would you be cool with twilight taking one of the cmc as her apprentice?

[FNGRpony 658]

well she's a princess now.

princess have students (I think?)

Twilight looks like she was literally born to teach.

 

I mean honestly, I'd be cool with all 3 being shoe horned in.

 

maybe that could be their adventure after their cutie marks?  Learning stuff from twilight.  Like Tommy oliver mentioned a writer liked the idea what if all their cutie marks embodied their friend ship together.

 

If the CMC embodied friend ship who better than teach each them than twilight?

Crap, that was way to good for me.

Edited December 20, 2013 by FNGRpony

[skylights 127]

Sweetie Belle is the only unicorn of the bunch and she doesn't seem to care that much about developing her magical ability. The only time a princess has been shown to take a student is when Celestia took on Twilight after she demonstrated her unusual talent with magic. I don't think that should be taken as evidence that all princesses take students.

[Zygen 6,066]

Well, i dunno, i feel like it may be cool in some theory, but only maybe for an episode.

 

And the only one who could really be her apprentice is like Sweetiebelle being the only unicorn. And shes not really interested in magic much, so there wouldn't be much of a point.

 

If its done really really way maybe as an episode or something, but not super big on it working out, even Twilight having another Apprentice would be iffy depending on execution. The CMC just don't really mix well with Twilight enough really.

[pinkiefan1287 610]

No I don't want that to happen. Problem one is all the CMC have someone to look up to and teach them. It would just be to odd for the CMC to want Twilight teaching them anything. Also Twilight is only good with magic. Sweetie Bell is the only unicorn and I don't think she has the same level as Twilight.

 

Still I like the idea of Twilight taking an apprentice. But I think it should be someone out-side of the CMC. Like a unicorn boy wanting to learn magic from her. Something like that.

[FlutterDash4072 189]

I don't think it would work very well. Sweetie Belle is the only CMC without a mentor, but magic doesn't seem like it's supposed to be her thing. I think she's meant to be a singer, having her study under Twilight wouldn't make sense.

[Scootalove 10,689]

I think it could be a theory but, Sweetie Belle isn't really interested in learning about magic just yet. Twilight should mentor a unicorn who could be interested in being her apprentice, or someone who wants to learn magic.

[Malinter 3,064]

If twilight was to ever take an apprentice it needs to be Trixie. She's the only pony we know that actually cares for magic abit more than most unicorns. 

Edited December 21, 2013 by Malinter

[Tigerpop198 696]

No I don't think that would be right. The cmc should stick to what they do, like getting a odd episode now and again.

[ReverseFaller 2,483]

No, I wouldn't like it. The CMC has only one Unicorn, and I don't think Sweetie Belle is terribly concerned about magic. Also, what would the other two do? They're only concerned about getting their cutie marks, and I don't think Twilight could help them do that all that well.

[Lightning Bliss 1,674]

I can't forsee how any of the CMC would be taken under her wing, granted I don't believe you have to be a unicorn to be trained in magics somewhat. But you gotta consider the CMC's and their goals or talents in order. I think by now we can all guess their talents?

 

SPOILERS if you don't know or haven't figured it out yet.

 

Sweetibell loves to sing and is very good at it

Scootaloo has an athletic talent of riding her scooter

Apple Bloom is architecturely creative, decorating and designing.

 

None of them are interested in magic though so i would think not.

[JonPear 209]

If twilight was to ever take an apprentice it needs to be Trixie. She's the only pony we know that actually cares for magic abit more than most unicorns. 

 

Trixie would have to mature a lot and learn a lot of humility before that could ever happen

[Koelath 445]

I'd be cool with all 3 being shoe horned in.

 

"Shoehorned" by its very definition is a negative thing. If you're cool with shoehorning, you're basically cool with the show being ruined.

 

That said, none of the CMC care enough about magic to make worthwhile apprentices to Twilight.

 

Trixie's the only one with real interest in that subject and she's far too egotistical to be any apprentice. Unless Rarity decided to get a bit of training to impress some prince or something...

[FNGRpony 658]

You do realize FNGR stands for no good reason.  ^^.  So if you were looking to shame me down hi you must be knew here.

They shoe horned Zecora in to things all the time.
Oh my goodness has the show been canceled?  You do understand flutter shy in was shoe horned into her extra screen time in magic duel.

 

It didn't really ruin anything.  Their a hand ful of pencil justeling analysis's who are aware of the fact, and in spite of it (hi voice of reason) still happen to like the episode.

And you said, your idea, was the only real interest, than shut it down.

Seems like under your definition your own suggestions are terrible.

 

I mean if you can't even support your ideas why should i value them?  That's a fair question.

 

but yeah they shoe horned the main six into daring don't,

and we got twilight and rainbows nerd fight,

 

if that's a ruined mlp, burn the place down.  Here i'll go get the gas.

 

 

"Shoehorned" by its very definition is a negative thing. If you're cool with shoehorning, you're basically cool with the show being ruined.

 

That said, none of the CMC care enough about magic to make worthwhile apprentices to Twilight.

 

Trixie's the only one with real interest in that subject and she's far too egotistical to be any apprentice. Unless Rarity decided to get a bit of training to impress some prince or something...

Edited December 22, 2013 by FNGRpony

[Malinter 3,064]

Trixie would have to mature a lot and learn a lot of humility before that could ever happen

 

Twilight is a princess now, I'd DARE Trixie to try and be like she was before in her presence. If fact I can almost imagine Twilight asking why is she acting so wierd.

[FNGRpony 658]

Twilight is a princess now, I'd DARE Trixie to try and be like she was before in her presence. If fact I can almost imagine Twilight asking why is she acting so wierd.

honestly i think it would annoy twilight if trixie treated her better just for being a princess.

 

Hum, trixie might even do it if she figured that out lol.