S05:E18 - Crusaders of the Lost Mark

[Thaliel 116]

Holy Celestia, that was an intense episode. I find it charming thet the 3 stripes are in the cmc members' mane colours

[CastletonSnob 3,074]

What would happen if Spoiled Rich met Upper Crust?

[geartree 33]

I feel that the episode was good. I think the pacing kind of changed near the end, but other than that I have no complaints. I just feel so many people give too much credit to the writer fpr this episode (I forgot who it was). I feel it was an easy episode to write due to how much the episode covered. But as I said, the pacing was good in my opinion.

Edited October 21, 2015 by geartree

[Grepper 3,192]

I liked this episode. The pacing felt rushed (like Magical Mystery Cure,) so it may have worked better as a two-parter.

Oh well.

 

I uploaded this segment of the episode because no one else had at the time.

[Speed 33]

I've put off watching this episode till now as I wanted to wait for a few episodes to be released so that I can watch several episodes in a row.

 

Having not seen any spoilers and going in blind to watch the episode, I have to say that I enjoyed it tremendously. To my surprise, the episode was replete with catchy, memorable songs and there was never a dull moment throughout the entire episode. The reason behind Diamond Tiara's arrogance and incessant name-calling was finally addressed the episode as well, which showed a emotional side to her that we've never previously seen.

 

Moreover, I nearly spit out my water when I saw that the CMCs had acquired their Cutie Marks. I mean, we've all sort of prognosticated that they would get it eventually, but I never figured that this episode would be the one. The brief flashback showing their previous efforts and adventures was heartwarming to say the least and the CMCs have came a long way since then.

 

Props to the fantastic Amy Keating Rogers for having outdone herself yet again! That being said, I am intrigued to see what the writers have in store for future CMC episodes, considering that the CMC episodes before this one have usually been centered around getting their cutie marks one way or another.

[cat-girl 13]

This episode was amazing!

[Emerald7 24]

#Feels in that Diamond Tiara song (totally NO tears). I think I might have broken my vocal cords when they got their marks!!!!!!!!!

[Will Guide 21,360]

About a year ago, I posted this on "How will the CMC get their cutie marks?"

I think I have a theory as to why their cutie mark is not appearing: It's because they're actively trying to see if it will appear.

 

Think back to Cutie Mark Chronicles and how the Mane 6 got theirs:

What do they all have in common besides Rainbow Dash's Sonic Rainboom? They were all NOT focusing on getting their cutie mark, and it appeared when they found their purpose in life.

 

Twilight: Becoming Celestia's student.

Applejack: Realizing Sweet Apple Acres was her home.

Fluttershy: Discovering she can communicate with animals and wanted to care for them

Pinkie Pie: Sharing her happiness with others in the form of a party

Rarity: Finding beautiful gemstones to help make other ponies look their best through fashion.

Rainbow Dash: Discovering she loves flying fast and winning!

 

In all the above, save Twilight, none of them had the appearance of their cutie mark pointed out to them. I believe if the CMC actually stop asking, "Did our cutie mark appear?" and checking their flanks, the probability will go from "Never" to "Will Someday" Whether or not this will happen onscreen in the show or not, that remains to be seen.

After seeing this episode, I guess I was right. Once the CMC decided to stop seeking their own Cutie Marks and help other ponies discover their Cutie Marks, it finally happened!

[PacificGreen 1,163]

I rewatched brief clips of the ending, and all I'm thinking is "Dude, the heartwarmingness of the episode is gonna pretty much make all of my CMC fanfics look like trash. :P"

[Buttonmash1973 1,026]

The comment are removed. 

Edited November 9, 2015 by Ulrik Raben

[Luffyiscool 397]

I think that giving Button a big role would be risky.

 

Just like how they kept Vinyl silent because they can't have Nowacking,

I'm sure they wouldn't give Button a voice that wasn't ShadyVox.

[danime91 16]

I must have watched this episode five times now, not including reaction videos. It was great. Sure the pacing felt a bit fast, but that's a minor issue when considering all the great stuff this episode threw at us. The songs were just great as well, especially Light of Your Cutie Mark, which I still have stuck in my head. Awesome facial expressions from Diamond Tiara, you could tell the animators had fun with that, especially her Egoraptor impression.

 

Anyone have ideas for what to name all those background ponies that popped up in this episode? I'm specifically referring to Big Teeth and Super Filly. Especially Super Filly, her design is adorable. I really hope she pops up again in later episodes.

[StarLight Danse 29]

It's been awhile since the episode air and I'm still can't believe that the CMC got their cutie marks

[4april 374]

I have watched this episode many times now since my last post.

 

This episode really does make me cry on the inside (and a little bit on the outside). The songs were perfect.Given that we had to wait for so long for this episode, it was very satisfying.

 

I used to think that when the CMCs get their cutie marks, the show will end. But now I realise that this is hardly the case. The CMCs have achieved so much so far and have got their cutie marks but the have also shown us that they can achieve a lot more.

 

'For it's more than just a mark

Its a place for us to start

An adventure that has only just begun' - Best Episode Ever

[Guest]

The CMC have their own Magical Mystery Cure!!!!

 

[Invincible 2,091]

So we got some DT (maybe even a little SS) character development, which was nice. It also set the stage for the CMC's character development, which was great. I liked that episode; feels both refreshing and nostalgic at the same time. You kind of see how far they've all come.

[Speed 33]

After re-watching the episode, I do agree with other people that have stated that the pacing of the episode could have been better. The segment of the episode where Diamond Tiara confronts her mother at the Ponyville schoolhouse and had a sudden change of heart saying that the CMC are her friends felt abrupt since she had wanted to be reinstated as the class president only a few moments ago.

 

Also, the fact that Diamond Tiara's mother happened to be at the schoolhouse felt contrived. However, it was probably difficult for the writers as they had to priortise some scenes over others and attempt to fit everything in one single episode. Nevertheless, with the catchy songs, great dialogue and all the feels, it still remains my favorite episode of the season thus far. 

Edited October 30, 2015 by Trigonia

[DJW 142]

Would it be remis to point out that the CMCs are essentially doomed to an increasingly awkward lifetime of looking at children's arses?

[The Derpy Hooves 615]

this episode just make my entire life explode!

 

i was thinking that these three fillies.... whatever....

 

though it was fun! and really beautiful!!!

Edited October 31, 2015 by The Derpy Hooves

[Reading Heart 167]

So, having recently joined, I feel a desire to chime in on this one, I've watched and re-watched this episode dozens of times, trying not keep in the liquid pride... it's been a failed effort.  I understand the issues folks have with pacing, but over all I view it as necessary to make this the jewel that it is within the many episodes of mlp.  While I admit that putting this much into a single 22 minute episode can be rough, I hope that they explore the growing friendship between Diamond, Silver and the Crusaders in future episodes..  I believe there is rich ground to explore there.  Lots more I could say, but I think most of it has already been said.

[Melontropica 0]

First of all, the pacing was held very well throughout the episode-until the last five minutes, where what was supposed to be a very important event in the show turned out incredibly rushed. 

However, the character development was excellent, and what stood out to me most was Diamond Tiara's solo in the middle of the episode. I usually do not enjoy songs in episodes, excluding the EQG series. But this song was absolutely great! It is obvious that the writers put lots of work in creating a perfect solo for Diamond Tiara. 

[Chaton 3,765]

This episode caused so much happiness, I think I may have got a cutie mark myself.

[NeonFlash1 19]

The marks they got was unexpected

[Chaton 3,765]

The marks they got was unexpected

Really? I guessed all along that they'd have similar marks.

[Reading Heart 167]

Most people were a bit surprised by the similarities of the marks.. but I like them, and there is a lot going on within them.. I'll break it down a bit.

 

First off, Shield: While the first aspect of a shield is that of a protection, gaining one's shield is also sort of a mark of moving from squire to knight... so our crusaders are knights and protectors.. fitting.  

Secondly: A shield is also the heart of a coat of arms, and each color has symbolic meaning

• Orange: Worthy Ambition 
• Silver or White: Peace & Sincerity
• Red: Warrior or martyr; Military strength and magnanimity 
• Purple: Royal majesty, sovereignty, and justice

Now the individuality of each mark

 

Apple Bloom

• Apple: Represents generosity, happiness, peace and salvation
• Heart: Represents sincerity (aka, honesty), also a symbol of goodness and charity

 

Scootaloo

• Wing: Represents swiftness and protection (generally 2 wings, but as Scootaloo already has two wings, I think it fits just fine)
• Lightning: Putting clarity and force into matters of importance

Sweetie Bell

• Star: Represents celestial goodness, a good person [Edited in: Also, it seems to mean magic in Equestria]
• Note: This one is harder, there is no specific heraldic symbol that uses a note, but there are several objects that make use of music, so I take this to imply music in general, but considering her name includes a Bell...I will go with that first, a bell, which indicates power to disperse evil.. but some other musical instruments indicate festivity and rejoicing.

Now, this is likely reading a lot more into then perhaps I should, but it fits so very well all of them.. together and individually.

 

Edited in: Also, clearly signs that the girls are spending entirely too much time with their sisters and their friends, the virtues of the main six are seen all over the place here

Edited November 6, 2015 by Reading Heart