a France in Equestria, there being a Spain is not out of the realm of possibilitiy.

True, but Gustav the griffon was french, and Equestria is based off of North America. On the official map we see an arrow pointing towards the griffons, but that is also in the same direction as europe. so does that mean that griffons are really european, and instead of them colonizing the new world. both ponies and other large mammals, more specifically bison, crossed what would be the considered the land bridge from asia to north america, during the ice age/windegos fucking with everyone because they're like that?

 

I'm surprised that no one has brought up Iron Will yet. Minotaur. half man half bull