How would ponies feel being introduced to Bronies?

[ManaMinori 4,145]

If any of the ponies from FiM landed on earth, had to stay in your house, and learned that this two-legged, fleshy creature is part of a near cult following of people who watches them and their friends adventures and SoL on TV, collects merchandise of them, or somepony they might know, and possibly even cosplays as them or some other pony- how do you think a pony would react upon discovering Brony culture, collectors, cosplayers, etc?

[BastementSparkle 20,326]

Pinkie: Would probably think that's super crazy and fun.

 

Rainbow Dash: The people of an entirely different universe and species appreciate her awesomeness? Sweet!

 

Rarity: Would probably be flattered, but also probably a bit weirded out.

 

Fluttershy: More than likely shy and uncomfortable.

 

Applejack: Not totally sure here, I imagine she might think it strange too.

 

Twilight: She'd be fascinated by how this is possible, how we can view their world like this, she might be a bit flattered so many people look up to her, she might also be a little uncomfortable too. A very mixed reaction from her.

 

Starlight: She's used to cults, nothing new here!

[ManaMinori 4,145]

Pinkie: Would probably think that's super crazy and fun.

 

Rainbow Dash: The people of an entirely different universe and species appreciate her awesomeness? Sweet!

 

Rarity: Would probably be flattered, but also probably a bit weirded out.

 

Fluttershy: More than likely shy and uncomfortable.

 

Applejack: Not totally sure here, I imagine she might think it strange too.

 

Twilight: She'd be fascinated by how this is possible, how we can view their world like this, she might be a bit flattered so many people look up to her, she might also be a little uncomfortable too. A very mixed reaction from her.

 

Starlight: She's used to cults, nothing new here!

spot on, but still, I can't imagine anyone being chill about every aspect of their lives being watched, debated over, people collecting merchandise of them, dressing like them...Cept the cult pony, SG

[cmarston1 5,959]

It would be really awkward.

[Flutter's lover <3 8,205]

I can only imagine what Fluttershy would think, upon seeing my shrine of her....She'd probably think I was a bit crazy but at the same time know that I adored her. Being on an alien planet, she'd probably feel nervous and shy as well...At the same time I'd also be a bit shy and nervous, actually meeting the pony I loved. So we'd probably sit and be awkward with each other for a little while...She'd probably be intrigued at meeting a new "animal" species as well and wanting to learn about them, Twilight would probably want to learn about us as well.

 

FS: "W-where am I...?"

Me: "...A-are you...Fluttershy..?"

FS:"Y-yes...h--how'd you....~"

~She sees all my vinyls, posters and plushies of her~

FS: "~...oh my, wh-what's all this..? I-is that....me?"

Me: "Umm...yea...I'm kinda in love with you..."

FS:"Oh...wow....*she attempts to change subject* um...wait, what are you..?We don't have your species in Equestria..."

Me:"I'm um..a human.."

FS:"Oh wow, a new species!"

Me:"Yea...probably don't know anything about me...but.. I know quite a bit about you.."

~Fluttershy proceeds to bombard me with questions about humans, ala Spike in Season 1 asking about dragons, curious and intrigued, while I awkwardly give answers~

 

At the same time I'd be shy and a bit nervous, actually meeting the pony I loved.So we'd probably sit and be awkward with each other..

[Luminance 2,186]

They would feel really good of themselves because they not only help children but also helped adults too in their portrayal of friendship.

Edited November 29, 2016 by Melodic Twilight

[Ganondorf8 11,306]

They would have mixed emotions about bronies. Some bronies they'd easily be able to get along with and even appreciate them for doing so much good, but then other broines are involved in the more questionable aspects of the fandom. Ponies will probably avoid them for their own peace of mind.

[Tropical Melody 6,165]

I like the last two posts - I was going to say, maybe totally freaked out that A. an alien race is so interested in them and B. that we watch their every move on our televisions without them being aware. Happy goldfish bowl ...

[DANUTERCISD 204]

Fluttershy would love me because of all the dogs i have.

Pinkie pie and my bro could probably get along well(they are both really hyper)

Rainbow dash might think I'm a nerd.

Twilight would ask me questions

Idk about rarity, probably would be disgusted cause of how i dont always clean my room.

Applejack would get along with my dad REALLY well. As for the fandom as a whole, they probably wouldn't react so positively.

[Midnight Seashell 206]

I think some would appreciate it while being freaked out, others would most likely hate it and want privacy and the remainder wouldn't care at all.

[GrimGrimoire 4,973]

I think all of them would be a mix of fascination to bewilderment.

 

That is until you came out dressed up in a costume of them... then it would nosedive into that realm of discomfort only understood by people trapped in an elevator after someone has strongly and extensively passed gas.

[OLD ACCOUNT 185]

Hmm well be afraid at first then slowly will get to know them and trust them.

[gamecubeguy214 2,512]

Twilight: You don't read or study? God damn you bitch

Pinkie Pie: Your sense of humor is immature bullshit

Applejack: Whoa sugarcube why don't you eat apples

Rainbow Dash: I've never seen someone who appreciates my awesomeness THIS much.

Rarity: Your hair is nasty, you wear garbage clothes, and your room is nasty! How could you?

Fluttershy: Why don't you main Pikachu? He's so cute! PAC-MAN is low tier trash.

[SaburoDaimando 1,196]

That's a question I don't think I need to answer, given that the voice cast enjoys poking fun at us.

 

Of course, my first meeting with Tara Strong was just me being a troll(She asked who this "Twilightlicious fan is."  My response was "Changelinglicious."  And she went "OH NO NOT CHANGELINGLICIOUS!"  XP)

[Kagami-sama 320]

Pinkie Pie: *cringe* but intrigued

Twilight: Will join us

Fluttershy: *cringe* but not judgmental

Rainbow Dash: *cringe* *and cringe some more*

Applejack: *cringe* but doesn't care one way or another

Rarity: M'Lady *tip*

[Rainblow H. Ash 5,091]

They would use Rainbow Power to free us from the Brony curse.

[Savy 5,077]

I feel like it would be kinda awkward at first hahaha.

[DivineMist1000 71,359]

Celestia and Luna will be the most loved and cherished creatures if I ever see them!!