Amnesia not scary? Let me guide you through the wonderful world of custom-made stories. I still stand with Amnesia being one of my most loved games. I don't regret anything about it. Althought the main story isn't scary, i have to agree on you with that.
But the custom stories? Man, i should of made a collab showing all the times i went flying backwards into my chair whilst playing them. .
But fix the hiding, you can crouch in a dark corner, face the wall, and put off your lantern. Makes it so pretty much neither a Gatherer or Brute even notices you, they can even bump into you and they won't notice.
But still, my undying love for Amnesia has Always been there, i'm a big fan of it. Can't wait!