What Episode Reminded You that MLP was for Little Girls?

[Gaines 1,223]

It was the season 7 premiere for me  It was just way too cheesy

[Cagey 4,248]

"Magical Mystery Cure" for me. Not a problem with Twilight's ascension, but the pacing, lack of explanation, and sheer density of musical numbers did it.

[Splashee 28,564]

It was the beginning of A Canterlot Wedding, when Spike comes and ruins the Mane 6's picnic with the announcement that Twilight has a brother and that whole wedding situation. Thankfully it picked up the drama and music numbers as the story went on, but that initial beginning of a forced princess wedding was just so aimed at the real target audience.

[Tacodidra 61,174]

"Suited for Success" – I didn't dislike it, but it did have a lot of focus on fashion. Fast forward a week or so, and I've become a Rarity fan.

[Silly Druid 6,983]

"Fame and Misfortune". For obvious reasons.

[Splashee 28,564]

Lol, I keep forgetting the theme song. The beginning, is sung in a way that is not directed towards boys at all. It was a constant reminder. However the rest of the theme song is great and catchy.

[They call me Loyalty 1,948]

That is the reason I like FiM. It is light-hearted, touching, full of charm, and cleverly written, for the most part. The point being that it is really good, actually.

[Ice Princess Silky <3 13,904]

You mean that moment of "oh! right, while this show is rich in meaning and not one dimensional, it's not going to be TOO deep because it's not only just for little girls but for children in general" type of moment? The moment for me was when they tried to reform each and every bad character. It made me giggle cause, like, while it IS good for teaching the premise of empathy to children (the whole 'yeah that person SEEMS bad but they were simply hurt, just be kind to them and they'll change, etc) it's not necessarily true in the real world. Life's too complex for that and then it hits you -- 'oh, this is a show for kids -- don't go THAT deep." XD

But I still enjoyed the show.

[Ring Team 123]

Probably one episode and one character approach: How Rarity was portrayed in season 1, although Sisterhooves Social changed my mind back in 2011.

The episode in particular was "Simple Ways" from season 4. The premise, the pacing and the execution of some core ideas were very silly. It's a pity, because her previous episode, Rarity Takes Manehattan, shows a high level of maturity I wish it was maintained in a kids show.

[Splashee 28,564]

Even when Bronies on YouTube were defending the show, it was a clear indication that something was off about the show's target. The whole "the show is not made for little girls because" and "MLP in the past was bad because it was made for little girls, but the new MLP is good because.... um....." was a real indication that MLP was made for little girls.

[Megas 27,630]

It always was. And no, that’s not an insult, nor should it be one 

In fact I always  felt the show got worse when they tried catering more towards bronies

Edited September 16 by Megas

[Evil Pink One 13,506]

.

When grown men debate and quarrel about the show.... I realized that this show is for kids.... If you get what i mean...

[Sasoriman 136]

The first seasons were, if nothing else, strong reminders that the show is for 5-year-olds first and whole families second. Season 9, being the weakest, had a few of those from Common Ground, which was lackluster in places, to Going to Seed, full-bodied and yet uneventful. 

[EpicEnergy 23,218]

Season 1's episode "Look Before You Sleep" is about Twilight holding a slumber party, which only girls do, so that reminded me I was watching a little girl's show. The later seasons seem to be targeted towards older ages than the target ages of the earlier seasons.

[Antiyonder 1,153]

Have to reiterate that it seems like people will accept/tolerate any thing from male oriented properties of the lowest quality, so I think it intellectually dishonest to then watch a program for girls if exceptional.

On 2023-02-23 at 2:29 AM, Evil Pink One said:

.

When grown men debate and quarrel about the show.... I realized that this show is for kids.... If you get what i mean...

A line from Goldeneye says it best.  "You're like boys with toys".