WYR: Entire musical episode or songs as is

[Doctor XFizzle 8,670]

Here's a "would you rather" of sorts for Season 3.

 

Would you rather have one hour-long (so 45ish minutes) special of an entirely musical episode. No talking, just one song after another to portray a story. BUT those are the only songs of Season 3. No other episodes in Season 3 will have songs.

 

or no musical episode and have songs spread out Season 3 like it normally is now.

 

Which will you choose?

 

Personally, as epic as an hour-long musical special would be, that would be lame if none of the other episodes would have songs. If the season is only 13 episodes long, then maybe I'll be more open to it, but if it's 26 no way. The special, if done, would have to be near the end of the season to give Daniel and crew tons of time to get everything done.

[MVC NVMXD JVRXD 2,406]

I'm not a big song fan, so I'd rather just have one musical.

[Pinkie D Pie 1,036]

Music thoughout the show. I like having one every few episodes, and wouldn't enjoy sitting though a full episode of just songs.

[~Chaos~ 3,971]

I'd just keep the songs spread out through the season, it's more enjoyable that way, watching an hour long special and knowing that it would have the only songs crammed into that one episode seems a bit silly, I like not knowing when a potential song will pop up and delightfully surprise us!

 

But I guess if the songs were well done, it could be kind of cool, but I'd just stick with spreading them out.

[Tenshinohana 264]

I would definitely want "no musical special, but music throughout the season". I'm such a music person that I always enjoy new songs - especially if the music is the same quality through the season. Because who can deny it...

 

DANIEL IGRAM AND WILLIAM KEVIN ANDERSON ROCKS.

Edited July 12, 2012 by Tenshinohana

[Vega 107]

Music throughout. An entirely musical episode wouldn't fit the established style of the show.

[PonyHag1 591]

I'd prefer music throughout the season.

[Twiliscael 3,962]

The whole appeal of the songs to me is how their like a fun little suprise when they show up. At any moment, I'm thinking "Pinkie could burst out into song right now," or "This would be the perfect time for Dash to sing." Having one episode would ruin my whole appeal of the music, so no I would not want a musical episode. Also, I can take one song at a time bit I might get a little teensy bit annoyed after 45+ minutes of singing.

[Random User 249]

I'd prefer music throughout the entire season in various episodes. The musical parts cover the topic at hand, and so give the songs a wider variety of subjects than one musical would probably produce, and variety entices me.