Creepy Ponies; G1 Vs. G4

[Troblems 5,609]

 

This is a G1 pony, and I sure as shit wouldn't want it in my bedroom when I tried to sleep. It looks like it wants to suckle my intestinal goodness.

Edited May 16, 2014 by Troblems

[Darker 1,351]

G3.5 is only creepy because they're BABIES. What the hell...

G4 are not exactly creepy, but the EYES, what's up with the EYES. Why are the eyes so big?! 

In G1, they're not creepy, they're really cute.

[Cstriker 737]

None of them were creepy. Just more anatomically correct.

[Pastel 7,627]

None of them, G3.5 ponies are a bit weird, but not creepy.

G4 ponies are by far the cutest of course.

[GenderIsAnIllusion 2,177]

I find gen 3 and 3.5 creepy as heeeeellllll

[Envy 5,999]

G4 ponies *do* look more like deer than horses, but I still find them to be very cute myself.

 

However, I don't find the G1 ponies to be creepy. I think they're cute in a different way. The generation that I actually have the hardest time finding cute is G2 because they kind of look like lizards... I'm not meaning to be down on G2, they just aren't for me, I guess. (Which is good because they're the rarest generation to find, I believe)

 

 

Galaxy.jpg

 

This is a G1 pony, and I sure as shit wouldn't want it in my bedroom when I tried to sleep. It looks like it wants to suckle my intestinal goodness.

 

Aw...

 

Either way, this is also G1:

 

 

And she is undeniably adorable!

Edited August 22, 2014 by Envy

[The JLmle 5,474]

So it's been a long time since I started this topic; but now that it's been resurrected, I feel that I need to make an update to my own thoughts... I've watched (and enjoyed) all of G1 and a fair amount of G3 and G3.5 since this was originally posted... 

G1 I actually find to be mostly cute these days, with the notable exception of the "gem eyes" though I've gotten used to them, there was just something about a pony with red gems for eyes that creeped me out as a little girl...

G4 I've always found to be adorable... Big eyes or not

G3.5 doesn't bother me, but I can see how the oversized heads may creep some other out... Note that I haven't seen any full animations with the "newborn cuties;" but I can see how they creep some people out... Personally they make me smile. Seriously.  I don't think they look like chickens but rather the baby from an old sitcom called Dinosaurs! I can't help but think "not the mama!" or "again!" and that makes me laugh rather than creeps me out... 

[Envy 5,999]

 

Oh please, the G1 cartoon was adorable and just as 'expressive'... Just watch the ending! 

 

[Paleopony 690]

The Newborn Cuties designs creep me out. The other ones look cute more or less.