S02:E04 - Luna Eclipsed

[Finesthour 7,287]

I know, but she's also in it in the release. That screen cap is of her in Ep4, is it not?

It is not a real screen shot. ._.

[Linguz 140]

It is not a real screen shot. ._.

 

So be it. She was not in the episode.

You sir (Marvelous), have lied to me.

[Finesthour 7,287]

So be it. She was not in the episode. You sir (Marvelous), have lied to me.

Exactly.

Welp, since halloween is over, I really want to watch this ep again.

[Linguz 140]

Exactly.

Welp, since halloween is over, I really want to watch this ep again.

 

Join a livestream tonight then.

[Finesthour 7,287]

Join a livestream tonight then.

Or just go to youtube and watch it?

[Captain Marvelous 544]

You sir (Marvelous), have lied to me.

 

I'm a pirate. It's kind of in my job description.

[Jokuc 8,173]

"The fun has been doubled!" Is my favourite quote from this episode.

[Ezio Auditore 702]

I kinda wanna talk in the Royal Voice for a day....

[NavelColt 22,879]

"How many points do I recieve!?"

 

Oh Celestia, so friendly after having banished your sister to the moon for a thousand years, but can't take a little time here and there to help your sister adapt to this new age </3

[Epic-Brony 6]

look who I found

 

 

waldo is a rarity

 

i didn't notice that!

[Homura Akemi 974]

I may not be a fan of Luna, but she needs more screen time just because then I'd feel like her type was more legit.

(No offense, fans.)

[XUNUSEDXXX 3,459]

"Fun? What is this, 'fun,' thou speakest of?"

"Tis a lie! Thou backside is whole and ungobbled thou ungrateful WHELP!"

Best quotes ever.

[Samrules350 179]

here are my two opinions

 

1. Luna is best pony!

2. SE2 EP4 is best episode!

[Lost Profile 644]

Now this episode is my favorit one!!!

 

Luna makes her aperence, FINALY... And, I really though she would be a lot more... Shy... Not flutershy shy, just shy, After an atempt to seal the world in night... But it was surprising that she was umm... Like the way she was... But it was understanding, Not knowing what fun is and speaking at the top of her lungs, with a midevil stile...

 

So this episode is my favorit, rainbow is it a shadow bolts costume, halloween, and luma.

[3005 332]

Before you read this review, please keep in mind I am not a Brony. No, far from it. I've tried multiple times to get into the show and I just couldn't. I watched this episode once, thought it was meh. I tried it again, and I have to say, I may continue with this series because of it. First off, I love Halloween, and Nightmare Night is close enough for me. I absolutely loved Luna, and the chemistry (not sexually... or maybe? ) between Twilight Sparkle and her. I kinda wish they'd focused more on Nightmare Night and partying rather than varying off that track and putting Luna as the focal point and trying to prove to everyone she's not bad. Other than that, though, I really enjoyed this episode.

[Soarin_Fangirl 14]

I probably have the most unpopular view of this episode but, personally, I find it one of the worst of the series. Now don't get me wrong, I love Luna and was looking forward to seeing how she'd adjust after being saved from her more evil Nightmare Moon persona, but I was sorely disappointed. We learn a lesson which is so ridiculous that it was almost offensive to her character. Nothing says lame like "oh it's GOOD they're scared of you because they find it fun...so just learn to love being scared of". It even sounds ridiculous to say lol. I think this episode would have been greatly improved if they took that sensitive subject and turned it into an episode about people understanding her, how she feels, and NOT being scared of her. The opposite made me truly dislike this episode.

[Radiance64 7,053]

You know, I kinda like Luna, and this ep was hers. Sure, we could talk about the subtle yet awesome costumes the ponies were wearing or something, but Luna owned this. I would definitely like her more if she got more screentime though.

[Soarin_Fangirl 14]

I definitely agree that Luna is a great character who deserves some more screen time. She has a lot of depth and, hopefully, we'll get to see her more in season 3. I just hope they write better episodes for her with a more touching or solid purpose.

[Homura Akemi 974]

I'm watching this episode right now. It's already been a year since the release, but now I think I'm starting to like Luna more now.

[BaBaBrony 111]

Had to watch this one tonight.

 

For the night is dark and full of terror.

[Lifehax 81]

When I watched this episode it changed my mind about Luna. I always thought she was completely evil and stuff but this episode showed me that she does not really have any more intention to do harm to anypony or cause any catastrophies.

 

:3

[HoneyBooBooChildPony 0]

My BF threw away my Halloween candy

[moongarnet77 47]

This was such an epic episode!!!!! :wub:

 

I did feel bad for Luna when she was upset about the little ponies running from her in fear..... But at least she learned a valuable lesson at the end.

[Pripyat Pony 2,608]

I did like this episode, save for one thing... Pinkie Pie. I understand that this is probably not a very popular opinion, but still, I must express it. I don't think that this was Pinkie's finest hour at all; what she was doing reminded me a lot of bullies who said "Oh, I was only joking!" after being nasty and thinking that made it alright. Luna was obviously genuinely upset after Pinkie made all the kids run away screaming from her; she really ought to have realised that and quit it. I also think that Twilight should have asked Pinkie to apologise to Luna.

 

Still, there were good parts, like Zecora's bit, and Derpy's costume. XD And also the bit at the end when Luna is accepted. And of course, Luna's batwinged royal guards! I wish we could see the batwinged pegasi again.

[angels_gal 204]

Luna is one of my favorite ponies!  and giving her an episode to herself was just sooo awesome to see. Derpy's costume made me chuckle, but when she popped up out of the bottom of the bobbing for apples barrell and with a huge grin pulled the plug up and then frowned as the water went away made me spit out the water i was drinking at the time. What was the lesson *I* took away from this episode?  don't take a sip of water when Derpy's around. lol!

Edited November 30, 2012 by angels_gal