What if all female characters in the show would be male?

[leonbrony17 1,216]

Fluttershy would lose her cuteness. Rainbow dash would look more muscular for sure. Pinkie would be ??? Twilight would be a nerd. Rarity would be very different. But i think applejack would be okay in my opinion.

 

Whould you like male mane 6?

[silvadel 1,393]

On cross and arrows.  It would certainly be different.  I think I would fit in less

[leonbrony17 1,216]

And all male characters would be female.

 

Would you still like the show?

[Lillim 45]

Ya id most likely like it more   i collect male mlp figurines so lel

[cmarston1 5,959]

I dunno, maybe I would still like the show.

But if it meant that we didn't get the EQG series, I probably would have burnt out on FIM at some point.

When I am not all that interested in FIM, EQG is able to help keep me motivated and give some of that similar charm, and keep my interest in G4 alive.

[Ganondorf8 11,303]

If their personalities remain mostly the same, then I'd be okay with it.

[Ashen Pathfinder 16,161]

@@leonbrony17

 

Just letting you know that I edited the title of your topic so as to better convey your question.

 

And to answer your question; of course! Character is more than just gender/sex of course.

[LeafFerret 3,382]

No, we just have too many shows that have a male main character, for once, I would like to see a female do their jobs.

[Sphinx-Ara 3,569]

Yeah I would, maybe little more or a little less, would I'd prefer though is a mix, 3 of them being female and the other 3 being male

[Starlighty 948]

Rarity would probably be gay...... hahahah 

 

Twilight would still be a nerd. (like the wizard guy) 

 

Pinkie pie would be like a mascot character  

 

RD would be the muscle jock 

 

Fluttershy would the shy quiet type still but in guy forum  

 

And I think AJ would just be the same but in guy forum like Big mac before he had that indecent at the hospital

 

 

BUT it would be really interesting because they would probably throw a lot of guy jokes and stuff in 

[GeekySonic 1,150]

Probably. Possibly. I don't know.

[EmployeeAMillion 70]

Definitely. One of the charming things about the show's cast is that, although it's predominantly female, you don't care about their gender so much as the adventures they go on. Although it would cost the existence of episodes like Look Before You Sleep and Simple Things, or at least change them a lot.

[Barpy 2,225]

It has it's upsides and downsides.

[AlbaTross 1,586]

Fluttershy would lose her cuteness. Rainbow dash would look more muscular for sure. Pinkie would be ??? Twilight would be a nerd. Rarity would be very different. But i think applejack would be okay in my opinion.

Whould you like male mane 6?

Hi, as there are two topics that are relatively similar I have decided to merge them.

[The_Gobo 36,257]

Would change the story a lot.
Not sure I'd be okay with some of the changes, but if the focus was only the main 6 being R63'd, then meh, it would make for an interesting episode. lol

[They call me Loyalty 1,948]

The traits you mentioned are not necessarily exclusive to the male gender. Personally, I don't imagine them all that different.

[Foxy Socks 2,599]

I like these kind of things, and would find it very cute for them to still be mostly the same characters.

[Applejacket 185]

I reckon AJ would be kind of a handsome, muscly cutie who doesn't really speak much, like Big Mac. But considering she appears to have the same body shape as everypony else I wouldn't give her her brother's body shape, I'd give them all the same body shape. Also, since when did Rainbow Blitz need lightning eyebrows? Lol it makes him look even stupider! RD doesn't have them, so why does he? :I

[Le Trotteur Sauvage 13,051]

The show will not have worked as well as it's used to ! Just imagine all the cuteness, gone !   
But I think there's not enough male character tho, it's just, girls everywhere.

[----- 477]

I guess it would be the same show only with male characters.

I do not see them changed personalitywise.

But all the shippings would then probably be gay (like guy x guy gay). °^°

Edited January 26, 2017 by Fluidty

[Nerdy Luigi 2,065]

It wouldn't be bad surely, but to be honest it would probably have less appeal to me, because almost everything else has a main character roster dominated by males. Plus, female characters just seem to be more relatable.

[AlbaTross 1,586]

Hard to say. I like that the gender of the characters is more or less inconsequential but I've grown attached to the characters the way they are, gender and all. Plus seeing some rule 63 fanart once triggered a rule 63 dream for me that I would call a nightmare. Things just got a little too real there, mostly because I myself was rule 63ed, though curiously enough I think near the end I reached the point where just enough of me knew it was a dream while still enough of me bought it as I remember refusing to watch FiM with my gender-swapped friend in spite of enjoying hours of rule 63 AVGN with Janine Rolfe.

[Tropico 226]

I think all their personalities would be the same if it was a real equestrian world. Since its a show by hasbro yeah, they would be different. specially rarity and fluttershy.

 

but hasbro or real equestria, I do think some jokes and resolution of problems would be a lil different.

 

 

 

But all the shippings would then probably be gay

 

 

Thats what I like