What Would Happen If PewDiePie Declares that He is a Brony

[Leonard Smix 421]

Markiplier joked about being a brony, I wasn't amused.

 

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=z8himX0bYNg

[Snow Frostflame 3,568]

well lets see here is the most reasonable thing that would happen all his ABB subs will unsub

he will get a lot more attention in the Brony fandom

and a little less attention in general or will cause more people to join the fandom

but after I saw the scene where he was drowning Twilight in a Amnesia custom story I don't think he will ever join us

[Pinky Pie 71]

Markiplier joked about being a brony, I wasn't amused.

 

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=z8himX0bYNg

Neither did I but he may be a brony even thought he said he wasn't. I mean, among all of those episodes why did he choose one of the best and the most-loved one (Sonic Rainboom)?

 

 

well lets see here is the most reasonable thing that would happen all his ABB subs will unsub

he will get a lot more attention in the Brony fandom

and a little less attention in general or will cause more people to join the fandom

but after I saw the scene where he was drowning Twilight in a Amnesia custom story I don't think he will ever join us

Can you please send me the link of that video, I've never seen it ^^

[Darker 1,352]

He has a lot of subscribers that are bronies. Not sure if he is one(It's much more possible that her girlfriend, Marzia, is).

 

There's one Youtuber very similar with Pewdiepie named Yamimash. He has much lesser subs, but he is a brony. And hey, people love him no matter what.

[Kyoshi Frost Wolf 41,934]

Not a single buck would be given, not from me anyway.

 

There is nothing special about him, at all. And yes, I know he gave money to charity before. If I made that much money doing nothing, I would donate too.

 

No offense to fans of him of course, I just don't like him much.

[Invincible 2,092]

This. This is what will happen:

 

[Fractured 2,684]

We will receive an influx of bronies who will claim to have watched the show. Secretly, they've formed their entire perception of FIM on one episode(Party of One;who'd have guessed?). Forums will be boarded, fanfictions mass produced...
I'm tasting colors just thinking about it.

[Envy 6,262]

I honestly have no clue who in the world that is. But after seeing "Bro Army", I am pretty sure I can say I don't ever want to know.

[Shadowking58 1,137]

Hi everypony. PewDiePie's current subscriber number is 30.176.517, which means he got the most subscriber number in YouTube. And when I was watching it, I just wondered what would happen if PewDiePie says that he's a brony. That would be an awesome weapon for those who hate them, but for the "Bro Army"... Here is my ideas about what would happen:

1) Hatred against bronies would really decrease (Which I hope)

2) PewDiePie would lose at least %50 of his subscribers (Which would probably happen)

PewDiePie needs to be taken down a few notches.

He's insanely overrated, in my eyes.

I'm sure he's a good person in real life, but online, ugh.

He has a lot of subscribers that are bronies. Not sure if he is one(It's much more possible that her girlfriend, Marzia, is).

 

There's one Youtuber very similar with Pewdiepie named Yamimash. He has much lesser subs, but he is a brony. And hey, people love him no matter what.

Yamimash is a brony? I know he has used them in his thumbnails before, but has he ever flat out said it?

I've been subscribed to Yami for a year.

[Darker 1,352]

PewDiePie needs to be taken down a few notches.

He's insanely overrated, in my eyes.

I'm sure he's a good person in real life, but online, ugh.

Yamimash is a brony? I know he has used them in his thumbnails before, but has he ever flat out said it?

I've been subscribed to Yami for a year.

He has referenced the show a couple times in the past while playing Gmod with SeaNanners, Markiplier or TheRpgMinx. Also he played a MLP monopoly once if I remember correctly, the only time him and Mark met in person.

[Shadowking58 1,137]

He has referenced the show a couple times in the past while playing Gmod with SeaNanners, Markiplier or TheRpgMinx. Also he played a MLP monopoly once if I remember correctly, the only time him and Mark met in person.

Do you remember the videos?

[Literally Snails 2,307]

I don't know and I don't care. PewDiePie is just a bunch of inexplicably popular white noise to me.

[Darker 1,352]

Do you remember the videos?

So far I only found one where he mentions MLP. I'm still searching for the others.

 

 

[SparklingSquirrels 21,366]

Yeah, he'd probably lose some of his fans, but then again, other bronies might like him more if he was a brony.

[Dattebayo 2,850]

Yeah, he'd probably lose some of his fans, but then again, other bronies might like him more if he was a brony.

To say that people will like him better just because he was a brony is redonkulous.

But sadly, probably true

Edited August 29, 2014 by Dattebayo

[Gernia 691]

I have a fear that the image of the MLP fandom will get worse in some people's eyes and some of his fans will probably become fans too because of that, which might make things even worse. Then again, some of the people who don't like us already will likely never change no matter what, so I guess it doesn't really matter.

 

I can't, or won't, stop him from doing that, though.

[A goat 323]

I would not give 2 craps if he became a brony. But if he DID become a brony, closet bronies would gain enough confidence to come out of their closet and tell people. However, his fanbase will probably be divided (which I couldn't care less about), and his critics will probably use the fact that he's brony as a criticism. Not all, but some.

[ShadowPirateX 600]

I personally wouldn't mind if PewDiePie became a brony. I'm a bit worried over how his less mature fans would act over it, but other than that I'd be cool with a cool guy watching a cool show.

[chirox the pony 1,336]

I wouldn't care if he was a brony, however if his fans start liking it then that's a different story, by which I mean I might leave this forum(assuming it gets filled up with his fanboys).

[Nameless Knight 1,001]

Even though I barely watch him (because he stopped being funny, like smosh, after age 12), I would be kind of happy, maybe it will increase our numbers by maybe 1 million? ...but also kind of angry or sad, because then a good deal of pewds haters might hate bronies too.... 

[Pinky Pie 71]

because then a good deal of pewds haters might hate bronies too.... 

I'm pretty sure almost all of them already hate us Some guys are like robots, programmed to hate everyone different than themselves.

[Nameless Knight 1,001]

I'm pretty sure almost all of them already hate us Some guys are like robots, programmed to hate everyone different than themselves.

 yeah your probably right, but the few that don't hate us will hate us...

 

I met a guy who was okay with me being a brony, but once he found out I watched pewds, he got really angry...

[ShintX 180]

He would Hoof fist the screen with his hoofiness.

[BitterBubblegum 75]

Let the comment flame war begin...

[Simon 4,557]

This thread appears to be discussing the Brony fandom so it has been moved to Sugarcube Corner.  The General Discussion area is meant for topics not directly related to My Little Pony.