Who is more evil? Rainbow Factory RD, Pinkamena from Cupcakes, or M Bison?

[Adachi 772]

I'm thinking Rainbow Factory RD, because she mangled ponies who failed their flying test to make rainbows. Even though it was necessary (arguably), she took great delight in doing it. Pinkamena is pretty high on the evil scale too, because she killed ponies to make coats and treats out of them. M Bison is pretty evil because he brainwashed a bunch of girls into being dolls for him, who killed on his command, and when his current body expired, he was gonna possess one of them. On a scale from 1-3, 1 being most evil, 3 being least evil, this is how I would rate them.

 

1 - M Bison

2 - RD (insane but performed a needed (questionable) duty

3 - Pinkamena (insane)

 

 

The reason I rated RD 2nd and Pinkamena last, is because they were mentally insane, so they get at least a partial excuse. Why else would they do messed up stuff like that? And at least they felt remorse when they killed their best friends. Also, RD was perfoming a needed (questionable) duty, and her duty drove her insane, being forced to kill Scootaloo took away the last shred of sanity she maintained. M Bison on the other hand kidnaps people, brainwashes them to force them to kill others, then uses their bodies as his new vessels, and not to mention his drug trade and other crimes (including killing Chun-Li's father, and also, killing Charlie). Pretty messed up.

 

Edit: Then again, I might switch RD and Pinkamena since Pinkamena did it purely because she was cuckoo bananas, and not because anyone needed her to do it.

Edited March 26, 2014 by Ryudo

[Geek0zoid 1,468]

Pinkamena.

She cut open Dashie and pulled her freaking guts out...

*Vomit*

[Scootalove 10,689]

Pinkamena, because she kills ponies and makes them into treats with no remorse of course.

[Ribbonfree 2,383]

Evil is a nuanced and complicated thing that neither Rainbow Factory nor Cupcakes explored well. They were snuff fics, pure and simple, and neither villain had especially good or interesting motivation in my opinion. So I'm going to say M Bison. At least we know more about his character than what we're offered the insane ponies.

Edited March 26, 2014 by Lil' Strapless

[Adachi 772]

Pinkamena, because she kills ponies and makes them into treats with no remorse of course.

I think she did feel some remorse when killing Dashie. She said she really wished she didn't have to kill her because she's her best friend, but her number came up.

[Scootalove 10,689]

I think she did feel some remorse when killing Dashie. She said she really wished she didn't have to kill her because she's her best friend, but her number came up.

Well, only some. Until, she had to kill her.

[ninjamon102938 222]

M bison because OF COURSE and YESSS YESSS

[Adachi 772]

Evil is a nuanced and complicated thing that neither Rainbow Factory nor Cupcakes explored well. They were snuff fics, pure and simple, and neither villain had especially good or interesting motivation in my opinion. So I'm going to say M Bison. At least we know more about his character than what we're offered the insane ponies.

Well, Celestia ordered Dashie to kill them, because their bodies were needed to manufacture rainbows. Although she ended up not caring about most of the ponies she killed (probably forced herself into not caring, so she wouldn't go completely insane from sadness/guilt). I think of RF RD as more of a tragic villain, because she had to compromise her morals to follow an order that was "for the good of Equestria", and she lost her sanity, and her sis as a result.

[Ribbonfree 2,383]

Well, Celestia ordered Dashie to kill them, because their bodies were needed to manufacture rainbows. Although she ended up not caring about most of the ponies she killed (probably forced herself into not caring, so she wouldn't go completely insane from sadness/guilt). I think of RF RD as more of a tragic villain, because she had to compromise her morals to follow an order that was "for the good of Equestria", and she lost her sanity, and her sis as a result.

 

I didn't like the story and the justifications, I didn't think they were well explored enough. That's why I said what i said.

[Malinter 3,064]

M bison because OF COURSE and YESSS YESSS

 

"What is it with you women? I killed MY father and you don't hear me complaining about it!"

[Archer Dash 163]

Was there ever any doubt?  (Pinkamena is still creepy as hell though)

[LightningGearV3.01 52]

Pinkamena, and for a good reason.

 

Rainbow factory dash may have been cruel, but it was for the sake of keeping something dear to them. also, all these ponies were probably death row inmates or something to make them deserve it.

 

M. Bison may have been a jerk, but his intentions were to overthrow the 'corrupt' government and preserve earth's natural resources (?)

 

Pinkamena has absolutely no reason to have done what she did. It was all for her own sick, personal gain, and nothing more. Everyone else had a goal in mind. That...thing took lives because she enjoyed her twisted way of doing things: everyone was a means to an end, and everyone was fair game. Even m. Bison, who single handedly purged all the good from his soul has more heart than that monster.

[DoubleRainbow_Dash 317]

Pinkamina is without a doubt the scariest of the three because she just murders ponies without remorse in the most sadistic way possible. However Rainbow Factory RD is second because although what she was doing was wrong she did it for what she thought was a noble cause.

[Adachi 772]

Pinkamena, and for a good reason.

 

Rainbow factory dash may have been cruel, but it was for the sake of keeping something dear to them. also, all these ponies were probably death row inmates or something to make them deserve it.

 

M. Bison may have been a jerk, but his intentions were to overthrow the 'corrupt' government and preserve earth's natural resources (?)

 

Pinkamena has absolutely no reason to have done what she did. It was all for her own sick, personal gain, and nothing more. Everyone else had a goal in mind. That...thing took lives because she enjoyed her twisted way of doing things: everyone was a means to an end, and everyone was fair game. Even m. Bison, who single handedly purged all the good from his soul has more heart than that monster.

I thought that M Bison only did what he did for global conquest. He kidnapped a bunch of girls and brainwashed them to keep them around as "just in case" bodies for when his current body expires. On top of that, he gets stronger the more that people hate him, and he uses Psycho Power, which is a corrupted form of Soul Power.

 

And in Street Fighter 2 Turbo, he even admits that he wanted to conquer the world all along, and he says he couldn't have done it without the player's help.

Edited March 27, 2014 by Ryudo

[Courageous Thunder Dash 7,824]

Freaking Pinkamena all the way...

[That 80s Pony 62]

Pinkamena all the way.

She enjoys brutally killing ponies for no reason!

That's pretty gut-wrenching...  -_- 

[Cirrus. 1,090]

Cupcakes was unfortunately the first fan made thing I read when I was finding out what the heck was going on with this show. I had seen enough of the show by the time I read it to know how the characters personalities are.

 

The thing I notice that people don't appear to get is that Pinkie Pie in "Cupcakes" is not the deflated-mane, twitchy, inanimate object conversing, looney Pinkamena like we know and love in "Party of One."

 

 

She is instead portrayed as a much more sinister Psychopath. She appears "Normal" (I'm using that very loosely here lol) and by that I mean how she usually acts in the show, but also kills and is completely unsuspected. She is NOT in Pinkamena mode.

 

Psychopaths are MUCH scarier than Pinkamena (aka obviously crazy) types in my book because they are so deceptive and undetectable. They're so hard to catch because they carefully plan out every detail, don't really make many mistakes, and don't have "Real" empathy- but are very good at mimicking it.

 

By the way, I have taken some Psychology/Criminology classes and studied different serial killers/mental illnesses for my Criminal Justice Major.

 

If someone did animate this story like it was written without Pinkie in Pinkamena form- a lot of the fandom would probably be extremely angery/upset.

Edited March 27, 2014 by steve88

[Adorkable 2,737]

M. Bison, so hard.

 

Right?

 

I'm kidding. ^^

 

But between those two, I would have to guess....Cupcakes?

 

Really, Pages of Harmony should have been an option, I haven't read it, but I heard it makes Cupcakes and Rainbow Factory look like child's bedtime stories.

[Rainboom Dash 1,056]

Pinkamena, for reasons several others here have given.

[TheChosenPony 279]

I know this wasn't an option but-

 

M.A Larson.

 

[SapphireStone 0]

I have not read either. I'm still gatering the courage to read them!

[King_DeQuan 8]

Pinkamena. She tortures ponies for as long as possible until their heart stops beating, and makes creepy jokes while doing it. Then, she makes the said pony into cupcakes, and feeds them to everone. That's pretty sinister.

[Doc. Volt 2,561]

@,

 

EHI!

 

here at the Cloudsdale Weather Coporation we work only and only to improve the lives of many ponies, dealing with the weather and provind all Equestria with beautifull rainbows! How can we be evil?? PRAISE THE FLOCK! MUAHAHAHA!

[Darker 1,351]

M Bison is actually a villain that feels evil while doing the correct thing.

 

He wins easily for me, he's one of the best video game villains, the other ones are merely creepypasta characters.

[Splashee 28,566]

... M Bison is an evil dictator that will get you with Psycho crush move it whatever. I would go with that