Who is The Luckiest/Unluckiest Mane 6 Pony?

[Shanks 10,816]

All the mane 6 ponies get lucky or unlucky at certain moments but some a bit more than others so who is the luckies mane 6 pony? And who is the unluckiest mane 6 pony?

 

Luckiest: I think the luckiest mane 6 pony is Twilight Sparkle because though she dosen't have as much family revealed as Applejack she does still have her parents and a close relationship with her brother. And though Twilight studied very hard she never had to go out and get a job to make ends meet. During her exam to make it into the Canterlot School of Gifted Unicorns right when it seemed like she wouldn't pass thanks to a sonic rainboom she had a massive magic surge which caused her not only to pass but for Celestia to decide to make her her apprentice.

 

Unluckiest: The unluckiest mane 6 pony is Applejack because she lost her parents at a young age and had to take on a great deal of responsibility at a very young age by helping her brother run the family business and being both a sister as well as a mother to her sister Applebloom.

Edited April 20, 2013 by EarthbendingProdigy

[Skye Starlight 223]

Depends on what luck you mean.

 

Dumb Luck wise, Twilight has the worst luck... She's had stuff fall on her head, fallen down stairs... not to mention being adorkably clumsy.

 

Otherwise, I agree. Twilight's family is really close. Her parents are alive and proud of her, her brother and sister in law adore her, her teacher's the ruler of equestria and she now has 5 amazing friends... She's had a near perfect life, with the exception of a few friendship problems, some *cough* minor injuries, and a lack of friends for a few years.

 

But Applejack's had a decent life too... She has a large family, she's comfortable in her place, working the farm... Even though she's doing it without her parents, she's got her siblings who love her, and Granny Smith to help out with raising Applebloom. It's why she seems like a BG pony. She's acheived all she wants to acheive, she's living the life she wants, and is happy where she is. Her few quirks (aka, her stubborn nature and pride) have already been explored. There's not much you can build on her...

[Betez 1,734]

I feel like Twilight is probably the luckiest, for obvious reasons. And I'd have to say Fluttershy is the unluckiest, because I feel like she's given a hard time by almost everyone, even animals.

[Drakkon 362]

Rarity; she leads a successful business, a very interactive and intriguing life, has her own shop, is an Element of Harmony, and much more. Twilight Sparkle has far more duties to attend to, especially now that she's a princess - I'd say the president of a country is less lucky than a happy citizen, since he developed into somebody who has an attraction for politics, which is always stressful.

 

The unluckiest pony is most probably Pinkie Pie. As shown in Swarm of the Century and Feeling Pinkie Keen, no one ever takes her seriously, and she was born to a less-than-fun family. While she does smile like no one else, she sadly leads a fairly meager life.

[Blue Moon 6,341]

Lucky: Pinkie Pie. She has a lot of ponies who care about herand she is known to survive near-death situations.

 

Unluckiest: Twilight She is really clumsy and has freaking pianos dropped on her head and is viciously beat up in Lesson Zero

[Dreadmallon 353]

   Keep in mind that my opinion right now is based off things off the top of my head, and could change rather quickly and easily.

 

   Luckiest: I don't care if she's my second/tied-first favorite pony. She has such a wide fanbase for simply being cute, when she has close to no long-term character development, and is backtracked a lot to maintain her timid nature and inability to trust anypony she doesn't know.

 

   Unluckiest: Applejack. There's not much to the character to allow her to have that many different episodes, which I find rather sad.

[Scootalove 10,689]

Lucky: Applejack because she has her dream job of running the farm with her family, and that she is a very loyal pony. A huge family matter of fact, and she has achieved a lot plus that she has a family that is behind her all the way.

 

Unlucky: Rarity, she owns a fashion boutique, very generous, and has a lot of friends but her enemy is Greed. But the thing is, when a famous fashion critic comes to rate her fashion and if it isn't up to par then she starts to doubt herself. I think that she is very unlucky but, besides Twilight being clumsy in Feeling Pinkie Keen. Rarity has bad luck as well.

[pinkiefan1287 610]

Luckiest: Pinkie Pie because with her pinkie senses she seems to be able to dodge all the bad things that comes her way. Like falling things, bees, and other stuff. Also Pinkie just seems so positive and nothing gets her down. 

 

Unluckiest: Rainbow Dash because it seems like she is getting injured a lot more. Sometimes not so bad to really bad. Also when her team was doing the water thing in Hurricane Fluttershy, most of her team got sick. 

[hawkflame 3,310]

Rarity; she leads a successful business, a very interactive and intriguing life, has her own shop, is an Element of Harmony, and much more. Twilight Sparkle has far more duties to attend to, especially now that she's a princess - I'd say the president of a country is less lucky than a happy citizen, since he developed into somebody who has an attraction for politics, which is always stressful.

 

The unluckiest pony is most probably Pinkie Pie. As shown in Swarm of the Century and Feeling Pinkie Keen, no one ever takes her seriously, and she was born to a less-than-fun family. While she does smile like no one else, she sadly leads a fairly meager life.

 

 

Rarity's success and the life she leads didn't happen because of luck, though.  They happened because she *made* them happen. 

 

I would say Twilight's the luckiest.  Aside from the other reasons mentioned in this thread, she's also Princess Celestia's *personal student*.  That's like having Barack Obama as your political science tutor.   And that all came about really through chance anyway, with Dash's Sonic Rainboom.

[Concord 1,982]

Hello!

 

If we were to look from Season 3's perspective...

 

The luckiest would be Twilight Sparkle. Come on, she got her own place in the castle right now. It's pretty obvious she's the luckiest one...

 

 

The unluckiest would be Rarity. Simply, because she never got her own episode in Season 3

[Drakkon 362]

Rarity's success and the life she leads didn't happen because of luck, though.  They happened because she *made* them happen. 

 

I would say Twilight's the luckiest.  Aside from the other reasons mentioned in this thread, she's also Princess Celestia's *personal student*.  That's like having Barack Obama as your political science tutor.   And that all came about really through chance anyway, with Dash's Sonic Rainboom.

While a great deal of that is indeed her own skill and determination, in the end there's also a great deal of luck involved. It seems like Rarity is the only person who seems to have a very ideal life, as she didn't end up disregarded and the butt of jokes like Pinkie Pie, nor has she developed into an unassertive person like Fluttershy (on the contrary) - she doesn't have a ginormous ego like Rainbow Dash, and the only person who could probably rival her in a 5-star life is Twilight, which upon her coronation no longer counts. Sadly, character flaws are developed, not chosen, thus it would be incorrect to say she had the potential to end up like Rainbow Dash or Fluttershy.

Edited April 20, 2013 by Inactive Sparkle

[Dashabel 381]

I'm not actually sure. This seems like an odd question, I couldn't answer who's the luckiest, because I think they've all got something to be proud of. Yet when it comes to being the unluckiest, that'll tie between Applejack and Fluttershy. Fluttershy basically just because she always gets pushed around and...you know.

As for Applejack I agree with the fact that she's the least ambitiously written, is happy with her life and has nothing more to reveal. That's why they need to create something for Applejack! I hope season four brings an awesome story for her... They won't just forget about her, will they?

No one actually knows that her parents died either, it's just assumed, I'm not challenging that I could come up with a better solution, I just think that's to tragic for the show. And yes, I'm happy with that conclusion, I've nothing against it. But we can't speak of it as though we know it for certain.

[Shanks 10,816]

While a great deal of that is indeed her own skill and determination, in the end there's also a great deal of luck involved.

Yes, but I don't think she was nearly as lucky as Twilight though, Twilight was handed more than any other pony at the beginning of her life while Rarity had to work her way up and for the most part make her own luck. We did see her get lucky a few times in the show though like in Sweet and Elite for example when none of her friends got angry with her for deceiving them by trying to attend two parties at once and when Fancy Pants called Twilight's dress "charmingly rustic" when he could have said it was the worst ever all the snobs in the room wanted one all of a sudden.

 

 

she doesn't have a ginormous ego like Rainbow Dash,

Actually she does, she has a huge primadonna, prissy side to her which has caused her vanity to get a bit out of control in many cases. Her ego may be there for different reasons than Rainbow Dash's but it is still there.

 

 

 

They won't just forget about her, will they?

No one actually knows that her parents died either, it's just assumed, I'm not challenging that I could come up with a better solution, I just think that's to tragic for the show. And yes, I'm happy with that conclusion, I've nothing against it. But we can't speak of it as though we know it for certain.

There was something released from the show staff a while back where it did actually confirm that they are dead, but that Hasbro wouldn't let them address that issue directly in the show for some reason I can't seem to find it so if anyone can help me out here it would be much appreciated. This isn't the first time I have seen this happen in a show, in Avatar the Last Airbender it heavily implied though didn't directly state that Jet died and it did the same for Zuko's mother though with her it left it a bit more open to interpretation. I found this a bit odd because in that same show it directly stated that all of the other airbenders were wiped out so talking about genocide is okay apparently but individuals dying is a no no, go figure.

[Blue Moon 6,341]

 

The reason they don't want to announce on the show that Applejack's parents are dead is because apparently, according to kids and parents, death is evil and innapropriate even though it is a natural part of life that everyone goes through sooner or later.

[Starlight Song 43]

I really want to say Spike is the unluckiest, because he woke up in an egg, no parents, and has basically been a servant all his life to another species. He also has been rejected many times by Rarity. 

But, if it has to be mane 6 -

The unluckiest would be Pinkie Pie. Apparently, as a young child she lived in a dull rock farm with no smiling, obviously hating it, because it was not who she was meant to be. The other girls in the mane six are constantly saying "That's just Pinkie Pie", "Just ignore her" and she is never really taken seriously even after Swarm of the Century. I have reason to believe that after that trama at her family, and a little with her friends, she tries to befriend everypony as an outershell

The luckiest pony is Applejack. I know her parents died, but if you really think about it, that's the only unlucky thing that's happened to her. She was born into a farm and knows how to Applebuck even before her cutiemark appeared. She doesn't really undergo any drastic chages or really learn that many lessons in the episodes, proving that Applejack just might be above the other girls. 

[Shanks 10,816]

The reason they don't want to announce on the show that Applejack's parents are dead is because apparently, according to kids and parents, death is evil and innapropriate even though it is a natural part of life that everyone goes through sooner or later.

I know the reason, I am just having trouble finding the staff announcement that confirms that Applejacks parents are dead but I have seen if before. It is a real shame though as if they did go into that subject Applejack's popularity would probably skyrocket which would make this Applejack fanboy very very happy.

[Blue Moon 6,341]

I know the reason, I am just having trouble finding the staff announcement that confirms that Applejacks parents are dead but I have seen if before. It is a real shame though as if they did go into that subject Applejack's popularity would probably skyrocket which would make this Applejack fanboy very very happy.

Yes, but kids would get upset over the fact that a pony actually died. Than parents would complain and they would end up censoring it like Derpy was censored.

[Shanks 10,816]

Yes, but kids would get upset over the fact that a pony actually died. Than parents would complain and they would end up censoring it like Derpy was censored.

Yeah, you are probably right why do so many parents have to be so god damned stupid? Smart people need to have more babies so the IQ of the general population can actually go up for once. At least wehave fanfics though and I don't know when but I will get this fanfic idea about Applejack's parents out there.

[Unpredictable Ranger 696]

Pardon me, but who is it that you referred to as the luckiest pony among the Mane 6, ?

 

Anyway whoops, I sent another post into this topic after Blue_Moon posted in here.

  Keep in mind that my opinion right now is based off things off the top of my head, and could change rather quickly and easily.

   Luckiest: I don't care if she's my second/tied-first favorite pony. She has such a wide fanbase for simply being cute, when she has close to no long-term character development, and is backtracked a lot to maintain her timid nature and inability to trust anypony she doesn't know.

 

   Unluckiest: Applejack. There's not much to the character to allow her to have that many different episodes, which I find rather sad.

Edited April 20, 2013 by Fluffle Puff

[Blue Moon 6,341]

Yeah, you are probably right why do so many parents have to be so god damned stupid? Smart people need to have more babies so the IQ of the general population can actually go up for once. At least wehave fanfics though and I don't know when but I will get this fanfic idea about Applejack's parents out there.

The reason there is so many stupid people is because many people can't accept the fact that death is a natural part of life that everyone goes through. They then think they should censor it from their kids because they think they are too young.

[Unpredictable Ranger 696]

@, pardon me, who is it that you were referring to as the luckiest Mane 6 character? Because you didn't mntion anypony's name in your post for that one.

[Dreadmallon 353]

Pardon me, but who is it that you referred to as the luckiest pony among the Mane 6, ?

 

Anyway whoops, I sent another post into this topic after Blue_Moon posted in here.

 

 

   Whoops, I seemed to have made a mistake. I meant for Fluttershy, however I'm sure you, along with others, could've figured that out through my description.

Edited April 20, 2013 by III New Moon III

[Unpredictable Ranger 696]

@, not really, since that I am still new in watching MLP:FiM; had I been watching it for long then only I will be able to distinguish the Mane 6 better by just their descriptions. Otherwise, that statement seemed vague to me.

 

Thank you for telling me that you meant Fluttershy as the luckiest mare among the rest of the other Mane 6 cast.

 

And since that I don't know much about the Mane 6, I can't say who I think is the luckiest and who is the unluckiest.

[Dreadmallon 353]

@, not really, since that I am still new in watching MLP:FiM; had I been watching it for long then only I will be able to distinguish the Mane 6 better by just their descriptions. Otherwise, that statement seemed vague to me.

 

Thank you for telling me that you meant Fluttershy as the luckiest mare among the rest of the other Mane 6 cast.

 

And since that I don't know much about the Mane 6, I can't say who I think is the luckiest and who is the unluckiest.

 

 

   I wasn't trying to be rude, I added that last part, about assuming who I was referring to, because I ran out of characters. But anyway, no need to be offended.

[Unpredictable Ranger 696]

No worries, I was not offended at all. Just wanted to know who was it that you were talking about.

 

As fr me, I think Rainbow Dash is the unluckiest as she often do things wrongly and face the consequences after she had done them (one example is the episode where she drank Twiley's secret potion that enhances a pony's special ability).

 

I know I might be inaccurate, since that there a re a lot of other episodes that I haven't watched yet.