Which character would you want to see become evil?

[Evilshy 5,090]

Fluttershy, obviously.

 

 

But really, any of the ridiculously powerful good guys (which I guess is just the Alicorns). It's like if Superman just said "fuck it, I'm taking over and none of you can stop me" (which he actually has done in a few comics). Imagine if Shining Armor and Cadence went evil while keeping their love for each other? Together they totally wrecked Chrysalis and her entire fucking army, even the remaining Alicorns would probably have a tough time against them. Or if Nightmare Moon came back and started to corrupt Celestia?

 

Seeing mane 6 (other than Twilight) go evil would be fun, but in the grand scheme of things, it wouldn't be a huge deal. Twilight is on a completely different level and could just turn them back, or immobilize them until she finds something that can.

[cmarston1 5,959]

I would really like to see an evil Celestia happen.  I just find it interesting to see what would happen if she got corrupted and turned into Solar Flare.

 

Other than that I would be willing to see Derpy become evil, only if the episode(s?) is/are about Applejack, Princess Celestia, Zecora, Cherilee and Flash Sentry teaming up to defeat her.

[Johnny1226 14,674]

I would like to see evil celestia that would be interesting

[Swifty 249]

However, taking into account the show's portrayal of Celestia, getting thrashed immediately after turning evil wouldn't surprise me. I'm still hoping for the former, though.

Yeah, i predict Evil Celestia to be utterly destroyed by Flurry Heart. To make a big exception to show the villain as a threat and Celestia be defeated by a baby, i expect nothing else from the writers. *lol*

Edited February 15, 2016 by Swifty

[Buck Testa 5,505]

 

 

Fluttershy, obviously.

 

 

The scary thing is, If Flutters ever went bad, you KNOW Discord would follow her. She has him wrapped around her little hoof

 

 

Plus, Fluttershy controls monsters and animals, and Discord can turn them into a formidable monster army. 

[MAIKUN 262]

Yes Diamond Tiara back to her rude, but evil ways again!

[Breakfast 21]

I'd say Fluttershy but the least likely candidate is the most obvious candidate.  That would be boring, wouldn't it?

 

Pulling this out of thin air here but - a teleportation spell 20 years into the future and the mane six find all of Equestria's towns and structures gone saved for the select remains in the Crystal Empire.  Discord turned back into stone with a permanent look of pain and sorrow on his face.  Celestia, Luna, and Cadence buried six feet under.  The likes of Tirek and the Changelings shackled at the hooves, having so long since been forced to swear fealty to overlords that they've lost all willpower.  The overlords?  On dual thrones in the Empire Throne room are Pound Cake and Pumpkin Cake.  Turns out their special talents were bringing forth the armageddon.

Edited February 15, 2016 by Breakfast

[Stormlight 1,371]

It might just be me, but I would want to see Applejack be a villain for the sake of my curiosity.

[----- 477]

Derpy, make Derpy  evil! owo

Edited February 15, 2016 by Fluidty

[Princess of Bananas 56]

Megan, from generation one of MLP.

[PinkieatHeart 208]

I'd like to see a temporary thing where Zecora becomes evil. Whether it'd be against her normal will or not, I don't know. But it'd be a good way to get more insight on her special kinda of magic, which would also be interesting cuz we'd get to see the characters try to handle it.

[DageNox 109]

Celestia:

 

She's been out of the spot light too long. I want to see her go off the deep end. Watching her sanity snap would be thrilling.

 

Pinkie Pie:

 

She'll be the one to smile last. I can imagine her basically being Jigsaw from SAW or something. Lots of potential for going down the path of a villain.

 

[BrawnyCharger 513]

I'd like to see all the Mane 6 members turn evil for just a simple 2, 3, or 4 part episode.

 

They'd be under an evil spell cast by a main villain such as either King Sombra, Queen Chrysalis, Tirek or anypony else. But the mane 6 would still remain just as true to their elements of harmony as before, but they would be given nasty twists to the way they represent their elements: 

 

Pinkie Pie: Laughter is one that can easily be corrupted, with Pinkie playing mean spirited, nasty, and harmful jokes and pranks in a manner similar to that of the Joker.

 

Applejack: Just as honest as ever, but in a more BRUTAL fashion. IE: Pointing out everypony's flaws in a way that would put them down or insult them.

 

Twilight Sparkle: Corrupted magic is also easy. Just imagine Twilight towards the end of the Friendship Games after "unleashing the magic".

 

Rainbow Dash: Loyalty can also be used for evil. Rainbow Dash would still fight alongside the Evil Mane 6 AGAINST her better judgement. 

 

Rarity: Corrupted Generosity is actually quite difficult to portray. True, Rarity would give away practically EVERYTHING she owns, but how would that be used for evil?

 

Fluttershy: How exactly does one use Kindness for evil? Maybe Fluttershy could allow her animal friends to run on a rampage and terrorize everypony in Ponyville while still kissing up to them and not scolding them for any of their nasty behaviors.

 

Then it would be up to your choices of 6 other ponies to carry the elements, break the spell, rescue the Mane 6, defeat the baddie, and save Equestria.

[just a luna fan 50]

The dark magic Luna had as nightmare moon was never destroyed and it corrupts celestia

[Evilshy 5,090]

 

 

The scary thing is, If Flutters ever went bad, you KNOW Discord would follow her. She has him wrapped around her little hoof

 

(photo)

 

Plus, Fluttershy controls monsters and animals, and Discord can turn them into a formidable monster army. 

 

 

Wouldn't even need to be full on, master plan evil villain. Honestly I just want to see her be an asshole a bit more. Discoreded Fluttershy and overly-assertive Fluttershy were some of my favorite moments in the series.

[Buck Testa 5,505]

Wouldn't even need to be full on, master plan evil villain. Honestly I just want to see her be an asshole a bit more. Discoreded Fluttershy and overly-assertive Fluttershy were some of my favorite moments in the series.

 

Seriously though, I have this hilarious head canon that Flutershy wants to take over Equestria but she's to shy to actually carry it out. She's learned to control powerful monsters, She stared down a Cockatrice that turns ponies to stone with a glance...and WON, Cerberus is familiar with her (perhaps she was the reason Cerberus wasn't where he was supposed to be when Tirek escaped?), She's hiding the fact that she still has fangs, and she has the Spirit of Chaos in check. Her pets she keeps around the house immobilized her friends on nightmare night, and her prized Pet is this

 

 

That is like Evilshy fanfic feul for days 

Edited February 16, 2016 by Buck Testa

[masterchaoss 27]

Oh for me I would love to see princess Cadance and how devastating the power of love could be when used for evil, I would love to see what the show would with it.

[Unlikeable Pony 2,698]

Oh for me I would love to see princess Cadance and how devastating the power of love could be when used for evil, I would love to see what the show would with it.

Eh, the problem is that a corrupted princess of love would probably end up being too much like a chrysalis rip off, using love as a means of control rather than selflessness.

Either that or a giant slut, but I doubt that would happen XD

[cider float 2,538]

I'd like to see all the Mane 6 members turn evil for just a simple 2, 3, or 4 part episode.

 

They'd be under an evil spell cast by a main villain such as either King Sombra, Queen Chrysalis, Tirek or anypony else. But the mane 6 would still remain just as true to their elements of harmony as before, but they would be given nasty twists to the way they represent their elements: 

 

Pinkie Pie: Laughter is one that can easily be corrupted, with Pinkie playing mean spirited, nasty, and harmful jokes and pranks in a manner similar to that of the Joker.

 

Applejack: Just as honest as ever, but in a more BRUTAL fashion. IE: Pointing out everypony's flaws in a way that would put them down or insult them.

 

Twilight Sparkle: Corrupted magic is also easy. Just imagine Twilight towards the end of the Friendship Games after "unleashing the magic".

 

Rainbow Dash: Loyalty can also be used for evil. Rainbow Dash would still fight alongside the Evil Mane 6 AGAINST her better judgement. 

 

Rarity: Corrupted Generosity is actually quite difficult to portray. True, Rarity would give away practically EVERYTHING she owns, but how would that be used for evil?

 

Fluttershy: How exactly does one use Kindness for evil? Maybe Fluttershy could allow her animal friends to run on a rampage and terrorize everypony in Ponyville while still kissing up to them and not scolding them for any of their nasty behaviors.

 

Then it would be up to your choices of 6 other ponies to carry the elements, break the spell, rescue the Mane 6, defeat the baddie, and save Equestria.

I can imagine Fluttershy becoming evil somewhat. Since she's not the element of loyalty she may impede the path of her friends when she meets with a sympathetic villain.