If you had lots and lots of peanut butter, what would you make with it?

[Espy Vibe 4,448]

Asking for a friend 

Just going through the pantry and for some reason we have 11 jars of peanut butter.

[Snoopy Fan 1,658]

I’d make a bunch of peanut butter based foods (peanut butter sandwiches, peanut butter cookies, etc.) and throw a peanut butter party.

[abronymouse 5,867]

a happy cow

 

[Tao 8,027]

I would do cookies or brownies 

[Totally Nyx 36,204]

I'd make a lot of crummy buttons.

[Silly Druid 7,220]

I would separate it into peanuts and butter.

[Sparklefan1234 172,974]

14 minutes ago, Totally Nyx said:

I'd make a lot of crummy buttons.

*Mmm* Crumbly peanut butter shirt. *Drools like Homer Simpson* 

[ZiggWheelsManning 11,099]

An X-wing starfighter.  Should I use it for combat against enemy TIEs or eat it?  

[SharpWit 2,718]

@Espy Vibe Are these all different brands or are they the same? Also are they all open?

[Mothra 703]

Why bother with the hassle? Just cut out the middle man, embrace the PB and eat straight from the jar

[DubWolf 17,380]

Strategically smear it  .

[Snow 7,549]

Peanut butter sandcastle 

[Totally Nyx 36,204]

I should probably branch out a bit. I'd make some peanut butter cookies too.

[Ganondorf8 11,385]

I'm no baker so my options are extremely limited, but I could do is melt the peanut butter down into liquid and make some kind of soup out of it.

[ThePinkestofPones 3,463]

BIG BATCH OF BROWNIES

[Fluttershutter 2,543]

Yeah, peanut butter cookies and brownies.

If they're not expired. I find expired stuff in the back of the pantry all the time. 

[Espy Vibe 4,448]

Cookies are a good idea, been craving them lately. I was also thinking maybe a peanut butter milkshake since we have some ice cream and a good amount of milk too.

I learned though that most are being used to make a peanut dipping sauce for spring rolls. But, that's the most I've ever seen. We don't eat that many spring rolls like that.

22 hours ago, SharpWit said:

@Espy Vibe Are these all different brands or are they the same? Also are they all open?

Oops, I probably should've said that they're unopened, the oil has separated from most (no big deal) and the oldest one expires in December 2025, and yes it's a mix of different brands.

 

[SharpWit 2,718]

For your cookies you have traditional, but there's also no bake that you freeze with oats and chocolate.

I've made a savory PB&J with peanut sauce, wine sauce, and crostini.

Peanut sauce also goes with a variety of thai foods.

Peanut butter banana bread

Peanut brittle

Spread some on pinecone, roll in bird seed, and hang them outside on trees for critters to enjoy.

Donate some to your local food bank.

Make a review video comparing all the different brands to jumpstart your YouTube career. 

[Iforgotmybrain 5,816]

Aside from cookies and brownies, might I recommend candy buckeyes? I don't know how common they are outside of Ohio and Michigan, but they're peanut butter and chocolate candies that resemble the nut from the Ohio Buckeye tree. Hence the name. They're pretty easy to make, and are absolutely delicious, like anything made of chocolate and peanut butter. If you look up "buckeye candies" you should find lots of recipes.

[Cash In 22,524]

Depends on how much peanut butter I have, but honestly, I'd probably just have it on toast and pancakes for a couple of months.

[SparklingSquirrels 21,356]

Pad thai perhaps? With homemade peanut sauce 

You’ll need a lot of other ingredients though… might as well just eat the peanut butter straight up 

[Treeglow Flicker 13,889]

Make a bust of Darth Vader out of it and then leave it on a pedestal inside an art gallery somewhere.

[Megas 27,785]

Peanut Butter brownies. Using PB fresh out of the jar goes a long way for that right kind of salty and sweetness