Which Pony Do You Think Should Be a Princess?

[Lightning Dancer 28]

Ok so I was thinking one day. (a.k.a today) Which pony of the mane 6 should be a Princess next if there was going to be another. I personally think Pinkie Pie would make an epic Princess and bring laughter to all of Equesteria! But what do you think? Reply in the comments and vote on the poll!

[Chigens and Kay 3,833]

None of them, honestly. We already have enough princesses...

 

Are Celestia, Luna, Cadance, and Twilight not enough? I think so.

---

 

If I absolutely had to choose, it would be Applejack. She is a hard worker and is very responsible. She has a strong head on her shoulders and I could see her carrying a nation.

[Scootalove 10,689]

I could definitely see Applejack be a princess, because we have seen her be hard working and well being able to maintain her own nation while she helps her friends with any issues.

[TailsIsNotAlone 3,695]

For the love of Celestia, none. In my view, no pony that wasn't a princess before Season 3 needs to be a princess now.

 

Applejack could handle the responsibility, but she would hate sitting around and looking pretty all day.

[Fhaolan 4,484]

Forget the Mane 6, Blueblood *needs* to be the next princess. I can just see the episode where, in a crazed, ever escalating desire to be the center of attention, he ends up stapling wings to himself, and is carted off to the asylum to get the cell next to Screw Loose.

[Shanks 10,816]

None of them please, we have enough princesses as it is alicorn Twilight may have come out of nowhere but at least it actually made sense for her to eventually become one but I just don't see it for the others. Rainbow Dash is too impatient and hot headed though she is improving, Fluttershy is kind and gentle but is not decisive and assertive enough. Pinkie Pie is way too naive, immature and has way too short of an attention span, Rarity is generous but already has enough problems with vanity as it is she dosen't need anything to feed that. Applejack would be the most well suited to become one but would have a great deal of trouble balancing that and her obligations to her family and the farm and would probably work herself into the ground.

[MelancholicMemory 2,027]

If there is another princess, it should be Colgate because she would have dominion of the most important thing ever. There needs to be a god-princess of good oral hygiene.

[elbj 190]

I think there are enough princesses. Four sounds like good stopping point for adding princesses to me. However, I think adding an Alicorn Prince into the mix would be interesting. The writers would need to make one up though, I don't see any stallions that have been shown so far being able to achieve Alicorn status like Twilight did. As much as I'd love to see Big Mac become an Alicorn, I fear it might ruin the show.

[Righteous Fury 344]

I find your lack of Big Mac disturbing.

 

 

Best Princess is best Princess.

 

(on topic, Fluttershy would be my choice, whoever doesn't want to rule is the person most suited to do it)

[Rainbow Dash Loyalty 1,275]

I wouldn't really think it would be such a great idea for another princess xP But if I honestly had to choose then Applejack should be next in the Princess line ;P

She's a good leader, honest, loyal and she's pretty smart. She's someone you can count on, so that's my reason why she could be the next alicorn princess xP

[~StatesTheOblivious~ 1,795]

All of them. But only under one condition. They intruduce that being an alicorn doesn't necessarily mean that you are a royalty, too. And I mean that in both ways.

Edited June 9, 2013 by StatesTheOblivious

[hawkflame 3,310]

Can anyone say Princess Alicorn Derpy?

 

(spoilered for size)

 

 

 

 

 

 

I don't know about anyone else, but I am definitely in favor of Derpicorn. 

[lincolnshirepony 527]

I don't think any of them should be a princess. I'm not sure any of them would want to be a princess anyways. That would conflict with their goals because they wouldn't be able to pursue their talents if they had to worry about looking after Equestria. 

[Trixies Apprentice L 493]

In all honesty none at all but for the w/e factor I would want to see how Rarity would coop being one she is the one having the dream after all. The other just don't fit the image 

[DND 2,355]

The rest besides Applejack would be a poor choice because the others don't show great qualities for princess-hood.

 

- Hyperactivity, childish actions

- Drama-queen, a bit uptight

- Shyness, wallflower qualities

- Arrogance, competition induced

 

Let's just face it: the others would create dysfunctional royalty. 

[Ilovepegasi 6]

honestly don't see applejack being a princess just her personality wouldn't be suited to it in my opinion... but then again I voted Pinkie Pie as next princess so. Lol  

 

Can anyone say Princess Alicorn Derpy?

 

(spoilered for size)

 

 

 

 

 

 

I don't know about anyone else, but I am definitely in favor of Derpicorn. 

Yes for the love of Celestia yes! Derpicorn awesome! Muffin Princess conjuring muffins and bringing silliness into the hearts of her foes and friends.

[Mephala 2,634]

The lack of Mayor Mare in this thread makes me unhappy. She would be an amazing princess.

I dislike all of the current ones, so why not make her one? *laughs* She's a mayor, she knows what she's doing. And she clearly understands the importance of currency to the kingdom.

 

[Moniker 93]

If I had to choose none of the main six should be princesses why? because Rarity is a bitch (Sorry if that offended someone) and she is already more or less a princess. Applejack, because she is the pony that gets the food for all the ponies, Big Mac is the muscle and pulls the cart not as much the bucking the apple trees sure he does that sometimes, granny smith she is almost useless, she would be totally useless if it wasn't for the whole Zap apple jam thing. Pinkie Pie she is too much of a loose cannon the guards need to keep a close eye during any party. Fluttershy takes care of the animals imagine what would happen if Fluttershy left, pulse we all saw how the Canterlot garden animals reacted to her. Rainbow Dash would never fulfill her life long dream for she would be too busy with her royal duties or she might skip out on them. However the background pony that should become a princesses is Octavia call me crazy but think of this, she already lives in Canterlot she is elegant she knows the sound of the parties that happen in Canterlot. But still call me crazy if you like but deep inside you all know I'm right to some extent. No can change my mind come in she already lives in Canterlot and already is in the castle when a party, she might not be your first choice but to me she would make more sense.           

[Ruddboy Olaf 10,628]

Why did you have to dum it down to the mane 6?

 

If it weren't for the limit,I would say Discord or Derpy!

 

But,I pick Fluttershy!

 

 

Yes! "Rise my animal friends and subjects! Now get Your ruler,Fluttershy,some tea,royal fool!"

 

Ahhahaha that would be awesome!

 

 

 

 

[Dopey Hooves 90]

It would be Pinkie Pie. I know what your thinking in your minds "  Why in the hell?" Well, I have some reasons and I would love if you listen o.e. So, everyone thinks of Pinkie Pie as a no branier but, I think of her as a princess. Because, there would be more fun to go around to the un-happy ponies. Since Pinkie Pie is such a cheerful pony she would make all the under the weather ponies feel good about their lives. But, if you piss Pinkie Pie off see will get very mad, she's a spy and she will keep her two eyeballs on you. You break a promise, your screwed. Pinkie Pie for princess!

[Sweet Dreams 1,893]

I wouldn't really want any of them to be princesses, we have enough, but if one needed to be crowned, I'd say Applejack. She's very level-headed, and quite a hard and honest worker. I think she would take the responsibility quite well, despite needing to spend less time with her family.

[Sugar Pea 2,682]

Next thing you know, they whole mare body of Equestria will be alicorns! THE END IS NEIGH!

LOL i'm just kidding...honestly, none of them. But I do think it's unfair that the other 5 weren't alicorns.

[Nohbdy 4,108]

Yeah, let's do that. Let's make everypony an alicorn!

 

Why is there no option for none of them? Seriously, making another pony a princess is a terrible idea. Twilight's coronation, poorly executed as it was, at least made some sense in that she was Celestia's protege. For the rest, it would be completely out of the blue. It would make no sense at all.

 

And you can be sure the fandom won't take kindly to it.

[Hypn0ticD 1,213]

How about no more princesses? Four is enough for the series! I'm still on the fence about Twilight becoming a princess, but I'm slowly coming around to the change... I think any other character just suddenly turning into a princess would be a bit much for me!

[Alexander Walton Kay 1]

I would love to see Rainbow Dash as a Princess. I could see her being an awesome action hero type, (a bit like Xena: Warrior Princess), impulsive but with her heart in the right place.