Ice Cream-Flavored Donuts or Donut-Flavored Ice Cream?

[Comrade Friendship 426]

Soooo, I saw this post

I couldn't choose for the life of me

And decided to save the world

Ice Cream-Flavored Donuts or Donut-Flavored Ice Cream?

Either way I'm sure you'll be as happy as Twilight!

[MidnightFire1222 1,682]

Ice cream can be many different flavors so I don’t know if ice cream flavored donuts can be achieved or not. Donuts can be topped with different flavored and filled with different filling flavors, but without that boil down to theirsame flavor. I personally think donut flavored ice cream makes more sense.

[Comrade Friendship 426]

23 minutes ago, MidnightFire1222 said:

Ice cream can be many different flavors so I don’t know if ice cream flavored donuts can be achieved or not. Donuts can be topped with different flavored and filled with different filling flavors, but without that boil down to theirsame flavor. I personally think donut flavored ice cream makes more sense.

Just ask Pinkie what's possible in the world of sweets

[Samurai Equine 45,944]

Donut flavored ice cream.

The thing about Ice Cream is that temperature is a component. It's not ice cream if it isn't cold; it melts. Whenever people try to make ice-cream flavored things, it always fails. The food in question is never something served cold. Even if ice cream was used as an ingredient, by that point, it's just flavor. There is nothing that will make you say "Ooh~! That just tastes like ice cream!". Nope. If you used Vanilla ice cream, the donut will just have a vanilla flavor, not an ice cream flavor. If you used chocolate ice cream, the donut will just have a chocolate flavor. Etc.

With ice cream, you can put almost anything in it. I've seen ice cream with brownie chunks. It would be too easy to make and sell an ice cream with chunks of donuts in it.  That's really the only way it would work, if you ask me.

Spoiler

Surprisingly, the only combination (that I can think of) that works both ways is Ice Cream and Cake.
You can buy an Ice Cream Cake, or you can buy a flavor of Ice Cream with chunks of cake in it.

 

[Clawdeen 12,110]

This. This is the true question of all questions.

Id say donut flavored ice cream although I wouldn’t say no to ice cream flavored donuts.

[Hadrien 937]

A donut flavored ice cream flavored donut flavored ice cream flavored donut flavored ice cream flavored donut flavored. 

So a donut that taste like a donut... 

[MidnightFire1222 1,682]

20 hours ago, Comrade Friendship said:

Just ask Pinkie what's possible in the world of sweets

Point taken. I guess I was thinking in more real life terms than imaginary terms.

[Comrade Friendship 426]

20 hours ago, Samurai Oni said:

Donut flavored ice cream.

The thing about Ice Cream is that temperature is a component. It's not ice cream if it isn't cold; it melts. Whenever people try to make ice-cream flavored things, it always fails. The food in question is never something served cold. Even if ice cream was used as an ingredient, by that point, it's just flavor. There is nothing that will make you say "Ooh~! That just tastes like ice cream!". Nope. If you used Vanilla ice cream, the donut will just have a vanilla flavor, not an ice cream flavor. If you used chocolate ice cream, the donut will just have a chocolate flavor. Etc.

bruh, behold

Edited October 19, 2023 by Comrade Friendship

[Trot Shuffle 3,599]

I'll gladly take both

but just one? Maybe the ice cream flavored donuts. Only because  I can stomach more donuts than ice cream.

 

[Iforgotmybrain 3,518]

I agree with Samurai. He’s got the science down.

[Dreambiscuit 8,024]

I think I’d go for the ice cream flavored donuts. I like donuts better than ice cream but I like ice cream enough to be intrigued by it as a donut flavor.

[EpicEnergy 22,089]

Donut flavored ice cream, and bonus if it has chocolate syrup, whipped cream, and sprinkles on it.

[Spark Thunderbass 1,398]

Ice cream flavored donuts sounds tastier to me, I'm not really that big into ice cream, would rather a donut flavored milkshake if anything.

[Cash In 21,528]

Yeah, I have to go with donut flavoured ice cream. I could imagine myself enjoying that. Can't say the same about the other one.